Autonomic nervous system activity correlates with peak experiences induced by DMT and predicts increases in well-being
Sympathovagal coactivation (joint sympathetic and parasympathetic cardiac influence) during DMT correlated with self‑reported spiritual experience and insightfulness and with improved well‑being two weeks after the session. Pre‑drug sympathovagal balance predicted insightfulness and subsequent coactivation, indicating autonomic nervous system dynamics underlie psychedelic peak experiences and could be harnessed (for example via biofeedback) to enhance psychedelic therapy.
Authors
- Fernando Rosas
Published
Abstract
Background: Non-ordinary states of consciousness induced by psychedelics can be accompanied by so-called “peak experiences,” characterized at the emotional level by their intensity and positive valence. These experiences are strong predictors of positive outcomes following psychedelic-assisted therapy, and it is therefore important to better understand their biology. Despite growing evidence that the autonomic nervous system (ANS) plays an important role in mediating emotional experiences, its involvement in the psychedelic experience is poorly understood. The aim of this study was to investigate to what extent changes in the relative influence of the sympathetic (SNS) and parasympathetic nervous systems (PNS) over cardiac activity may reflect the subjective experience induced by the short-acting psychedelic N,N-Dimethyltryptamine (DMT). Methods: We derived measures of SNS and PNS activity from the electrocardiograms of 17 participants (11 males, mean age = 33.8 years, SD = 8.3) while they received either DMT or placebo. Results: Results show that the joint influence of SNS and PNS (“sympathovagal coactivation”) over cardiac activity was positively related to participants’ ratings of “Spiritual Experience” and “Insightfulness” during the DMT experience, while also being related to improved well-being scores 2 weeks after the session. In addition, we found that the state of balance between the two ANS branches (“sympathovagal balance”) before DMT injection predicted scores of “Insightfulness” during the DMT experience, as well as subsequent sympathovagal coactivation. Conclusion: These findings demonstrate the involvement of the ANS in psychedelic-induced peak experiences and may pave the way to the development of biofeedback-based tools to enhance psychedelic therapy.
Research Summary of 'Autonomic nervous system activity correlates with peak experiences induced by DMT and predicts increases in well-being'
Introduction
Psychedelics produce marked alterations in perception, cognition and emotion, and intensely positive self‑transcendent or 'peak' experiences that occur during psychedelic therapy have been shown in earlier research to predict beneficial mental health outcomes such as reductions in depression, anxiety and substance craving. Despite the clinical relevance of these peak states, the biological mechanisms that produce them remain unclear; work to date has concentrated on central nervous system effects while largely overlooking peripheral bodily systems. The autonomic nervous system (ANS), which comprises sympathetic (SNS) and parasympathetic (PNS) branches and exerts strong influence over cardiac function, is increasingly recognised as important in emotional processing and may be implicated in the affective qualities of psychedelic experiences. Bonnelle and colleagues set out to test whether cardiac indices of SNS and PNS activity relate to subjective peak experiences evoked by the short‑acting psychedelic N,N‑dimethyltryptamine (DMT). Specifically, they hypothesised that (1) individuals who begin the session from a state of greater sympatho‑vagal balance would be more likely to report peak experiences, and (2) peak experiences during DMT would be associated with concurrent sympatho‑vagal coactivation (joint SNS and PNS influence). The study used the brief timecourse of DMT to link minute‑by‑minute autonomic measures with self‑reported phenomenology and subsequent changes in wellbeing.
