AyahuascaPlacebo

Subacute Effects of the Psychedelic Ayahuasca on the Salience and Default Mode Networks

This randomised placebo-controlled study (n=43) inspects the subacute effects of psychedelic ayahuasca on the primary sensory brain networks and networks supporting higher-order effective and self-referential functions in healthy participants (21 placebo/22 ayahuasca) using task-free functional magnetic resonance imaging data (fMRI).

Authors

  • Fernanda Palhano-Fontes

Published

Journal of Psychopharmacology
individual Study

Abstract

Background: Neuroimaging studies have just begun to explore the acute effects of psychedelics on large-scale brain networks’ functional organization. Even less is known about the neural correlates of subacute effects taking place days after the psychedelic experience. This study explores the subacute changes of primary sensory brain networks and networks supporting higher-order affective and self-referential functions 24 hours after a single session with the psychedelic ayahuasca.Methods: We leveraged task-free functional magnetic resonance imaging data 1 day before and 1 day after a randomized placebo-controlled trial exploring the effects of ayahuasca in naïve healthy participants (21 placebo/22 ayahuasca). We derived intra- and inter-network functional connectivity of the salience, default mode, visual, and sensorimotor networks, and assessed post-session connectivity changes between the ayahuasca and placebo groups. Connectivity changes were associated with Hallucinogen Rating Scale scores assessed during the acute effects.Results: Our findings revealed increased anterior cingulate cortex connectivity within the salience network, decreased posterior cingulate cortex connectivity within the default mode network, and increased connectivity between the salience and default mode networks 1 day after the session in the ayahuasca group compared to placebo. Connectivity of primary sensory networks did not differ between groups. Salience network connectivity increases correlated with altered somesthesia scores, decreased default mode network connectivity correlated with altered volition scores, and increased salience default mode network connectivity correlated with altered affect scores.Conclusion: These findings provide preliminary evidence for subacute functional changes induced by the psychedelic ayahuasca on higher-order cognitive brain networks that support interoceptive, affective, and self-referential functions.

Unlocked with Blossom Pro

Research Summary of 'Subacute Effects of the Psychedelic Ayahuasca on the Salience and Default Mode Networks'

Introduction

Classic psychedelics produce altered states of consciousness with wide-ranging effects on sensory, cognitive, autonomic, interoceptive, self-referential, and emotional systems. Ayahuasca is a traditional Amazonian admixture containing N,N-dimethyltryptamine (N,N-DMT) and monoamine oxidase inhibitors; N,N-DMT has high affinity for serotonergic and sigma-1 receptors, while the monoamine oxidase inhibitors render it orally active. Recent clinical trials have reported rapid antidepressant effects of ayahuasca, including benefits observed 1 day after a single session, but the neural mechanisms underlying changes in affect, mood, and self-representation remain incompletely understood. Task-free functional MRI (tf-fMRI) can map intrinsic large-scale brain networks such as the salience network (involving the anterior cingulate cortex and anterior insula) and the default mode network (involving posterior cingulate cortex, precuneus, medial prefrontal cortex), which are implicated in interoception, socioemotional processing, and self-referential thought. Pasquini and colleagues set out to characterise subacute (24-hour) changes in intra- and inter-network functional connectivity after a single ayahuasca session in ayahuasca‑naïve healthy participants, and to relate those changes to subjective measures of the acute psychedelic experience. The primary hypothesis was that 24 hours after dosing ayahuasca would alter higher-order affective and self-referential networks (salience and default mode) but not primary sensory networks. The investigators used a seed-based connectivity approach, complemented by independent component analysis (ICA), to map salience, default mode, visual and sensorimotor networks before and 24 hours after dosing in a randomised placebo-controlled design.

