Enhancing mindfulness and compassion through an ayahuasca-inspired formulation containing N,N-DMT and harmine: A randomized controlled trial in healthy subjects
In a randomised, double‑blind, placebo‑controlled within‑subjects trial in 31 healthy volunteers, an ayahuasca‑inspired N,N‑DMT plus harmine formulation produced acute increases in mindfulness and both self‑ and other‑directed compassion one day after dosing compared with harmine or placebo, with larger effects in high‑sensitivity individuals. These findings suggest the formulation may have therapeutic potential similar to traditional ayahuasca and warrant further clinical investigation.
Authors
- Milan Scheidegger
Published
Abstract
Background: Mindfulness and compassion are therapeutically relevant and can be increased through different forms of meditation practices. However, meditation practice needs time and commitment. These resources are often limited in patients with mood disorders. Therefore, efficacious remedies that increase mindfulness and compassion could provide therapeutic options. This study aimed to investigate the relationship between psychedelic experiences induced by an ayahuasca-inspired N,N-dimethyltryptamine (DMT)/harmine formulation on mindfulness and compassion in healthy subjects. Methods: This study applies a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled within-subjects design in a laboratory setting with 31 healthy participants. Each subject received a formulation comprising DMT + harmine, harmine + placebo, and placebo only on three different study days. Primary outcomes were mindfulness (MINDSENS) and compassion (SOCS). Results: A significant effect of the drug on mindfulness ( p < 0.05, F = 3.41), self-compassion (SOCS-S; p < 0.01, F = 7.53), and compassion with others (SOCS-O; p < 0.05, F = 3.37) 1 day post-treatment was found. Significant differences between the high- and low-sensitivity groups were found for mindfulness ( p < 0.05, F = 6.54), self-compassion ( p < 0.05, F = 4.21), and compassion with others ( p < 0.05, F = 4.42). Conclusions: In line with previous studies on traditional botanical ayahuasca, our findings support the notion that the DMT/harmine formulation might have therapeutic potential through its ability to acutely enhance mindfulness and compassion. Continuing studies in therapeutic settings are needed to further elucidate the mechanisms of action of ayahuasca-inspired formulations.
Research Summary of 'Enhancing mindfulness and compassion through an ayahuasca-inspired formulation containing N,N-DMT and harmine: A randomized controlled trial in healthy subjects'
Introduction
Aicher and colleagues frame the study against evidence that mindfulness and compassion training improve psychological well-being but require time and practice that some patients with mood disorders cannot sustain. Previous studies report that serotonergic psychedelics and traditional ayahuasca can rapidly improve mood and increase mindfulness-related capacities and prosocial behaviour; however, the mechanisms by which ayahuasca's principal components—N,N-dimethyltryptamine (DMT) together with MAO-A inhibiting beta-carbolines such as harmine—affect mindfulness and compassion remain unclear. This randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled within-subject trial tested whether an ayahuasca-inspired formulation combining intranasal DMT with sublingual/orodispersible harmine (DMT/HAR) acutely increases mindfulness (MINDSENS Composite Index, MCI) and compassion (Self and Others Compassion Scales, SOCS-S and SOCS-O) in healthy volunteers, compared with harmine alone (HAR) and placebo (PLA). The authors hypothesised greater increases in mindfulness and compassion after DMT/HAR than after HAR or PLA, and stronger effects in participants classified as high versus low sensitivity to the drug.