Methods
The study was a single‑blinded, placebo‑controlled experimental trial in healthy volunteers. Participants underwent continuous simultaneous fMRI‑EEG resting‑state scanning for 28 minutes, with DMT or placebo administered at the end of the eighth minute; they lay with eyes closed and ECG was recorded throughout. After scanning, participants completed retrospective questionnaires indexing altered states (the 11‑Dimension Altered States of Consciousness questionnaire, ASC‑11D, and the Mystical Experience Questionnaire, MEQ‑30) and a wellbeing measure (WHO‑5) at baseline and two weeks post‑session. A second session with in‑scanner verbal intensity ratings is noted in the protocol, but the present report concerns ECG data from the uninterrupted resting‑state scans. Twenty participants with prior psychedelic experience completed visits, but only 17 (11 males; mean age 33.8 y, SD 8.3) provided ECG recordings with <10% noisy segments and were included. ECG was recorded with two electrodes and an MR‑compatible amplifier at 5 kHz with a 250 Hz hardware low‑pass filter. Recordings lasted 28 minutes (8 minutes baseline, 20 minutes post‑injection). Preprocessing involved demean and 1–30 Hz bandpass filtering, automatic R‑peak detection in Kubios followed by manual inspection and correction; datasets with >10% noisy segments were discarded. Autonomic indices were computed in Kubios from overlapping 180 s RR‑interval windows updated every 20 s. A composite SNS index used mean heart rate, Baevsky's stress index and the Poincaré plot SD2; a PNS index used mean RR interval, RMSSD and Poincaré SD1. Sympatho‑vagal balance was indexed by SD1/SD2 from the Poincaré plot, and sympatho‑vagal coactivation was operationalised as the product of the SNS and PNS indexes (SNSxPNS), transformed into strictly positive values. The authors focused analyses on a post‑onset 'core' window (minutes 11–25, i.e. ~3 minutes after injection onward) and a baseline window (minutes 3–7 of the recording), reflecting the timing of autonomic and subjective effects. Statistical analyses visualised timecourses averaged across participants and used paired t‑tests to compare DMT and placebo at each timepoint. After checking normality, Spearman correlations assessed relations between ANS measures and ASC‑11D subscales; significance was set at p < .05 two‑sided, with Bonferroni correction applied for correlations that were not predicted. Minute‑by‑minute correlations between ANS indexes and subjective ratings were also computed to localise effects in time. For longer‑term wellbeing analyses, participants were split by median change in WHO‑5 from baseline to two‑week follow‑up and SNSxPNS during the core experience was compared between groups via independent t‑test. Where procedural details (for example DMT dose) were relevant but not provided in the extracted text, the extraction does not clearly report them.
Results
Timecourse of autonomic activity: SNS and PNS indexes were plotted across the 8 minute baseline and 20 minute post‑injection periods and compared between DMT and placebo. SNS increased and PNS decreased significantly in the DMT condition relative to placebo from the time of injection. SNS remained significantly higher than placebo for 11 minutes post‑injection, while PNS remained significantly lower for 8 minutes. Primary associations with subjective peak experiences: The sympatho‑vagal coactivation index (SNSxPNS) computed during the core DMT experience correlated strongly with two ASC‑11D subscales linked to peak experiences. Specifically, SNSxPNS correlated with Spiritual Experience (n=17, Spearman r = .625, p = 0.007, uncorrected) and with Insightfulness (n=17, r = .692, p = 0.002, uncorrected). These relations were highlighted as central findings. SNS and PNS separately: During the core experience, SNS activity showed positive correlations with Experience of Unity (n=17, r = .517, p = 0.034) and Elementary Imagery (n=17, r = .528, p = 0.035), and negative correlations with Impaired Control and Cognition (r = −.590, p = 0.013) and Anxiety (r = −.514, p = 0.034). The authors note that these latter relations were not explicitly predicted and did not survive correction for multiple comparisons. PNS showed generally weaker and often inverse relationships compared with SNS. Temporal specificity (minute‑by‑minute): Minute‑by‑minute correlations revealed that SNS was positively associated with Experience of Unity from approximately minutes 2–17 post‑injection and with Elementary Imagery from minutes 1–17. SNS was negatively associated with Impaired Cognition from minutes 2–15 and with Anxiety from minutes 4–10. PNS exhibited weaker, often opposite trends, with negative correlations with Experience of Unity appearing around minutes 15–17 and positive correlations with Anxiety around minutes 5–8. The SNSxPNS index correlated significantly with Spiritual Experience between minutes 4–13 post‑injection, and with Insightfulness both at a pre‑injection baseline window (minutes −5 to −3, peaking at −3) and later around minutes 12–13 (peaking at minute 13). Baseline sympatho‑vagal balance predicts peak quality: Baseline SD1/SD2 (Poincaré‑derived sympatho‑vagal balance) related to Spiritual Experience (n=17, r = .555, p = 0.021) and showed a marginal relationship with Insightfulness (r = .413, p = 0.099). Individuals with baseline SD1/SD2 closer to 1 (interpreted as a more balanced ANS) scored higher on Spiritual Experience. Baseline SNS and PNS indexes alone did not predict subjective ratings. Relation to wellbeing two weeks later: Wellbeing (WHO‑5) change scores were available for 16 participants and a median split produced two groups (Group 1: no change or reduction in wellbeing, n=8, mean change −1.50 ± 1.6; Group 2: improved wellbeing, n=8, mean change 1.62 ± 0.91). Group 2 reported higher Blissful Experience than Group 1 (t = 2.7, df = 14, p = 0.017). Importantly, during the core experience Group 2 showed higher SNSxPNS coactivation than Group 1 (t = 2.32, df = 14, p = 0.036), whereas SNS and PNS alone did not differ between groups.
