Treating Addiction: Perspectives from EEG and Imaging Studies on Psychedelics
This book chapter (2016) reviews the evidence regarding the effects of psychedelics on the brain and their potential as treatments for psychiatric and addictive disorders.
Authors
- Luis Fernando Tófoli
Published
Abstract
Despite reports of apparent benefits, social and political pressure beginning in the late 1960s effectively banned scientific inquiry into psychedelic substances. Covert examination of psychedelics persisted through the 1990s; the turn of the century and especially the past 10 years, however, has seen a resurgent interest in psychedelic substances (eg, LSD, ayahuasca, psilocybin). This chapter outlines relevant EEG and brain imaging studies evaluating the effects of psychedelics on the brain. This chapter also reviews evidence of the use of psychedelics as adjunct therapy for a number of psychiatric and addictive disorders. In particular, psychedelics appear to have efficacy in treating depression and alcohol-use disorders.
Research Summary of 'Treating Addiction: Perspectives from EEG and Imaging Studies on Psychedelics'
Introduction
Classic or serotonergic psychedelics (for example, psilocybin, LSD, mescaline, and the DMT-containing brew ayahuasca) produce profound alterations of perception, cognition and affect and have been used in ritual contexts for centuries. Although the pharmacology of individual compounds varies, these agents commonly act at serotonin 5HT2A receptors and can induce experiences ranging from enhanced imagery and introspection to mystical-type states. Interest in their clinical potential has resurged after decades of restricted research, with accumulating evidence suggesting therapeutic effects in depression and some substance-use disorders. Tófoli and colleagues set out to (1) review EEG, MEG, PET, SPECT and fMRI studies that have investigated the acute brain effects of classic psychedelics in humans, and (2) discuss the emerging evidence for their use as adjunctive treatments for addiction. The chapter emphasises findings from human neurophysiology and neuroimaging and considers possible neurobiological mechanisms that might underlie clinical effects.
Methods
The extracted text presents a narrative review of human EEG and brain‑imaging studies of classic psychedelics and of clinical and observational reports concerning therapeutic use for psychiatric and addictive disorders. No explicit, reproducible literature search strategy, inclusion/exclusion criteria, or formal systematic review methods are reported in the extracted text; the chapter instead synthesises representative EEG, PET, SPECT and fMRI studies alongside clinical and preclinical findings. Where available, the authors describe key experimental designs from primary studies (for example, double‑blind, placebo‑controlled crossover administrations of freeze‑dried ayahuasca or single‑dose psilocybin PET/fMRI experiments), and they report sample characteristics such as volunteer numbers, prior psychedelic experience, dosing regimens and timing of neurophysiological or imaging assessments. The review therefore combines results from controlled laboratory experiments, open‑label clinical reports, observational surveys of ritual users, animal models and early clinical trials to draw inferences about brain effects and potential therapeutic mechanisms.
Results
Across modalities, a number of recurrent neurophysiological and neuroimaging findings are reported, although the literature remains patchy and sometimes inconsistent. EEG studies commonly show broad reductions in spectral power, particularly in the alpha and theta bands, and increases in peak frequency; some studies also report increased gamma activity. SPECT and PET investigations frequently observe increased cerebral blood flow (CBF) or glucose metabolism in brain regions involved in emotional processing, notably the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) and insula. Functional MRI work often finds reduced activity and connectivity within hubs of the default mode network (DMN), particularly the posterior cingulate cortex (PCC)/precuneus, and pronounced effects on visual cortices and visual connectivity. Ayahuasca: Early ritual EEG studies in Santo Daime users (n = 11) found increased gamma power in left occipital‑temporal‑parietal electrodes with eyes closed; another EEG report in 12 experienced users showed increases in alpha and theta power predominately in occipital sites. In a double‑blind, placebo‑controlled crossover with encapsulated freeze‑dried ayahuasca (18 experienced volunteers), absolute EEG power decreased across bands (most prominently theta) whereas beta power increased; effects began 15–30 minutes after ingestion, peaked between 45 and 120 minutes, and returned to baseline by 4–6 hours. LORETA analyses after a high dose localized band power decreases to temporo‑parieto‑occipital junction and temporomedial/frontomedial regions. Polysomnography in a randomised crossover trial (22 healthy males) comparing ayahuasca (equivalent 1 mg/kg DMT) and D‑amphetamine found that ayahuasca did not subjectively impair sleep, both drugs reduced REM duration, but ayahuasca increased slow‑wave sleep power while amphetamine decreased it. An uncontrolled EEG study of 20 experienced users who ingested ayahuasca in natura reported a biphasic pattern: alpha power reduction at about 50 minutes and increases in slow and fast gamma at 75 and 125 minutes, with regional localisation predominantly left parieto‑occipital and frontotemporal; these EEG changes correlated with serum levels of DMT and β‑carbolines. A placebo‑controlled SPECT study (n = 15) scanned ~100–110 minutes post‑dose and showed increased CBF bilaterally in anterior insula, right ACC/frontomedial cortex and left