Methods

This randomised, placebo-controlled study recruited 50 cognitively and physically healthy, ayahuasca‑naïve participants from local media and online advertisements. Exclusion criteria included current chronic disease; the extracted text does not list the full set of exclusions. Participants were randomised to receive a single oral dose of ayahuasca (1 mL/kg; n intended = 25) or a placebo beverage (1 mL/kg; n intended = 25). Alkaloid concentrations in the ayahuasca batch were quantified by mass spectrometry and reported as group means: N,N-DMT 0.36 ± 0.01 mg/mL, harmine 1.86 ± 0.11 mg/mL, harmaline 0.24 ± 0.03 mg/mL, and tetrahydroharmine 1.20 ± 0.05 mg/mL. The placebo was designed to mimic organoleptic properties (bitter/sour taste, brown colour) and contained water, yeast, citric acid, zinc sulfate and caramel colourant; zinc sulfate produced modest gastrointestinal discomfort to partially control for non-specific effects. Task-free fMRI scans were acquired on a 1.5 Tesla scanner approximately 1 day before dosing (baseline) and again ~24 hours after the session. EPI parameters were TR = 2000 ms, TE = 35 ms, flip angle 60°, 35 slices, 213 volumes; T1-weighted structural images used an FSPGR BRAVO sequence. Seven participants were excluded after initial inclusion (three from ayahuasca, four from placebo) for reasons including loss to follow-up, scanning artefacts, a discovered cystic lesion, and elevated blood glucose discovered post hoc; the final analysed sample was 43 (22 ayahuasca, 21 placebo). Preprocessing used CONN and included discarding the first three volumes, slice-timing correction, realignment, spatial smoothing (6 mm FWHM), coregistration to structural images, normalisation to MNI space (2 mm3 voxels), motion assessment with ART (outlier volumes defined by global signal >5 SD or framewise displacement >0.9 mm), and physiological/noise regression using CompCor. Residual motion parameters, outlier volumes, white matter and CSF signals were regressed out, and a temporal band-pass filter of 0.01–0.1 Hz was applied. Mean framewise displacement was low in the sample and near a stringent 0.25 mm threshold. For intra-network analyses, bilateral regions-of-interest from the Brainnetome Atlas were used as seeds: anterior cingulate cortex, posterior cingulate cortex, occipital cortex and precentral cortex. Voxel-wise seed-based regression generated salience, default mode, visual and sensorimotor connectivity maps. Group ICA (20 components, two-step PCA reduction, infomax algorithm) was performed as a control. Inter-network connectivity was estimated by extracting average time series from the identified network maps and computing pairwise Pearson correlations. Statistical analyses used voxel-wise one-sample t-tests to define masks, then voxel-wise two-sample t-tests on change maps (post minus pre) to compare groups; reported voxel-cluster thresholds varied (commonly joint cluster and extent probability p<0.05 and p<0.01 uncorrected, with some stricter FWE-corrected thresholds at mask derivation). The investigators controlled for head-motion differences in secondary analyses, ran nonparametric permutation testing with FSL Randomise (threshold-free cluster enhancement, p<0.05 with FWE correction), and used partial correlations (controlling for framewise displacement differences) to associate connectivity changes with Hallucinogen Rating Scale (HRS) subscales assessed ~4 hours post-dosing. Two-sample t-tests assessed demographic and HRS group differences; multiple comparison corrections were applied where stated.