Discussion
Bonnelle and colleagues interpret their results as evidence that both sympathetic and parasympathetic branches of the ANS are involved in key elements of psychedelic‑induced peak experiences, particularly Spiritual Experience and Insightfulness. The sympatho‑vagal coactivation index (SNSxPNS) during the DMT session was a stronger predictor of subsequent improvements in wellbeing than retrospective subjective reports alone. Contrary to the authors' expectation that negatively valenced experiences would be linked to parasympathetic withdrawal, negative elements were instead associated with reduced SNS engagement during the core experience. The discussion situates these findings relative to limited prior work on psychedelics and cardiac autonomic activity, noting methodological gaps in earlier studies (for example sparse HRV sampling and lack of baseline measures). The authors propose that sympatho‑vagal coactivation may index a physiological state conducive to peak experiences and suggest potential translational applications, including biofeedback or behavioural techniques (for instance breathing practices) to steer the ANS toward favourable states prior to or during psychedelic‑assisted therapy. They also link the baseline balance finding to contemplative practices, suggesting that training which increases sympatho‑vagal balance might prepare individuals for deeper experiences. Caveats and future directions acknowledged by the investigators include ambiguity about causality between ANS and central nervous system changes — it remains unclear whether ANS changes drive phenomenology or follow central processes — and the need to compare ANS timecourses with EEG or fMRI to address this. They further recommend complementing cardiac measures with other autonomic indices such as electrodermal activity, pupillometry or piloerection. The authors caution that sympatho‑vagal coactivation is not specific to positive peak experiences and can occur in other states (for example freezing or certain panic presentations); they note theories that subdivide parasympathetic function (ventral versus dorsal branches) as a possible explanatory nuance. Overall, the researchers conclude that DMT produced a pronounced sympathetic activation that paralleled subjective intensity and that both the initial physiological stress response and the subsequent balance between stress and recovery are important components of peak experiences and improved wellbeing; they propose further work to validate physiological markers of 'readiness' and to test whether these findings generalise to other psychedelics and non‑drug altered states of consciousness.
View full paper sections
SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT
Psychedelics can give rise to intense positive subjective experiences -aligned with Maslow's notion of 'peak experiences' -that can have a positive and enduring impact on mental health. Understanding how these experiences relate to peripheral physiology before and during the acute effects of psychedelics is an important object of enquiry, as it may help advance the therapeutic use of these compounds. In this study, we demonstrate that specific peripheral states computed from heart rate activity recordings predicted and correlated with acute peak experiences and increases in wellbeing. These findings have implications for the relationship between peripheral physiology and altered states of consciousness. Moreover, they highlight a putative marker of physiological 'readiness' prior the psychedelic experience that could predict therapeutically relevant mechanisms that might be modified to improve mental health outcomes in psychedelic-therapy.
INTRODUCTION
Psychedelics induce significant alterations in perceptual, cognitive, and emotional processing and in scientific studies can act as tools of perturbation for human consciousness. Evidence suggests that intense positively valanced self-transcendent experiences (also called 'peak experiences') occurring during psychedelic therapy significantly predict positive mental health outcomes, such as reductions in depression and anxiety, as well as reduced craving in substance abuse disorders. Despite the important therapeutic relevance of these experiences, the mechanisms leading to these states remains unclear. In addition, even though great care may be taken to optimize psychedelic therapy to facilitate these experiences, attempting to predict the affective features of a psychedelic experience is still challenging. Contemporary research has largely focused on the effects of psychedelics on the central nervous system, ignoring other biological mechanisms potentially involved in the emotional states induced by these substances. Yet, brain and body are undeniably intrinsically and dynamically linked; perceptions, emotions, and cognitions not only influence, but also respond to the state of the body, as intuited by William James over a century agoand emphasized by the embodied approach to cognitive neuroscience. The importance played by the Autonomic Nervous System (ANS) -particularly at the cardiac level -in emotional experiences and affective states is becoming increasingly recognized. Although the centrality and specificity of the autonomic response is still subject to debate, recent work importantly demonstrated that cardiac sympatho-vagal activity may initiate emotional responses preceding neural dynamics. To what extent, then, are the intense emotional experiences fostered by psychedelics mediated by their impact on ANS activity and heart function? The ANS has two main branches: the sympathetic nervous system (SNS) and the parasympathetic nervous system (PNS). The SNS is involved in priming the body and brain for action, triggering a series of physiological changes that are part of the stress response ("fight-or-flight"). The SNS has generally been proposed to be involved in emotional arousal, when it is experienced with positive (e.g., joy, excitement) or negative (e.g., anxiety, hyper-arousal) valence. Classic psychedelics (e.g., LSD, psilocybin, mescaline, and DMT) are serotonin-2A (5-HT2A) receptor agonists and exert effects consistent with activation of the SNS, particularly pupillary dilation, increases in heart rate and blood pressure, and increases in plasma stress hormones cortisol and epinephrine. The PNS on the other hand, is involved in rest and