amygdala/parahippocampal gyrus. fMRI work in ritual members reported increased activity in primary and higher visual cortices and parahippocampal and fusiform regions; other fMRI studies described decreased DMN activity and reduced functional connectivity between PCC/precuneus and other regions. Psilocybin: FDG‑PET studies (n ≈ 10) after oral psilocybin (15–20 mg) reported a global MRglu increase (~25%), most pronounced in frontomedial/ frontolateral cortices, ACC and temporomedial regions, with smaller increases in basal ganglia and sensorimotor/occipital cortices; frontal MRglu increases correlated with “psychotic‑like” symptoms in one study. EEG/MEG work found decreased parieto‑occipital alpha power and reductions in 1.5–20 Hz power within a network including anterior/posterior cingulate and parahippocampal regions; intensity of spiritual experience correlated with delta phase‑lagged synchronisation across retrosplenial, parahippocampal and lateral orbitofrontal sites. Intravenous psilocybin (2 mg) fMRI paradigms showed increased visual cortex activity and enhanced vividness of autobiographical memory imagery, with subsequent subjective well‑being correlating with imagery vividness. Arterial spin labelling studies linked decreased ACC/mPFC perfusion to subjective intensity and reported reduced mPFC–PCC coupling. Connectivity analyses indicate a general increase in global connectivity during the psychedelic state, characterised by many transient, low‑stability patterns and some novel persistent structures; compared with MDMA, psilocybin tends to increase between‑network resting‑state connectivity and to reduce differentiation between networks. Emotional‑processing studies reported attenuated amygdala reactivity to negative stimuli after psilocybin, with the degree of attenuation correlating with improved mood. Mescaline and LSD: A SPECT study of 12 males given 500 mg mescaline showed a hyperfrontality pattern 4.5 hours post‑dose, correlated with psychotomimetic symptoms. Early EEG LSD studies described decreased broadband power and increased peak frequencies, particularly frontal. More recent LSD imaging work reports increased visual cortex CBF, decreased visual cortex alpha power, expanded primary visual cortex functional connectivity and reductions in DMN connectivity. Therapeutic and observational findings: Historical clinical literature and contemporary studies suggest potential antidepressant and antiaddictive effects. An open‑label SPECT study in 17 patients with recurrent depression reported significant HAM‑D and MADRS reductions at 80 minutes after ayahuasca intake, sustained for 21 days; SPECT 8 hours post‑dose showed increased CBF in left nucleus accumbens, right insula and left subgenual area. In an open‑label trial of psilocybin for treatment‑resistant depression (n = 12), depressive symptoms were significantly reduced at 1 week and effects persisted at 3 months after a high dose. Early meta‑analysis of LSD trials suggested benefit for alcohol‑use disorders. Observational data from ritual ayahuasca users (Project Hoasca and larger surveys) are reported as showing lower rates of addiction and reduced drug abuse in members versus general population samples. Small workshops and preclinical models report reductions in addiction‑like behaviours, and an open‑label psilocybin study showed decreased drinking and 80% tobacco abstinence at 6 months in participating subjects.
Discussion
The authors interpret convergent findings across EEG, PET/SPECT and fMRI as indicating that classic psychedelics produce reproducible changes in brain dynamics: broad reductions in spectral power (notably alpha and theta), increases in certain higher‑frequency bands, increased perfusion/metabolism in emotion‑related regions (ACC, insula) and decreased activity or connectivity in DMN hubs such as the PCC/precuneus. They emphasise strong and consistent effects on visual cortex function and connectivity and note that changes in network differentiation and transient increases in global connectivity may characterise the psychedelic state. Tófoli and colleagues situate these neural effects within therapeutic contexts, arguing that observed changes—particularly DMN modulation, influences on regions implicated in affect and interoception, and rapid increases in markers such as BDNF—provide plausible mechanisms for antidepressant and antiaddictive effects. They caution, however, that the relationship between DMN effects and addiction is complex: whereas alcohol dependence has been linked to DMN hyperconnectivity, many addictive drugs show reduced DMN connectivity, so simple models are premature. Molecularly, the chapter highlights evidence that psychedelics may upregulate BDNF and can modulate dopamine systems indirectly via serotonergic mechanisms; DMT’s action at sigma‑1 receptors is noted as another potentially relevant pathway. Key limitations acknowledged by the authors include gaps and contradictions in the literature, limited standardisation of substance preparations and dosing (notably for complex brews such as ayahuasca), small sample sizes, a mixture of controlled and open‑label designs, and difficulty dissociating direct pharmacological brain effects from psychological or contextual factors. They also point out the need to better characterise visual phenomena (true hallucinations versus imagery facilitation) and to refine understanding of which aspects of neurophysiological change are therapeutically relevant. Implications discussed include the need for more rigorous, controlled imaging and electrophysiology studies, careful study of clinical populations (for example, alcohol‑dependent patients), and consideration of how ritual, spiritual and psychotherapeutic contexts interact with neurobiological effects to produce lasting clinical benefit.