Methods
The trial used a within-subjects, double-blind, randomised, placebo-controlled design. Thirty-one healthy male participants completed three experimental sessions, each separated in time, in which they received in counterbalanced order: (1) DMT + harmine (DMT/HAR), (2) harmine + placebo intranasal spray (HAR), and (3) placebo + placebo (PLA). Six additional recruits dropped out and were replaced so that 31 participants (mean age 25.39 ± 4.21 years) completed all three arms. Inclusion criteria included age 20–40, BMI 18.5–30, male sex, absence of current or past somatic, neurological or psychiatric disorder, no family history of psychosis or bipolar disorder, no interacting medication, and no current or regular drug use; participants provided written informed consent and received monetary compensation. Interventions were designed to mimic key pharmacology of ayahuasca while avoiding oral administration. Harmine HCl was administered as a 100 mg orodispersible tablet for buccal delivery, 30 minutes before the intranasal dosing sequence. DMT was delivered as an intranasal spray in incremental doses totalling 100 mg across 10 administrations (10 mg every 15 minutes over 150 minutes). Matching placebos with comparable texture/taste were used. The setting was a single-participant, soundproof, temperature-controlled laboratory room with a relaxed living-room ambience and standardised background music; a medically trained experimenter supervised each session. Participants could skip individual DMT doses for tolerability; this occurred twice across the study. Primary outcome measures were the MINDSENS Composite Index (MCI; derived from selected items of the FFMQ and the Experiences Questionnaire) assessing mindfulness subdomains (observing, non-reacting, decentering), and the Sussex-Oxford Compassion Scales for others (SOCS-O) and self (SOCS-S). Assessments occurred at baseline, 24 hours post-experience, and at 1- and 4-month follow-ups. For analysis, the investigators used (generalized) linear mixed-effects models estimated by REML via the lme4 package in R. Participants were dichotomised into high- versus low-sensitivity groups by a median split on maximum subjective intensity ratings in the DMT/HAR condition. Fixed effects included drug condition (DMT/HAR, HAR, PLA), sensitivity group, and their interaction; models were fit on standardized data to yield standardized parameters. Type III repeated-measures ANOVA tables with Satterthwaite or Kenward-Roger degrees of freedom were used to test effects, post hoc contrasts were computed with the emmeans package, significance was set at 0.05, and p-values were corrected for multiple comparisons using the Benjamini-Hochberg method.
Results
Sample flow and tolerability: Thirty-one male participants completed all three conditions; six recruits initially enrolled dropped out and were replaced. Only a few and small side effects were reported, and two dose skips occurred. The extracted text does not provide a detailed adverse-event table or physiological safety data within this section. MINDSENS Composite Index (MCI): The mixed model showed substantial total explanatory power (conditional R2 = 0.86) and a fixed-effects contribution (marginal R2 = 0.19). There were significant main effects of drug (F(2,56.19) = 3.41, p = 0.04) and sensitivity (F(1,29.08) = 6.54, p = 0.016), plus a significant drug × sensitivity interaction (F(2,56.19) = 7.87, p < 0.001). Post hoc contrasts indicated higher MCI after DMT/HAR versus placebo (mean difference = 0.14, SE = 0.05, df = 56.1, t = 2.58, p = 0.04). No significant difference emerged between DMT/HAR and HAR (p = 0.17) or between HAR and PLA (p = 0.35) in the pooled sample. When stratified by sensitivity, the high-sensitivity subgroup showed pronounced increases: DMT/HAR exceeded HAR (Mdiff = 0.28, SE = 0.07, p < 0.001) and PLA (Mdiff = 0.31, SE = 0.07, p < 0.001), whereas the low-sensitivity subgroup showed no significant condition differences. Self-compassion (SOCS-S): The model had conditional R2 = 0.90 and marginal R2 = 0.14. There were significant effects of drug (F(2,56.04) = 7.53, p = 0.001), sensitivity (F(1,28.96) = 4.21, p = 0.05), and their interaction (F(2,56.04) = 4.58, p = 0.014). Post hoc tests demonstrated that both DMT/HAR (Mdiff = 2.83, SE = 0.84, p < 0.01) and HAR (Mdiff = 2.82, SE = 0.85, p < 0.01) produced higher SOCS-S scores than PLA, with no significant difference between DMT/HAR and HAR (p = 0.99) in the overall sample. In the high-sensitivity group, DMT/HAR and HAR each exceeded PLA (DMT/HAR vs PLA: Mdiff = 5.19, SE = 1.18, p < 0.001; HAR vs PLA: Mdiff = 3.26, SE = 1.18, p = 0.01), while the low-sensitivity group showed no significant contrasts. Compassion for others (SOCS-O): The model yielded conditional R2 = 0.88 and marginal R2 = 0.13, with a main effect of drug (F(2,56.14) = 3.37, p = 0.042) and sensitivity (F(1,29.05) = 4.42, p = 0.04); the drug × sensitivity interaction was not significant (p = 0.20). Overall, DMT/HAR was higher than PLA (Mdiff = 2.28, SE = 0.88, p = 0.04). In subgroup analyses, the high-sensitivity group reported greater SOCS-O after DMT/HAR than after PLA (Mdiff = 3.69, SE = 1.24, p = 0.01); low-sensitivity participants again showed no significant condition differences. Subscale findings and temporal pattern: Across mindfulness subscales, non-reacting showed a strong drug effect, while observing and decentering increased in the high-sensitivity group. For SOCS subscales, recognizing suffering and feeling for the person suffering increased for SOCS-O in the high-sensitivity group; for SOCS-S the recognizing suffering subscale increased. Notably, self-compassion rose after both HAR and DMT/HAR, consistent with a nonspecific serotonergic contribution of harmine. No sustained effects were detected at the 1-month and 4-month follow-ups according to the extracted text.