recovery after periods of stress, energy conservation/storage and regulation of bodily functions. While parasympathetic activity has often been found to be associated with positive and pro-social emotions, the relation between emotional valence and PNS is not straightforward. The PNS does not appear to be directly activated by classic psychedelics. Rather, serotonin 2A receptors antagonist ketanserin, known to reduce or even prevent psychoactive effects when administered simultaneously with a classic psychedelic, has been found to cause an increase in parasympathetic activity. The PNS might however become active throughout the experience as a homeostatic response to the initial stress response induced by psychedelics, a mechanism known as 'vagal rebound'. A commonly held view is that the sympathetic and parasympathetic branches of the ANS are subject to reciprocal central control, with increasing activity of one branch associated with decreasing activity of the other. However, it has now been established that autonomic control of dually innervated target organs, such as the heart, cannot adequately be viewed as a continuum extending from parasympathetic to sympathetic dominance. Rather, the two autonomic branches can vary reciprocally, independently, or coactively. We refer to this joint influence as 'sympatho-vagal coactivation'. Intensely pleasurable experiences are often associated with autonomic manifestations (e.g., 'chills'), which are accompanied by physiological markers of arousal such as increase heart rate. On the other hand, contemplative experiences (e.g., mindfulness meditation), which can also lead to peak experiences, are typically associated with increased parasympathetic activity. However, to our knowledge, the interplay between autonomic activity and peak experiences -which share some characteristics of the two types of experiences mentioned above -has never been investigated. Furthermore, if we consider sympathetic tone as reflecting our ability to respond to stress (and/or salience), and parasympathetic tone as our ability to regulate and restore homeostasis after a stress response, it then becomes apparent that a state of balance between the two branches (sympatho-vagal balance), might be beneficial for adaptation, resilience to stress, and emotional flexibility. These attributes may play a crucial role in navigating the often challenging emotional states induced by psychedelics. N,N-dimethyltryptamine (DMT), a short-acting serotonergic psychedelic with therapeutic potentialoffers a unique opportunity to investigate shifts in autonomic activity and their relation to the psychedelic experience as its short duration of action (~12 minutes) allows drawing more accurate relationships between subjective reports of acute effects, physiological measures, and mental health outcomes. Crucially, it also provides an optimal opportunity to assess how these dynamics relate to peak experiences, and changes in wellbeing. Here, our primary aim was to investigate the complete profiles of SNS and PNS fluctuations throughout the DMT experience, and to evaluate to what extent these profiles may reflect participants' subjective experience. We hypothesized that 1) starting the experience from a state of greater sympatho-vagal balance may be conducive of peak experiences, and that 2) peak experiences may be associated with sympatho-vagal coactivation (Figure).
PARTICIPANTS AND EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES
The study was designed as a single-blinded placebo-controlled trial in healthy participants. Experimental sessions consisted of continuous and simultaneous fMRI-EEG resting-state scans which lasted 28 min, with DMT or placebo administered at the end of the 8th min. Participants laid in the scanner with their eyes closed (an eye mask was used to prevent eyes opening), while brain activity and electrocardiograms (ECG) were recorded. Following the scanning procedure, participants were interviewed and completed questionnaires designed to assess the subjective effects experienced during the scan [Visual Analog Scales and validated scales: 11 Dimensions Altered States of Consciousness Questionnaire-ASC-11Dand the Mystical Experience Questionnaire-MEQ-30]. A second session then followed with the same procedure as the initial session, except on this occasion, participants were (audio) cued to verbally rate the subjective intensity of drug effects every minute in real time while in the scanner (Figure). This article reports the results concerning the ECG data collected during resting-state scans where participants received either DMT or a placebo, and were not interrupted for experience sampling purposes. In total, 20 participants with previous experience with psychedelics completed all study visits, but only 17 (11 males, mean age = 33.8 y, SD = 8.3) had reliable ECG data (i.e., less than 10% noisy segments). Further details about the experimental procedure and participants can be found in Timmermann et al. (2023). This study was approved by the National Research Ethics Committee London-Brent and the Health Research Authority and was conducted under the guidelines of the revised Declaration of Helsinki (2000), the International Committee on Harmonization Good Clinical Practices guidelines, and the National Health Service Research Governance Framework. Imperial College London sponsored the research, which was conducted under a Home Office license for research with Schedule 1 drugs.
SUBJECTIVE RATINGS
Participants rated their subjective experience at the end of their DMT or placebo session, using the 11 Dimensions Altered States of Consciousness Questionnaire-ASC-11D. Among the 11 subscales of the ASC-11D, our analysis focused on those most relevant to evaluate the positive characteristics of peak experiences -Experience of Unity, Spiritual Experience, Blissful State, Insightfulness -and the elements of the experience that carry a negative valence -Impaired Control and Cognition and Anxiety. We also reported the results for the five other subscales (Disembodiment, Complex Imagery, Elementary imagery, Synaesthesia and Meaning) in order to control for the specificity of the effects observed, but did not take these into account in our multiple comparisons corrections. Participants also completed the Well-being index (WHO-5) questionnaire at baseline and two weeks after their experience.