View full paper sections
INTRODUCTION
Psychedelics have long been used by native cultures in various rituals. In spite of countercultural connotations of the term psychedelic-coined by Sir Humphrey Osmond to mean "mind manifesting" -this appellation has been carefully chosen by scientists involved in "psychedelic renaissance" studies. The term may include substances with a number of different pharmacological profiles, including serotonin agonists, glutamatergic N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor antagonists, κ-opioid receptor agonists, anticholinergic agents, and cannabinoids. Depending on the drug, dose, setting, and personal predisposition, the altered state of consciousness associated with psychedelics often includes cognitive changes; broad perceptual changes; profound experiential changes in mood, thought, insight, and memory; and mystical and transpersonal experiences including illusions and hallucinations. Based on their effects, these compounds can be categorized into deliriants, dissociatives, and classic psychedelics. Deliriants, such as plantderived scopolamine and atropine and synthetic dimenhydrinate and trihexyphenidyl, commonly involve acetylcholine antagonism and tend to induce true hallucinations, delusions, and delirium (eg, stupor, confusion, confabulation). Dissociative hallucinogens, apart from perceptual changes, invoke a sense of detachment or dissociative anesthesia, described as oneirophrenia (dreamlike mind). Mechanisms of action of dissociative hallucinogens include NMDA receptor antagonisms (eg, ketamine and phencyclidine-PCP) and κ-opioid agonism (eg, salvinorin A, the active component of Salvia divinorum). Ibogaine is also a NMDA receptor antagonist and considered a dissociative hallucinogen, but its pharmacodynamics are complex and may include serotonin and opioid systems. This chapter will focus on the properties of classic or serotonergic psychedelics. Methylenedioxymethamphetamine (MDMA, also known as "ecstasy" or "molly") and other phenethylamines with empathogenic properties are sometimes considered psychedelics, since they also act on serotonin receptors but because they also have amphetamine-like characteristics and are rarely hallucinogenic in the classical sense, they will not be included herein. Based on their chemical profiles, classic psychedelics can be classified into three main categories: tryptamines, such as psilocybin, found in "magic mushrooms," and N,N-dimethyltryptamine (DMT); phenethylamines, such as mescaline and dl-2,5-dimethoxy-4-methylamphetamine (DOM); and lysergamides, such as lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD), with both tryptamine and phenethylamine properties, have efficacy primarily as partial agonists at serotonin 5HT 2A receptors. Classic psychedelics modulate serotonin (5HT 2A ) receptors, although recent work suggests involvement of sigma-1 receptors. They include psilocybin, ayahuasca, mescaline, and LSD, which have very low addictive potentialand increasing evidence suggests that they may be an alternative tool in the treatment of addiction. This chapter has two aims. The first aim is to present the available studies that have used electroencephalography (EEG), magnetoencephalography (MEG), positron emission tomography (PET), single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT), or functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to investigate the human brain under the influence of classic psychedelics. The second aim is to discuss their use as therapeutic options to treat drug addiction.
BRAIN RESEARCH STUDIES OF CLASSIC PSYCHEDELICS
Knowledge about plants and substances with psychedelic properties is not new to modern science: mescaline was isolated by Arthur Heffter in the late 19th century, and the effects of LSD were identified by Albert Hofmann in 1943. Nevertheless, our knowledge about the mechanisms of action of these substances remains superficial, in part due to the research embargo this field has been subjected for many decades, at least since the end of the 1960s, as a result of the "war on drugs". While scientific studies using psilocybin have been taking place since the end of the 20th century, LSD, the most paradigmatic of all psychedelics, has only recently reentered the scope of modern science. This is also true for the evaluation of psychedelics using modern neuroimaging techniques: in spite of the rapid proliferation of MRI-based psychiatric, pharmacological, and psychological studies, relatively few publications have used MRI to assess the effects of psychedelics on the human brain.