Results

Forty-three participants (22 ayahuasca, 21 placebo) passed quality checks and had tf-fMRI at both time points. Groups were comparable for age, sex distribution and head motion. Acute subjective effects measured by the Hallucinogen Rating Scale were robustly greater in the ayahuasca group across most subscales: somesthesia (p<0.0005), affect (p<0.005), perception (p<0.0005), cognition (p<0.0005), volition (p<0.009) and intensity (p<0.0005); all survived correction for multiple comparisons except volition. Comparing change maps (post minus pre) between groups, voxel-wise two-sample t-tests indicated increased functional connectivity within the salience network in the ayahuasca group relative to placebo, localised bilaterally to the anterior cingulate cortex and superior frontal gyrus (reported test statistic t = 1.3 for the seed-based finding; cluster/extent thresholds p<0.05 and p<0.01 uncorrected). Conversely, decreases in default mode network connectivity were observed in the ayahuasca group, predominantly centred on the posterior cingulate cortex. Inter-network analyses showed increased connectivity between the salience and default mode networks after ayahuasca compared to placebo (t = 2.5; p<0.02). No significant group differences were found for intra-network connectivity of primary sensory networks (visual, sensorimotor) or their inter-network couplings with salience and default mode networks. Control analyses yielded convergent results: ICA replicated increased anterior cingulate and superior frontal connectivity for the salience network and a trend-level decrease in posterior cingulate connectivity for the default mode network. Adding the difference in mean framewise displacement as a covariate did not materially change the findings. Nonparametric permutation testing (Randomise) also supported the primary results. Exploratory partial correlations (controlling for framewise displacement differences) related subacute connectivity changes to acute HRS scores within the ayahuasca group: increases in salience network connectivity correlated positively with somesthesia (partial r = 0.55, p<0.01), decreases in default mode connectivity correlated negatively with volition (partial r = -0.59, p<0.005), and increased salience–default mode connectivity correlated with affect (partial r = 0.47, p<0.03). These associations were generally absent in the placebo group. Multiple regression across all participants tested interaction effects: the slope relating salience connectivity change to somesthesia differed by group (β = -0.51, t = -3.00, p<0.005), and the slope for affect versus salience–default connectivity also differed by group (β = -0.39, t = -2.64, p<0.02). The regression for volition versus default mode connectivity change found no significant group interaction (β = -0.13, t = -0.88, p = 0.383).

Discussion

Using a randomised placebo-controlled design with tf-fMRI scans before and 24 hours after dosing, the investigators report that a single ayahuasca session produced subacute increases in anterior cingulate and superior frontal connectivity within the salience network, decreases in posterior cingulate connectivity within the default mode network, and increased coupling between salience and default mode networks. No subacute changes were detected in primary sensory networks, suggesting some specificity to higher-order affective and self-referential systems. The authors interpret the salience network increases as related to interoceptive and socioemotional processing, noting that hubs such as the anterior insula and anterior cingulate play central roles in integrating autonomic and visceral information and mobilising visceromotor responses to salient stimuli. Pasquini and colleagues link their findings to pharmacology: N,N-DMT acts at 5-HT2A receptors and other ayahuasca alkaloids interact with monoamine systems, receptors whose cortical distributions overlap hubs of the salience and default mode networks. They compare the present subacute profile with prior acute and subacute studies of psychedelics and ketamine, which have reported mixed effects on salience and default mode connectivity (acute decreases, entropy changes, or post-session increases depending on compound and timing). Structural work in long-term ayahuasca users showing anterior cingulate cortical thickness increases and decreased thickness in certain default mode regions is cited as context for possible longer-term anatomical-functional relationships. The authors acknowledge several limitations. They note the use of relatively liberal voxelwise cluster‑extent thresholds in parts of the analysis and the small sample size and moderate MRI field strength (1.5 Tesla), which reduce statistical power and may favour false positives. Although they performed several control analyses—ICA replication, permutation testing and motion covariate analyses—to mitigate methodological concerns, the default mode connectivity decreases did not survive more stringent thresholds and thus should be interpreted cautiously. Correlational analyses tying connectivity changes to HRS subscales were exploratory; the volition subscale has known low internal consistency and both groups showed comparable relationships between volition and default mode change, raising the possibility of non-specific or placebo-related effects. Finally, the investigators emphasise that effects after a single session in healthy participants are expected to be modest, and recommend larger, longitudinal studies including clinical populations and multimodal autonomic measures to clarify acute and longer-term impacts on networks supporting interoception, affect and self-referential processing.

Conclusion

The study provides preliminary evidence that a single ayahuasca session produces subacute functional changes in large-scale brain networks involved in interoception, affect and self-referential processing: increased salience network connectivity (notably anterior cingulate), decreased default mode network connectivity (posterior cingulate), and increased salience–default coupling 24 hours post-dose, with these changes correlating with acute subjective somatic, affective and volitional experiences. Primary sensory networks did not show subacute connectivity changes. The authors conclude that ayahuasca may exert sustained effects on mood-related neural circuits, while emphasising the need for further, better‑powered and longitudinal research to confirm and extend these findings.