DATA COLLECTION
ECG data was collected using two electrodes. One was placed in participants' backs (behind the chest area), and the other was placed above the heart area. The data was recorded with an MR-compatible BrainAmp MR amplifier (BrainProducts GmbH, Munich, Germany). The data was recorded with a sampling rate was 5 kHz, and with a hardware 250 Hz low-pass filter. Recordings lasted 28 min, with 8 min of baseline and 20 min post injection.
PRE-PROCESSING
ECG data was demeaned and band-passed filtered at 1-30 Hz. It was then exported in text format to Kubios Scientific software. Automatic R-peak detection was applied, and all identified R-peaks were again manually inspected. Where necessary, R-peaks were corrected manually. Data sets with >10% of noisy segments (i.e. without the possibility of reliable R-peak detection due to artifacts) were discarded from further analysis. Three participants for the DMT session and four participants -same three plus another -for the placebo session were discarded due to this procedure.
MEASURES OF ANS ACTIVITY
A similar procedure to that used in Olbrich et al. was used, whereby indexes of sympathetic (SNS) and parasympathetic (PNS) activity were computed in Kubiosbased on 180s RR-intervals data, updated every 20s. To evaluate the relationship between ANS measures and subjective ratings during the core experience, we focused on the window following the initial stress response (or the 'onset'), when SNS activity is beginning to reduce (3 minutes post injection, at minute 11, Figure), and during which subjective intensity ratings are significantly superior to that of placebo (up to minute 25, Table). For the correlation analyses relating to specific periods (i.e. baseline or core experiences), the indexes were computed based on the corresponding section of RR interval data (3 to 7 min for baseline, 11 to 25 min for core experience, see Figure).
MEASURE OF SYMPATHETIC ACTIVITY
A Sympathetic Nervous System (SNS) index was calculated in Kubios using mean HR (higher heart rate is linked to higher sympathetic cardiac activation), Baevsky's stress index (a geometric measure of HRV reflecting cardiovascular system stress, and sympathetic cardiac activation) and standard deviation along the line of identity of the R-R Pointcaré plot (SD2, see below).
MEASURE OF PARASYMPATHETIC ACTIVITY
A Parasympathetic Nervous System (PNS) index was calculated in Kubios based on mean R-peak intervals (RR) (longer mean RR interval means lower heart rate and higher parasympathetic cardiac activation), the root mean square of the successive differences (RMSSD) -which is a commonly used time-domain HRV parameter that captures the quick beat-to-beat changes in RR interval, and therefore, strongly linked to respiratory sinus arrhythmia, a well-known measure of parasympathetic activity -and Poincaré plot index SD1.
MEASURES OF SYMPATHO-VAGAL BALANCE
Given the controversy around the validity of the ratio of low frequency (LF) to high frequency power (HF) -computed from Fast Fourier Transformation of R-R peaks time series -as an index of sympatho-vagal balance, we used a measure derived from the PoinCarré plot of R-R intervals that has been proposed as an index of sympatho-vagal balance. The Poincaré plot is a scatter plot of RRn vs. RRn+1 where RRn is the time between two successive R peaks and RRn+1 is the time between the next two successive R peaks. When the plot is adjusted by the ellipse-fitting technique, the analysis provides three indices: the standard deviation of instantaneous beat-to-beat interval variability (SD1), the continuous long-term R/R interval variability (SD2), and the SD1/SD2 ratio (SD12). SD1 indicates the dispersion along the minor axis of the Poincaré plot's fitted ellipse. It reflects short-term HRV (instantaneous beat-to-beat variability) and correlates with baroreflex sensitivity and is therefore mainly influenced by parasympathetic modulation. SD2 indicates the dispersion along the major axis of the Poincaré plot's fitted ellipse and reflects long-term RR interval fluctuations. SD2 increases suggests activation of both parasympathetic and sympathetic nervous system. SD1/SD2, which measures the unpredictability of the RR time series, is used to measure autonomic balance.
MEASURE OF SYMPATHOVAGAL COACTIVATION
As we hypothesized that peak experiences would be associated with a state of co-activation of PNS and SNS, we computed a PNS and SNS interaction index based on the product of the two measures, previously translated into a range of strictly positive values. A higher SNSxPNS index indicates more co-activation of the two ANS branches.