AYAHUASCA
Ayahuasca (the "vine of the spirits" in Quechua) is a psychedelic brew traditionally used by Amerindians that reached Brazilian urban centers around 1930, where it has since been used as a sacrament in syncretic churches such as the Santo Daime, the Unia ˜o do Vegetal (UDV), and Barquinha. More recently, the use of ayahuasca has expanded to the United States and Europe. There are numerous recipes that may be used to prepare ayahuasca, although it is most frequently produced by the decoction of the bark of a liana named Banisteriopsis caapi (B. caapi) with the leaves of a DMT-containing plant, Psychotria viridis. Indigenous traditions consider the B. caapi vine to be the main ingredient of ayahuasca and name the brew after the native species (eg, ayahuasca, natem, yag e, nixi pae). In research studies, it is important to keep in mind the potential diversity of components of ayahuasca, since it has come from a number of different plants and cultivars collected at different times. Compared to other psychedelics, the pharmacology of ayahuasca is particularly complex. DMT is mostly inactive when taken orally due to the presence of monoamine oxidase (MAO) enzymes in the gut. However, B. caapi is rich in β-carboline alkaloids (eg, harmine and harmaline), which are reversible MAO inhibitors. The constituents of ayahuasca therefore protect DMT from degradation, allowing its access to the central nervous system. Also, MAO inhibition likely has direct impact on the brain, as these enzymes protect other monoamines, such as serotonin, dopamine, and norepinephrine, from oxidative deamination. Furthermore, β-carbolines may have psychoactive properties independent of MAO inhibition. For example, another component of ayahuasca, tetrahydroharmine (THH), is a serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI). It is still in dispute to what extent harmine, harmaline, and THH have independent psychedelic effects. The acute effects of ayahuasca begin approximately 30-40 min after oral intake, and last up to 4 h. Autonomic responses include increases in cardiac and respiratory rates, blood pressure, temperature, and pupil diameter. Ayahuasca effects also include changes in perception, altered spatiotemporal scaling, enhanced visual imagery (especially with eyes closed), increased introspection, changes in mood, and the memories with high emotional salience. Results of several research studies using ayahuasca are presented in Table. The first EEG study using ayahuasca was conducted in 11 members of the Santo Daime church in a ritual setting. Increased gamma power was observed in left occipital-temporal-parietal electrodes, during the eyesclosed condition. With eyes open, significant increased gamma power was restricted to occipital electrodes. In another EEG study of 12 experienced individuals after three doses, ayahuasca increased power of both alpha and theta bands when compared to baseline. The strongest increase of alpha activity was observed in occipital electrodes; alpha was unchanged in the frontal electrodes and theta power significantly increased in both occipital and frontal areas. The first set of well-controlled experiments was performed with a low (0.6 mg/kg of DMT) and high (0.85 mg/kg of DMT) dose of encapsulated, freeze-dried ayahuasca administered to 18 volunteers with previous psychedelic experience, in a double-blind crossover, placebo-controlled design. Absolute power decreased in all frequency bands, most prominently in theta; relative power of delta decreased. There was also an increase in beta power. Observed EEG changes began 15-30 min after ayahuasca intake, reached a peak between 45 and 120 min, and thereafter decreased to baseline 4-6 h after administration. The spatial distribution of brain electrical activity was investigated using lowresolution electromagnetic tomography (LORETA) and a high dose (ie, 0.85 mg/kg of DMT) compared to placebo. Statistically significant differences, found at 60 and 90 min after ayahuasca intake, showed decreases in the alpha, delta, theta, and beta bands. Analysis with LORETA indicated that power decreases in delta, alpha, and beta bands occurred in the temporo-parieto-occipital junction, while theta decrease was localized to temporomedial and frontomedial regions. To investigate the impact of daytime ayahuasca consumption on sleep, as measured by polysomnography, freeze-dried ayahuasca (equivalent to 1 mg/kg of DMT), and an active placebo of D-amphetamine (20 mg) were administered to 22 healthy male volunteers in a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover design. Subjects ingested ayahuasca or amphetamine during the day, and sleep was evaluated the following night. In contrast with D-amphetamine, ayahuasca did not Note: BOLD, blood-oxygen-level-dependent contrast imaging; DMT, N,N-dimethyltryptamine; EEG, electroencephalography; fMRI, functional magnetic resonance