Discussion
Aicher and colleagues interpret the findings as evidence that an ayahuasca-inspired DMT/harmine formulation can elicit acute increases in measures of mindfulness and compassion in healthy volunteers tested in a controlled laboratory setting. The investigators note that the observed magnitude of change on the MINDSENS index is comparable to effects seen in meditation practitioners for whom the index was developed, suggesting that pharmacological induction of altered states may transiently produce similar capacities such as non-reactivity and decentering without concurrent meditation training. The authors highlight that effects were concentrated in participants classified as high-sensitivity to the DMT/HAR condition; these individuals showed robust increases across mindfulness and compassion measures, whereas low-sensitivity participants did not exhibit condition-dependent changes. Harmine alone produced increases in self-compassion, which the team attributes to nonspecific serotonergic effects of the MAO-A inhibitor. The absence of persistent effects at 1 and 4 months is emphasised, and the authors argue that longer-term stabilisation of mindfulness/compassion likely requires integration or concomitant therapeutic/mindfulness training. The investigators place their results alongside prior ayahuasca and psychedelic research, noting overlap with reports of enhanced empathy, prosociality, and antidepressant effects, while acknowledging that prior naturalistic studies may be confounded by ceremonial or group contexts. They propose that pharmacological formulations such as DMT/HAR may transiently increase openness, acceptance and affiliative attitudes even outside ceremonial settings, which could be therapeutically useful if combined with psychotherapy or compassion-focused interventions. Limitations acknowledged by the authors include the homogeneous sample (male-only, young, highly educated), the laboratory rather than therapeutic setting, moderate dosing chosen to permit concurrent neurobehavioural testing, potential unblinding especially among high-sensitivity participants, and lack of formal assessment of blinding efficacy. The investigators recommend dose–response work, examination of personality moderators such as trait absorption, and trials in clinical populations to determine effective doses and to test whether DMT/HAR–assisted interventions can produce clinically meaningful and durable changes in mindfulness, compassion, and psychiatric outcomes.
View full paper sections
RESULTS
The following questionnaires were applied: The MINDSENS Composite Index (MCI; Soler et al., 2014) consists of 10 items of the Five Facet Mindfulness Questionnaire (FFMQ)and nine items of the Experiences Questionnaire (EQ;. The 19 items of the FFMQ and EQ that discriminated best between daily meditation practitioners and non-meditators were selected for the MINDSENS Composite Index. Examples of the subgroups are as follows: observing "I pay attention to how my emotions affect my thoughts and behavior," non-reacting "When I have distressing thoughts or images, I am able just to notice them without reacting," and decentering "I have the sense that I am fully aware of what is going on around me and inside me." Decentering is defined as the capacity to step outside one's personal perspective The questionnaire consists of a 20-item scale for others (SOCS-O) and a 20-item scale for self (SOCS-S). Scores on both scales show adequate internal consistency, interpretability, floor/ ceiling effects, and convergent and discriminant validity. The items are scored on a 5-point Likert-type scale, ranging from never to all the time. Time points were baseline, 24 h after the experience, 1-month follow-up, and 4-month follow-up.