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
To visualize the time course of SNS and PNS activity during the DMT and placebo sessions, the indexes for each time-points were averaged across participants. Paired samples t-tests were used to identify the time points where SNS and PNS indexes were significantly different between the DMT and placebo sessions (Table). After checking for the normality of each measure, Spearman correlations were used to assess the relationship between ANS activity and subjective experience, as measured using the ASC-11D questionnaire (Table). All significance levels were set to p < .05 (twosided). Tables and figures show uncorrected statistics. Bonferroni corrections were only used for the correlations that were not predicted and are reported when relevant in the results section. Correlations between minute-by-minute ANS indexes and subjective ratings were also performed to identify the phases of the experience during which the relation between ANS and subjective experience were strongest. Spearman coefficients for each of the correlations were then plotted for ease of visualization. Only subscales that showed at least one significant correlation with one of the ANS measures were plotted (Figure). Finally, participants were split into two groups based on the change in wellbeing reports from baseline to follow-up assessment at two weeks (WHO-5), using a median split. This procedure was used to account for participants inter-individual variabilities in estimating and reporting their wellbeing. Wellbeing data was missing for one participant. SNSxPNS scores during the core experience were compared between the two groups using an independent t-test.
EFFECT OF DMT VS PLACEBO ON SNS AND PNS ACTIVITY PROFILES
The time courses of SNS and PNS activity, which were derived from ECG data collected during an 8 min baseline period and for 20 min post-DMT/placebo injection (see Methods) were averaged across participants during the DMT and the placebo session and plotted on Figure, along with during-experience subjective intensity ratings. SNS activity increased, and PNS activity decreased significantly in the DMT condition compared with placebo from the time of injection. SNS remained significantly higher in the DMT condition compared to placebo for 11 min post injection, and PNS remained significantly lower for 8 minutes (see Table).
ASSOCIATION BETWEEN ANS SCORES AND SUBJECTIVE EXPERIENCE RATINGS
To the extent of our knowledge, there is no established index of sympatho-vagal coactivation. We therefore computed a new measure based on the product of the SNS and PNS indexes calculated in Kubios software based on ECG data during the core DMT experience (i.e. post-ascent or 'core' phase, after the initial physiological stress response) (see Methods). Importantly, and in keeping with our hypothesis, the SNS and PNS coactivation index, which we predicted would reflect both the quality and intensity of peak experiences, was positively and robustly correlated with Spiritual Experience (n=17, r=.625, p=0.007, uncorrected) and Insightfulness (n=17, r=.692, p=0.002, uncorrected) (Table), two important indicators of peak experiences. SNS and PNS activity during the core experience showed some correlations with subjective ratings on the ASC-11D subscale. Spearman correlation coefficients are reported in Table. SNS activity during the core experience correlated positively with Experience of Unity (n=17, r=.517, p=0.034), and Elementary imagery (n=17, r=.528, p=0.035), and negatively with the two subscales of the ASC-11D of negative valence, Impaired control and cognition (r=-.590, p=0.013), and Anxiety (r=-.514, p=0.034), but these relations, which were not explicitly predicted, did not survive correction for multiple comparisons. To get a more detailed view of which phases of the experience showed the strongest correlations between subjective ratings and ANS measures, Spearman correlations were also performed between the 11 subscales of the ASC-11D and minute-by-minute fluctuations of SNS and PNS indexes, calculated based on 180s RR-intervals data (Figure, Tables). SNS was positively correlated with the Experience of Unity ratings from minute 2 to minute 17 post-injection and with Elementary Imagery from minute 1 to minute 17 post-injection. SNS was negatively correlated with Impaired Cognition from minute 2 to 15 post-injection and with Anxiety from minute 4 to 10 post-injection (Figure, Table). PNS showed an inverted and weaker trend compared to SNS, with negative correlations with Experience of Unity from minute 15 to 17 and with Elementary Imagery, and positive correlations with Anxiety from minute 5 to 8 post-injection (Figure, Table). Importantly, SNS x PNS was significantly and positively correlated with Spiritual Experience from minute 4 to 13 post-injection, and with Insightfulness, with correlations starting at baseline (minutes -5 to -3, maximum at minute -3), and resurfacing later in the experience at minutes 12 and 13 (maximum at minute 13) (Figure, Table).
EFFECT OF AUTONOMIC BALANCE ON THE QUALITY OF THE PEAK EXPERIENCE
We hypothesized that peak experiences would be facilitated when the two branches of the ANS are well balanced at baseline. We therefore investigated the impact of autonomic balance at baseline on subjective ratings relevant to the peak experience and anxiogenic experience, using an established index of sympatho-vagal balance derived from the Poincaré plot of the R-R intervals, SD1/SD2. SD1/SD2 at baseline significantly related to Spiritual Experience ratings (n=17, r=.555, p=0.021), and related marginally to Insightfulness (n=17, r=.413, p=0.099), but not to any other ratings (Table). Individuals who entered the DMT experience with a SD1/SD2 score closer to 1 (i.e., with a more balanced ANS), scored higher on the Spiritual Experience subscale of the ASC-11D (Figure). SNS and PNS indexes at baseline did not correlate with any elements of the subjective experience.