imaging; HRM, harmine; HRL, harmaline; LORETA, low-resolution electromagnetic tomography; PCC, posterior cingulate cortex; SPECT, single-photon emission computed tomography; sMRI, structural magnetic resonance imaging; THH, tetrahydroharmine. induce any subjectively perceived deterioration of sleep quality or disruptions of sleep initiation and/or maintenance. Both ayahuasca and D-amphet- amine inhibited rapid eye movement (REM) sleep, decreasing its duration in absolute values and as a percentage of total sleep time, and showed a trend to increase REM onset. On the other hand, D-amphetamine decreased slow-wave sleep (SWS) power, while ayahuasca increased SWS power. The most recently published EEG study on ayahuasca investigated the relationship between temporal changes in EEG measures with serum concentrations of the main components of ayahuasca. Ayahuasca, donated by UDV, was given in natura to 20 individuals with previous experience. There was no blinding or placebo control. A biphasic effect of ayahuasca was found. The first phase showed reduced alpha power, 50 min after ingestion; the second phase was characterized by an increase in slow-and fast-gamma (30-50 and 50-100 Hz, respectively) power 75 and 125 min after ingestion. Alpha power decrease was most evident on the left parieto-occipital cortex. Slow-gamma increases were localized to the left centro-parieto-occipital, left frontotemporal, and right frontal cortices, while the fast-gamma increases were found on the left centro-parieto-occipital, left frontotemporal, right frontal, and right parieto-occipital cortices. These effects were significantly associated with circulating levels of DMT, harmine, harmaline, THH, and some of their metabolites. A SPECT study using freeze-dried ayahuasca in a placebo-controlled design evaluated healthy male volunteers (n ¼ 15) with previous psychedelic experience, scanned 100-110 min after ayahuasca administration. Significantly increased cerebral blood flow (CBF) was observed bilaterally in the anterior insula, asymmetric to the right hemisphere, in the right anterior cingulate cortex (ACC)/frontomedial cortex, and in the left amygdala/parahippocampal gyrus. fMRI has also been used to investigate the acute effects of ayahuasca (de. fMRI was acquired before and after (40 min) ayahuasca, from nine members of the Santo Daime church, who performed a visual perception and a mental imagery task. This study suggests that ayahuasca selectively increases the activity of the primary and higher visual cortices (BA17, 18, and 19), the parahippocampal gyrus (BA30), and the right fusiform gyrus (BA37). A positive modulation was also found in the frontopolar cortex (BA10). In another fMRI study, ayahuasca significantly decreased the activity in many regions of the Default Mode Network (DMN), particularly the posterior cingulate cortex (PCC)/precuneus. Also, decreased functional connectivity between the PCC/precuneus and other regions was observed during the effects of ayahuasca. The DMN is a set of brain regions with higher activity at rest (eyes-closed) relative to externally oriented tasks and has been associated with a variety of mental states, including mind wandering and rumination.
PSILOCYBIN
Psilocybin, an indolealkylamine and tryptamine, is the main active ingredient of the group of fungi known as "magic mushrooms." Psilocybin is a prodrug, that is, a substance that is metabolized after administration to become pharmacologically active as psilocin. When given orally, psilocybin is almost entirely transformed into psilocin during first-pass liver metabolism. Intravenous administration requires conversion of psilocybin to psilocin in the kidneys, a process that may be less efficient. The neuropsychological effects of psilocin appear to be mediated by stimulation of serotonergic receptors, namely, subtypes 5HT 2A , 5HT 2C , and 5HT 1C . Psilocybin is well tolerated and safe for human studies at oral doses of 8-25 mg and intravenous doses of 1-2 mg; Tyls ˇ, Pa ´lenı ´c ˇek, & Hora ´c ˇek, 2014). Results of several research studies using psilocybin are presented in Table, together with the few mescaline and LSD studies available. A PET study used [ 18 F]-fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) to assess cerebral metabolic rate of glucose utilization (MRglu) following psilocybin administration. Ten healthy volunteers were scanned before and 90 min after receiving a single oral dose of psilocybin (15 mg to subjects 50 kg or 20 mg to subject 51 kg body weight). Psilocybin produced a global increase (25%) of MRglu, most prominent in frontomedial and frontolateral cortices, ACC, and temporomedial cortex. Increased MRglu was also found in the basal ganglia (19%) and in sensorimotor and occipital cortices (14%). Significant correlations were found between "psychotic-like symptoms" and increased MRglu in the prefrontal cortex. EEG/MEG