CONCLUSION
This randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blinded study aimed to evaluate mindfulness-and compassion-related capabilities after the intake of an innovative ayahuasca-inspired formulation (containing DMT and MAO-inhibitor harmine; DMT/HAR) and harmine (HAR) against placebo (PLA) in healthy subjects to explore potential therapeutic change mechanisms. Our findings indicate an acute increase in mindfulness-and compassion-based outcome measures, comparable to changes in meditation practitioners, since the MCI was originally developed to assess the effects of long-term meditation practice. Our study indicates that short-term enhancement in mindfulness abilities can be reached not only by meditation practice, but also by a pharmacological intervention with DMT/HAR in a controlled laboratory setting, even without concomitant mindfulness training. Following our initial hypothesis, we found a significant drug effect with specifically higher mindfulness and compassion scores in DMT/HAR and less pronounced effects in HAR, compared to PLA. Significant effects for HAR could only be found for self-compassion. Participants from the high-sensitivity group were more likely to report differences in mindfulness, self-compassion, and compassion with others when DMT/HAR was compared to HAR or PLA, but not participants from the low-sensitivity group. No lasting effects in the 1-month and 4-month follow-up were found. Regarding the specific mindfulness subscales, decentering and observing abilities were increased in the high-sensitivity group, and a highly significant drug effect was found for nonreacting. Non-reacting describes a state of mind in which one allows thoughts and feelings to come and go without getting caught up in them, which, in turn, is therapeutically valuable. Decentering on the other hand is defined as the capacity to step outside one's personal perspective of a lived experience and to disidentify from the content of thoughtsor in other more specific words it is the capacity to recognize one's thoughts and emotions as temporary events of the mind. This allows patients to consider thoughts and emotions in a detached manner rather than statements that are necessarily true. Hence, increased decentering abilities could explain the therapeutic effect of interventions with psychedelics like ayahuasca in depression, a disorder that is associated with impaired decentering abilities, in other work also called reduced metacognitive awareness. Regarding the SOCS-O (compassion with others) subscales, recognizing suffering and feeling for the person suffering were also significantly increased in the high-sensitivity group. In the SOCS-S (self-compassion) subscales, only the recognizing suffering subscale was significantly increased in the high-sensitivity group. Testing for drug effects, most of the subscales of SOCS-S (four out of five) were significantly increased, which indicates that DMT/HAR has a stronger effect on self-compassion compared to compassion with others and mindfulness. Interestingly, self-compassion increased in both the DMT/HAR and HAR conditions. This finding could be explained via the nonspecific serotonergic stimulation effects that are described for the MAO-A inhibitor harmine. Moderately elevated levels of serotonin in the synaptic cleft may reduce anxiety/stress and promote general feelings of empathy and tenderness toward oneself. Comparable findings of adaptive self-attitudes such as increased emotional empathy and selfcompassion were observed after ingestion of nonspecific serotonergic substances such as MDMA. Cultivating self-compassion brings understanding toward oneself in instances of perceived inadequacy or sufferingand is an important mediator of the positive effects of MBCT interventions on depressive symptoms. Therefore, augmenting CFT with pharmacological interventions that enhance compassion and social connection could be especially suitable for people who have a compromised capacity for experiencing and expressing affiliative motives and emotions, that is, those with high levels of self-criticism and shame. Ayahuasca-inspired formulations might be particularly well suited to support attitudes of openness and acceptance toward physical and mental discomfort by enhancing compassion for self and others, which is a valuable skill set for navigating physical and mental crises and coping with stress in everyday life. It is possible that the sensitivity to the substance and experiential aspects depends on certain predispositions, such as personality traits. For instance, the trait of absorption, which refers to an individual's openness to a variety of cognitive, perceptual, and imagistic experiences, was found to strongly predict several experiences measured in previous studies. Interestingly, trait absorption was not only associated with the ability to reach peak experiences but also found to be elevated in meditation practitioners. Hence, further research examining personality traits and their influence on the ability to reach intense psychedelic experiences and their association with outcome measures, such as mindfulness, is essential. Furthermore, depression or other psychiatric disorders (or also somatic diseases) may impact an individual's sensitivity to both mindfulness-based interventions and the pharmacological treatment with DMT/HAR. Depression and also anti-depressive medication might alter neurobiological mechanisms and increase or decrease sensitivity to the DMT/HAR. Further clinical trials with patients are necessary to explore effective doses for patients with mood disorders or other indications. Based on these doses, further studies should investigate whether patients experience effects on mindfulness, compassion, or other therapy-relevant mechanisms induced by DMT/HAR. In summary, our results provide an explanatory mechanism that could contribute to similar benefits reported in prior studies for ayahuasca in the treatment of addiction and depression. It is worth mentioning that prior studies showing benefits associated with long-term ayahuasca use could be confounded by participants being members of a religious group or taking ayahuasca in a ceremonial context. The present results obtained in a non-ceremonial, controlled laboratory setting, where participants engaged in neurobehavioral tasks, support the notion that ayahuasca-inspired pharmacological formulations, such as those containing DMT and harmine, may transiently increase mindfulness-and compassion-related capabilities independent of context. Despite these significant acute drug effects, we could not find any long-term effects, which may be due to the fact that the study was not embedded in a therapeutic or mindfulness-based setting. Psychedelic-induced states of enhanced mindfulness tend to be short-lived and strongly support the notion of concomitant training and integration to stabilize and maintain more adaptive mental states in everyday life.
Study Details
- Study Typeindividual
- Populationhumans
- Characteristicsre analysisplacebo controlledrandomizedparallel groupdouble blind
- Journal
- Compounds
- Topic
- Author