CHANGES IN ANS DURING THE EXPERIENCE ARE RELATED TO LONG-TERM CHANGES IN WELLBEING.
Participants were split in two groups based on whether they had reported an improvement in their wellbeing in the two weeks following their DMT experience. Group 1 reported no change or a reduction in wellbeing (n=8, mean change in WHO-5 from baseline: -1.50 ± 1.6 SD). Group 2 reported improved wellbeing compared with baseline (n=8, mean change in WHO-5 from baseline: 1.62 ± 0.91). In terms of quality of the DMT experience, Group 2 showed significantly higher ratings of Blissful Experience compared to Group 1 (t=2.7, df=14, p=0.017), with no other significant differences for the other subscales. Importantly, when comparing ANS activity during the core experience, Group 2 showed a higher SNS x PNS coactivation index during the core experience compared with Group 1 (t=2.32, df=14, p=0.036), but no significant difference in SNS or PNS activity alone.
DISCUSSION
The aim of this study was to explore whether, and to what extent, changes in autonomic function during DMT administration related to the content of subjective experiences -as well as later changes in wellbeing. Our hypotheses were that positively experienced peak states would be associated with the coactivation of sympathetic and parasympathetic systems, while negatively valenced experiences would be associated with parasympathetic withdrawal. We also hypothesized that entering the experience in a state of greater sympatho-vagal balance would be conducive of peak experiences. While our results confirmed the involvement of both branches of the ANS in specific aspects of the peak experience, notably the Spiritual Experience and Insightfulness, negative experiences did not appear to be associated with PNS withdrawal. Rather, we unexpectedly observed that negative experiences were associated with reduced engagement of the SNS during the core experience. Only one study to-date directly investigated the effect of a psychedelic (LSD) on cardiac sympathetic-vagal activity, based on measures of heart rate variability (HRV). However, in this study, HRV was only measured during two relatively small timewindows, out of many hours of LSD-induced psychedelic experience, making it difficult to interpret their relevance to the overall subjective experience. Furthermore, the absence of baseline HRV measurement prevented the assessment of the relevance of the ANS in predicting the quality of the subsequent psychedelic experience. Another study examined the effects of several psychedelics on HRV, however, this study did not directly examine measures of SNS and PNS and its relationship to subjective effects. The present findings confirmed our hypothesis of the involvement of both PNS and SNS in peak experiences. More specifically, we found these effects to be more pronounced in the Spiritual Experience and Insightfulness subscales, both features of peak states induced by psychedelics. Importantly, sympatho-vagal coactivation during the experience was a better predictor of subsequent improvement in wellbeing than subjective reports. Future work should evaluate whether the present findings are specific to peak experiences induced by DMT or if they can be extended to other psychedelics and non-drug induced NSCs. Such a physiological marker of peak experience would allow the implementation of techniques aimed at guiding individuals undergoing psychedelic-assisted therapy towards favorable physiological states via biofeedback, where behavior (e.g., breathing) is guided by real-time feedback of the ANS. Furthermore, these physiological peak states could serve as objective markers of the quality of the psychedelic experience, which could be particularly valuable given the ineffability inherent to peak experiences. It is important to note that, although the present results confirm our hypothesis that sympatho-vagal coactivation is an optimal physiological state for the occurrence of psychedelic-induced peak experience, SNS and PNS can also coactivate under other circumstances that are not related to such experiences, such as the 'freezing' state, or certain forms of panic disorder, whereby increased excitability of both the PNS and SNS, referred to as amphotonia, can occur. Possibly accounting for this apparent discrepancy, according to a popular theory, the PNS may be further divided into two subsystems -a ventral one associated with rest, safety and pro-social behaviors, and a dorsal one associated with immobilization behaviors. The observation that baseline sympatho-vagal balance can predict the intensity of subsequent spiritual experiences is also of interest, as it may provide a physiological marker of 'readiness' to undergo a deeper and more transformative psychedelic experience. It is also consistent with the notion, pursued in some contemplative practices such as Zen Buddhism, that finding the right equilibrium between arousal and rest, tension and relaxation, is key to the meditative practice. If indeed meditation practices allow the cultivation of a more balanced ANS, as suggested in a study that identified increase sympatho-vagal balance after an advanced meditation program, our findings may provide mechanistic evidence for previous observations that contemplative practices may aid in the preparation for psychedelic experiences to foster safety and positive effects. Our findings may thus have translational relevance by suggesting that cardiophysiological state may be a key factor for the success of the clinical use of psychedelics, complementing preliminary findings that psychological preparedness may promote safety and efficacy of psychedelic therapy. Furthermore, our findings are in line with suggestions that a