studies with psilocybin have shown decreased parietooccipital alpha power. Psilocybin decreased power (1.5-20 Hz) was observed within a neural network comprising the anterior and posterior cingulate cortices and the parahippocampal regions. Furthermore, the intensity of the psilocybin-induced spiritual experience correlated with the phase-lagged synchronization of delta oscillations between the retrosplenial cortex, the parahippocampus, and the lateral orbitofrontal area. Psilocybin, D-methamphetamine, and 3,4-methylenedioxyethylamphetamine (MDE, an empathogen with properties similar to MDMA) were evaluated in healthy volunteers (n ¼ 8) in another double-blind, placebo-controlled 18 F FDG PET study. Psilocybin increased MRglu in various frontotemporal cortical regions, predominantly in the ACC, and mostly in the right hemisphere. Psilocybin-induced mental state was compared to acute psychosis, where frontal hyperreactivity is present at rest, but is also associated with a reduced capacity to recruit prefrontal regions upon cognitive demand. fMRI has also been used to study the acute effects of psilocybin. Ten healthy volunteers recalled positive autobiographical memories during two fMRI sessions under the influence of psilocybin (2 mg, intravenous), or placebo, separated by approximately 7 days. Psilocybin was associated with increased activity in visual cortices. Vividness of the memory and visual imagery was stronger with psilocybin. Furthermore, there was a significant correlation between subjective well-being at follow-up and vividness of the positive memory.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
In another fMRI study, arterial spin labeling was used to evaluate CBFrelated changes after intravenous administration of psilocybin (2 mg) or saline. Decreased activity in ACC/mPFC correlated with the intensity of subjective effects, as measured by a visual analog scale. Moreover, functional connectivity analysis revealed a significant decrease in positive coupling between the mPFC and the PCC. In a followup study, different functional connectivity patterns were explored, suggesting that psilocybin increases brain connectivity overall when compared to placebo. The psychedelic state is characterized by higher connectivity, defined by the appearance of several low stability, transient structures and a few persistent ones that were not observed with placebo. In a reanalysis of the same data, changes in resting-state functional connectivity (RSFC) between different resting-state networks (RSN) were measured. Data following exposure to psilocybin were compared to data following MDMA exposure. Psilocybin, but not MDMA, generally increased between RSFC networksAddiction and Psychedelics 2014). Decreased RSFC between visual and sensorimotor RSN was also observed. Thus, current evidence suggests that RSFC networks become less differentiated in the psychedelic state (eg,. Amygdala reactivity to negative or neutral stimuli was lower following psilocybin than following placebo administration. A correlation was found between psilocybin-induced attenuation of the BOLD response in the right amygdala in response to negative stimuli and a psilocybin-induced increase in positive mood state. Such results indicate a positive effect of psilocybin on emotion processing, which suggests possible therapeutic properties.
MESCALINE
Mescaline, isolated by Arthur Heffter in 1897, is the active component of psychedelic cacti such as peyote (Lophophora williamsii) and wachuma (Echinopsis pachanoi, also known as San Pedro). Similar to the other classic psychedelics, mescaline is a 5HT 2A/2C agonist and one of the most selectively serotonergic psychedelic. The usual dose of mescaline in humans is between 300 and 500 mg and its effects last for 6-8 h. Twelve healthy, male volunteers, ingesting a dose of 500 mg of mescaline sulfate were compared to 12 agematched male who were given placebo. After intake (4.5 h), subjects were scanned with 99m Tc-HMPAO SPECT, and showed a pattern of hyperfrontality when compared to placebo, which was correlated with psychotomimetic symptomatology.
LYSERGIC ACID DIETHYLAMIDE
LSD is psychoactive in very small amounts: effects are noticeable at about 25 μg, with typical doses between 50 and 150 μg. Effects of LSD can last 8-14 h depending on the dose and tolerance due to repeated ingestion. As seen in EEG studies of mescaline and psilocybin (eg,, early EEG studies with LSD reported consistent findings including decreased broadband power and increased peak frequencies particularly in the frontal cortex. More recently, it was found that LSD has significant effects on the visual system, showing increased visual cortex CBF, decreased visual cortex alpha power, and a greatly expanded primary visual cortex (V1) functional connectivity profile. Moreover, likewise other psychedelics, LSD decreases the DMN connectivity (Carhart-Harris,.