View full paper sections

INTRODUCTION

Classic psychedelics belong to a family of substances that lead to altered states of consciousness, with a broad range of effects on sensory, cognitive, autonomic, interoceptive, self-referential, and emotional systems. Assisted sessions with psychedelic substances such as ayahuasca and psilocybin have recently gained prominent use for the treatment of affective disorders. Ayahuasca is an indigenous preparation that contains leaves of Psychotria viridis and the bark of Banisteriopsis caapi, two plants commonly found in the Amazon basin. The admixture contains the psychedelic tryptamine N,N-dimethyltryptamine (N,N-DMT) and monoamine oxidase inhibitors. The first has a particularly high affinity to serotonin and sigma-1 receptors whereas the latter renders N,N-DMT orally active by inhibiting the enzyme monoamine oxidase in the gut. Recent clinical trials have explored the antidepressant effects of ayahuasca. In an open-label trial, 17 patients with treatmentresistant depression were submitted to a single session with ayahuasca. Significant antidepressant effects were observed 1 day after the session and persisted for 21 days. Consistent results were found in a separate randomized placebocontrolled trial, where a significant rapid antidepressant effect of ayahuasca was already observed 1 day after the session, compared to placebo). Yet little is known about the underlying neural mechanisms by which ayahuasca may modulate affect, mood, and internal representations of oneself. Neuroimaging techniques provide a powerful tool to explore brain changes elicited by psychedelic agents (Dos. Task-free functional magnetic resonance imaging (tf-fMRI, also referred to as resting-state fMRI) measures synchronous, low frequency (<0.1 Hz) fluctuations in blood oxygen level-dependent (BOLD) activity among distant gray matter regionsand has been used to delineate distinct intrinsic large-scale brain networks supporting primary sensory and higher cognitive and emotional functions. Importantly, human emotions and social behavior are modulated by a distributed set of brain regions including the anterior cingulate cortex, bilateral anterior insula, and subcortical and limbic structures that regulate affect, interoception, and self-awareness by interacting with the autonomic nervous system. These regions coactivate and are structurally connected, cohesively forming the salience network, a large-scale brain system involved in homeostatic behavioral guidance and supporting socioemotional functions by integrating visceral and sensory information. A second prominent large-scale brain system is the default mode network, which is primarily composed of the posterior cingulate cortex, precuneus, inferior parietal lobe, parahippocampal gyrus, and medial prefrontal cortex. This network has been repeatedly associated with selfreferential processes such as mind-wandering, introspection, and memory retrieval under healthy and pathological conditions. Recent neuroimaging studies have explored the acute effects of psychedelics on functional organization of human brain networks, with reports of increased functional integration at the global brain level, and connectivity increases primarily affecting the primary visual cortex and frontal areas. Only one study has reported salience network connectivity decreases under acute conditions, whereas most studies report decreased connectivity in important hubs of the default mode network, such as the posterior cingulate cortex. A recent study assessing subacute neural changes 24 hours after a single dose of ayahuasca reported decreased negative connectivity between the anterior cingulate cortex, a salience network hub, and key default mode network regions such as the posterior cingulate cortex and medial temporal lobes. These connectivity changes correlated with increased self-compassion scores and other measures of enhanced psychological capacities assessed 24 hours after the session, providing a biological basis for the post-acute or "after-glow" stage of psychedelic effects. Likewise, subacute effects of psilocybin in patients with treatment-resistant depression 1 day after dosing led to increased connectivity between hubs of the salience and default mode networks such as the subgenual cingulate and posterior cingulate cortices, whereas connectivity decreases were observed in patients between the prefrontal and parahippocampal cortices, two important default mode network regions. Little is known, however, about inter-and intra-network subacute changes induced by ayahuasca on the salience and default mode networks of naïve healthy participants hours to days after a psychedelic session, and how functional changes may relate to the altered state of consciousness elicited during the psychedelic experience. To address this critical gap, we leveraged tf-fMRI data assessed before and 24 hours after a randomized placebocontrolled trial exploring the subacute effects of ayahuasca in naïve healthy participants. We hypothesized that 24 hours after ayahuasca administration, we would observe changes in higherorder affective and self-referential networks but not primary sensory networks. Furthermore, we predicted that changes in higher-order affective and self-referential networks would relate to the acute effects of ayahuasca. We applied a seed-based connectivity approach to map the salience, default mode, visual, and sensorimotor networks and assessed subacute inter-and intranetwork connectivity changes 1 day after the session with ayahuasca compared to placebo.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