cultivation of optimal psychological and physiological states can improve safety and efficacy of psychedelics and non-ordinary states of consciousness, more broadly. These results warrant further research into the potential to develop markers of 'readiness for acute alterations of consciousness' based on the state of the ANS, which could be used as predictors of peak experiences, and thereby of positive outcomes in psychedelic-assisted therapy. DMT induced a pronounced increase in SNS activity, with a profile that appeared to directly parallel that of subjective intensity ratings (Figure). Though this association could simply relate to greater target receptor engagement by DMT other explanations are possible. Indeed, other forms of non-ordinary states of consciousness (NSCs) are also known to be associated with, and even induced by, states of high arousal. For instance, direct manipulation of the SNS through specific breathing practices (i.e., hyperventilation) can induce NSCs similar to those induced by psychedelics. Noteworthily, neardeath experiences, which share commonalities with DMT experiences, are associated with intense sympathetic activation, due to hypoxia. Unlike the non-specific relations between SNS activity and numerous aspects of the psychedelic experience previously reported with LSD, in this study, we identified a more specific relationship between SNS activity and psychedelic phenomenology, with a positive relationship principally observed for the ASC-11D subscale Experience of Unity. Like the Spiritual Experience and Insightfulness subscales, the Experience of Unity subscale is a feature of psychedelic peak experiences. It comprises several items indicating a disruption to the sense-of-self, including feelings of time and space collapsing and merging with the environment. Notably, states of high arousal induced via other means have also been found to disrupt time and space processing (54) -possibly as a result of a disconnection of the hippocampus with prefrontal areas under stress (55) -which may impact the ability to construct spatially coherent internal scenes and a sense of separate self. Relatedly, the role of endogenous serotonin transmission in non-drug induced NSCs has also been considered and discussed. Although we were able to identify clear relationships between acute changes in ANS and subjective experiences elicited by DMT, the question of whether changes in the ANS are driving or following changes at the level of the central nervous system remains open. This could be addressed in future studies by comparing the time courses of ANS fluctuations with that of brain activity determined via electroencephalography or functional magnetic resonance imaging, in an approach similar to that of Candia-Rivera et al.. While we did not address ANS-CNS causality, we did find a prediction of positive peak experiences via baseline ANS activity, which suggests a causal link from the ANS to phenomenology. Future studies should also aim to complement measures of autonomic activity derived from cardiac activity with other autonomic measures such as electrodermal activity, pupillometry, or piloerection. The present results support the hypothesis that the remarkable psychological effects of psychedelics are not only the result of cortical neuronal mechanisms but involve multiple bodily systems -including the ANS. Specifically, we found that physiological stress response, as well as the balance between physiological stress and relaxation, are key aspects of both peak experiences and improved wellbeing. These findings may help the development of biofeedback techniques to guide the ANS toward states that are conducive to experiences that facilitate better mental health outcomes.
FIGURES AND TABLES
Figure. Proposed model for ANS involvement during the psychedelic experience. The hypothesis proposed here is that peak experiences, which are characterised by their intensity and positive balance, are associated with the dual influence of the sympathetic (red) and parasympathetic branches of the ANS (blue) over cardiac activity. Psychedelics may facilitate the induction of this 'sympatho-vagal coactivation' by triggering an initial stress response associated with strong sympathetic stimulation and moderate parasympathetic withdrawal, followed by a recovery phase largely mediated by parasympathetic activity increase. We further hypothesised that starting the experience from a state of balance between the SNS and PNS (sympatho-vagal balance) may be optimal in order to return to a balanced, but more activated state, after the initial stress response, which we hypothesize to be optimal for peak experiences. Intensity ratings (purple dots), corrected within the same participants but during a distinct DMT session, were averaged across participants and normalized to match the levels of SNS indexes for visualization purpose. Significant differences between DMT and placebo can be found on Table. The line at the bottom illustrates the different phases which were considered for data handling. ECG data used to estimate SNS and PNS was collected during 28 min, with 8 minutes of baseline, followed by DMT/placebo injection. SNS and PNS indexes were computed from 180 s of data, therefore no measures could be computed for the first and last 3 minutes of ECG data. The onset zone, or initial stress response, was defined as the phase during which SNS ascents. Note that for both DMT and placebo, SNS starts increasing before the injection, most likely due to anticipatory processes.
Full Text PDF
Study Details
- Study Typeindividual
- Populationhumans
- Characteristicsre analysissingle blindrandomizedplacebo controlledcrossover
- Journal
- Compound
- Author