SUMMARY OF CURRENT BRAIN RESEARCH IN PSYCHEDELICS
Despite gaps in our current knowledge, occasional contradictory reports, and problems inherent to pharmacological research studies (eg, differentiating a brain response due to the direct action of the pharmaceutical agent from a "psychological" effect; consistency/standardization of substance preparation, dosing, administration, etc.; unique pharmacodynamics properties of each psychedelic compound), there are some consistent findings in the current psychedelic literature (please refer to Figs.and). For example, EEG studies suggest that psychedelics induce a broad power reduction, most prominent in alpha and theta bands and increased peak frequency, especially for alpha. SPECT/PET studies suggest that psychedelics increase CBF in key regions involved in emotional processing, such as the ACC and insula. A common finding in neuroimaging studies (eg, fMRI) is reduced activity in key hubs of the DMN, particularly of the PCC/precuneus. Another persistent finding is that psychedelics have pronounced effects on the visual system (Carhart-Harris,. This area of investigation now requires a more refined description of the effects of psychedelics on the visual system since literature does not clearly differentiate true hallucinations, visual illusions, pseudohallucinations, or visual imagery facilitation. The valence of images and their integration with memories and affective states may be important in considering the therapeutic value of psychedelics.
PSYCHEDELICS AS THERAPEUTIC TOOLS
Psychedelics (eg, LSD, mescaline, psilocybin, DMT) were extensively explored as therapeutic tools before they became classified as illicit substances. Indeed, a rich literature focusing on the therapeutic potential of psychedelics, including treatment of depression, neurosis, obsessivecompulsive disorder, and addiction flourished in the 1950-1960s. The feeling of subjective wellness after the use of psychedelics, referred to as Fig.Summary of results of EEG and imaging studies with psilocybin, mescaline, and LSD: localized effects in the central nervous system. Default mode networks hubs are marked with an asterisk (*). Note: CBF, cerebral blood flow; EEG, electroencephalography; fMRI, functional magnetic resonance imaging; sMRI, structural magnetic resonance imaging. an "afterglow", has been reported in the literature since the 1960s (eg,. In contrast to most antidepressants, psychedelics promote a positive mood almost immediately. Early evaluation of psychedelics as chemical models of psychosis (ie, psychotomimetics or substances that induce states that mimic psychosis) suggested that at least some psychotic symptoms are induced by endogenous activations of 5HT 2A pathways, as observed using LSD in drug-discriminant animal studies. Such findings led to development of risperidone, an antipsychotic that in addition to blocking dopamine receptors, inhibits 5HT 2A receptors. Modern studies continue to use psychedelics as a source of insight into psychosis in general and schizophrenia in particular. Treatment of both depression and addiction with psychedelics has shown promise. A growing literature indicates that psychedelics have antidepressant effects. Ayahuascaand psilocybinin open-label studies show potential antidepressant effects. As part of an ongoing investigation on the potential of ayahuasca to treat depressive states, a SPECT study was performed in 17 patients with recurrent depression 8 h after intake. Ayahuasca, donated by Santo Daime, was administered in natura using an open-label design, and depression severity was assessed using the Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression (HAM-D) and the Montgomery-A ˚sberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS). A significant decrease in ratings of depression was reported on both scales at 80 min after intake, a finding that persisted for 21 days. SPECT, performed 8 h after ayahuasca intake, showed significant CBF increases in the left nucleus accumbens, right insula, and left subgenual area. Similarly, two oral doses (10 and 25 mg) of psilocybin were given to 12 patients with moderate-to-severe treatment-resistant depression. Outcomes were measured with the quick inventory of depressive symptoms. Compared to baseline, depression symptoms were significantly reduced after 1 week and effects were sustained after 3 months after high-dose treatment. Based on results of early studies using LSD and other psychedelics, the scientific studies of ayahuasca in humans, and anthropological and qualitative accounts from the ritual and religious use of psychedelics, a number of scientists began to explore the use of psychedelics for the treatment of drug-related disorders (eg,. Indeed, a contemporary meta-analytic examination of early LSD studies found evidence for a beneficial effect of LSD on alcohol-use disorders. Results from modern observational and clinical trials are currently in a preliminary phase. Taken together, though, they are promising and seem to suggest a therapeutic effect of psychedelics on some psychiatric disease states. In the seminal Project Hoasca, 15 male members of the UDV and 15 matched controls were given standardized questionnaires. Though the data were retrospective and the sample was small, the religious use of ayahuasca seemed to present a strong and positive impact in the lives of UDV members. UDV membership was also associated with reduced drug abuse in teenagers. A survey of almost 1700 UDV members suggested lower rates of addiction relative to the general population. Similarly, members of Santo Daime relative to the general population appear to have fewer psychiatric diagnoses of drug abuse. Therefore, although more studies are clearly necessary, current data seem to suggest that psychedelics have antiaddictive properties. Additional studies have shown reduced addict-like behaviors in addicted patients who participated in an ayahuasca workshop with South American shamans. A study with mice demonstrated that ayahuasca inhibits the development of an animal model of alcohol dependence. Open-label study with psilocybin presented encouraging results for both alcohol and tobacco cessation: significant decreases in drinking behaviors were observed, and 80% of participating subjects achieved tobacco abstinence at 6-month follow-up.