We recruited 50 participants from local media and the Internet. All individuals included in the study were cognitively and physically healthy and naïve to ayahuasca. The following exclusion criteria were adopted: (a) diagnosis of current chronic disease (e. Half of the participants (n = 25) received a single low dose of 1 mL/kg of ayahuasca and the other half (n = 25) received 1 mL/kg of a placebo substance. Alkaloids concentrations were quantified by mass spectroscopy analysis. A single ayahuasca batch was used throughout the study, containing on average (mean ± SD): 0.36 ± 0.01 mg/mL of N,N-DMT, 1.86 ± 0.11 mg/mL of harmine, 0.24 ± 0.03 mg/mL of harmaline, and 1.20 ± 0.05 mg/mL of tetrahydroharmine. The batch was prepared and provided by a branch of the Barquinha church, Ji-Paraná, Brazil. The liquid used as placebo was designed to simulate organoleptic properties of ayahuasca, such as a bitter and sour taste, and a brownish color. It contained water, yeast, citric acid, zinc sulfate, and caramel colorant. The presence of zinc sulfate also produced modest gastrointestinal distress allowing to control for the non-specific effects of ayahuasca. Analogously to two previous studies investigating the subacute effects of psychedelics, baseline tf-fMRI assessments occurred 1 day before dosing and a second tf-fMRI assessment occurred 24 hours after dosing (Figure). Blood samples were drawn at baseline and 1 day after the session. To assess the acute psychedelic experience, we used the Hallucinogenic Rating Scale (HRS), which was initially designed to assess the psychedelic effects of N,N-DMT. It is divided into six subscales: (a) intensity, which reflects the strength of the overall experience; (b) somesthesia, which assesses somatic effects including interoception, visceral, and tactile effects; (c) affect, which assesses comfort, emotional, and affective changes; (d) perception, which assesses visual, auditory, gustatory, and olfactory effects; (e) cognition, which assesses changes in thoughts; and (f) volition, which is related to the subject's capacity to willfully interact with his/her 'self'. We used the validated HRS version translated to Brazilian Portuguese. Participants completed the HRS at the end of the dosing session (approximately 4 hours after ayahuasca or placebo ingestion).

NEUROIMAGING DATA ACQUISITION

tf-fMRI scanning was performed on a 1.5 Tesla scanner. fMRI data were acquired using an EPI sequence with the following parameters: TR = 2000 ms; TE = 35 ms; flip angle = 60°; FOV = 24 cm; matrix = 64 x 64; slice thickness = 3 mm; gap = 0.3 mm; number of slices = 35; volumes = 213. T1-weighted images were also acquired using a FSPGR BRAVO sequence with the following parameters: TR = 12.7 ms, TE = 5.3 ms, flip angle = 60°, FOV = 24 cm, matrix = 320 x 320; slice thickness = 1.0 mm; number of slices = 128.