POTENTIAL MECHANISMS OF PSYCHEDELIC TREATMENT EFFICACY
Functional activity of the DMN appears to be disrupted in a number of mental disorders, including addiction. These disruptions are complex and still not clearly elucidated, and it is too soon to suggest that the potential therapeutic role of psychedelics may come from their effect on the DMN. Such a mechanism would also seem contradictory based on findings that with the exception of alcohol, most addictive substances show reduced DMN connectivity and most psychedelics have also been shown to acutely reduce DMN connectivity. In subjects with alcohol-use disorders relative to controls, DMN regions appear to be hyperconnected. Increased functional connectivity correlated with scores on an alcohol dependence scale. Alcohol-dependent subjects compared to controls also showed decreased functional connectivity of the precuneus after alcohol administration. Considering such findings, alcoholism seems to be the most promising candidate for DMN studies investigating psychedelics for the treatment of addiction. Another use of psychedelics in treatment is to increase interoception and self-awareness, which may help in both psychiatric and addictive states. Mindfulness, likewise psychedelics, decreases activity of the DMN. Evaluation of the interaction between mindfulness techniques and psychedelic states may provide insights into better quality of life. Indirect activity of psychedelics on brain dopamine systems may be relevant to substance-use disorders (eg,. For example, harmine and psilocin can increase dopamine in the ventral striatum/nucleus accumbens via 5HT 2A/2C receptor stimulation. LSD, psilocybin, and DMT may also effect dopamine transmission, though not necessarily in the nucleus accumbens. Imaging studies do not generally note a remarkable effect of psychedelics on the mesolimbic dopaminergic reward system. By contrast, a number of brain regions with an emerging role in the initiation or maintenance of addiction (eg, amygdala, hippocampus, insula, and medial prefrontal cortex) are directly influenced by psychedelics. From a molecular perspective, available evidence suggests that psychedelics increase the expression of brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF). BDNF increases are associated with the mitigation of symptoms of anxiety and depression: the increase in BDNF associated with use of antidepressants (eg, SSRI) coincides with the beginning of their therapeutic efficacy, typically 2 weeks after initiation. A more rapid effect of psychedelics may be associated with BDNF increases primarily in cortical pyramidal cells of layer V via a mechanism involving stimulation of 5HT 2A receptors. Ayahuasca may additionally increase BDNF via at least one of the β-carbolines, namely, harmine, as demonstrated in animals. Indeed, β-carbolines may have independent antidepressant and anxiolytic properties possibly associated with direct stimulation of serotonin receptors or by MAO inhibition. Similarly, THH can act as an SSRI and increase serotonin levels. Such hypotheses, however, fail to explain the apparently immediate antidepressant properties of ayahuasca. DMT, in the few isolated studies in humans, seems to have antianxiety effects. This is likely due to stimulation of serotonin 5HT 2A receptors. However, DMT is also a natural ligand for the sigma-1, intracellular chaperone receptor. Although the molecular roles of sigma-1 receptors remain to be explored, DMT has been identified as one of its natural and endogenous ligands. Indeed, it has been hypothesized that dysfunction of sigma-1 receptors is associated with depression, anxiety, and substance-use-related disorders. A number of antidepressants have been shown to bind to sigma-1 receptors, and conversely, ligands of sigma-1 receptors have antidepressant effects in animal models of depression.
CLOSING REMARKS
There are many aspects of psychedelic consumption that may be beneficial beyond what may be adequately quantified in a laboratory setting (Garcia-Romeu,. For example, traditional users of psychedelic plants often note the presence of a guiding instance, as well as visions that can be therapeutic as "didactic scenes" are common during ayahuasca use. Finally, psychedelic users often report spiritual experiences (eg,and the ritual and religious use of peyote or ayahuasca is legal in many countries. Such considerations are not outside the scope of our modern attempts to treat addiction since after all, Alcoholics Anonymous, still one of the mainstays of treatment of alcoholism, includes a spiritual dimension. The goal then is not to deny, but to understand the spiritual/ mystical components of psychedelics and provide research to assist therapists and other health professionals to exploit such properties of psychedelics to help those seeking relief from psychiatric symptoms or addiction. This is an open path for exploration with modern EEG and imaging techniques.
Full Text PDF
Study Details
- Study Typemeta
- Populationrodentshumans
- Characteristicsliterature review
- Journal
- Author