NEUROIMAGING DATA PREPROCESSING

Of those 50 participants that met our initial inclusion criteria, three in the ayahuasca group and four in the placebo group were excluded from further analyses. One subject was excluded due to loss to follow-up resulting in the missing of the second scan; one subject due to obvious scanning artifacts as missing of the parietal cortex in the field of view; one participant had to be excluded due to a cystic lesion identified after visually inspecting the anatomical scans after the session; and four subjects had to be excluded due to high blood glucose levels indicative of diabetes, which were revealed to the researchers about a week after completion of the experiment. The first three fMRI volumes were discarded to allow T1 saturation. Preprocessing steps were performed using CONN () (Whitfield-Gabrieli and Nieto-Castanon, 2012) and included slice timing correction, head motion correction, and spatial smoothing (6-mm full width at half maximum Gaussian kernel) (Supplementary Figure). Functional images were coregistered to the subject's anatomical image, normalized into the Montreal Neurological Institute template, and resampled to 2 mm 3 voxels. The motion artifact was examined using the Artifact Detection Toolbox (ART;). Volumes were considered outliers if the global signal deviation was superior to five SD from the mean signal or if the difference in frame displacement between two consecutive volumes exceeded 0.9 mm. Physiological and other spurious sources of noise were removed using the CompCor method. CompCor is used for the reduction of non-physiological noise (head movement, cerebrospinal fluid) in BOLD data. Anatomical data are used to define regions of interest composed primarily of white matter and cerebrospinal fluid. Principal components are derived from these noise-related regions of interest and then included as nuisance parameters within general linear models for BOLD fMRI time-series data denoising. Residual head motion parameters (three rotation and three translation parameters), outlier volumes, white matter, and cerebral spinal fluid signals were regressed out. Finally, a temporal band-pass filter of 0.01 Hz to 0.1 Hz was applied. We evaluated the amount of head motion in our sample by individually estimating the head mean framewise displacement at both sessions (Supplementary Table). Participants showed a head mean framewise displacement way below the widely used threshold of 0.50 mmand close to the stringent threshold of 0.25 mm recommended by experts in the field.

INTRA-NETWORK FUNCTIONAL CONNECTIVITY ANALYSES

For each subject, average BOLD activity time courses were extracted using bilateral regions of interest from the Brainnetome Atlas (seed numbers 187 and 188 for the anterior cingulate cortex, seed numbers 175 and 176 for the posterior cingulate cortex, seed numbers 203 and 204 for the occipital cortex, and seed numbers 59 and 60 for the precentral cortex,). Salience, default mode, visual, and sensorimotor network functional connectivity maps were generated through voxel-wise regression analyses using the extracted timeseries as regressors. Baseline one-sample t-test maps derived from the seed-based approach were visually explored by experts and subsequently spatially correlated with publicly available maps of the visual (R seed = 0.44), sensorimotor (R seed = 0.49), default mode (R seed = 0.69), and salience networks (R seed = 0.64), and interactively compared to maps available on NeuroVault (). To control for our method of choice, the seed-based approach, we replicated the analysis using group independent component analysis (ICA) implemented through the GIFT toolbox (). Briefly, preprocessed tf-fMRI data from all subjects were decomposed into 20 spatially independent components within a group-ICA framework. Data were concatenated and reduced by two-step principal component analysis, followed by independent component estimation with the infomax-algorithm. This procedure results in a set of averaged group components, which are then back reconstructed into the subject's space. As in the seed-based approach, baseline one-sample t-test maps derived from the ICA-based approach were spatially correlated with publicly available maps of the default mode network (R ICA = 0.63)and salience network (R ICA = 0.56).

INTER-NETWORK FUNCTIONAL CONNECTIVITY ANALYSES

Average time series of resting BOLD activity were derived before and after the session from the one-sample t-test maps of the salience, visual, sensorimotor, and default mode networks identified in the seed-based analyses (Figure). Pairwise Pearson's correlation coefficients were used to estimate the level of functional connectivity between networks at baseline and after the ayahuasca session.

STATISTICAL ANALYSES

Using individual brain network connectivity maps across both samples at baseline, a voxel-wise one-sample t-test was implemented in SPM12 () to assess significant functional connections to our seeds of choice (t = 6.5, extent probability threshold of p<0.01 familywise error (FWE) corrected, voxel-wise threshold of p<0.001 FWE corrected for multiple comparisons; Figure). These maps were used as masks for subsequent voxel-wise statistical analyses. Change maps of brain network functional connectivity were derived by individually subtracting the functional connectivity maps at baseline from the ones post-dosing. Voxel-wise two-sample t-tests were used to assess differences in brain network functional connectivity between placebo and ayahuasca. Control analyses were performed by adding the difference in head mean framewise displacement between both scans as a covariate of no interest. We explicitly refrained from comparing functional connectivity maps at baseline across the two groups in accordance with the recommendation from the Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials Group (CONSORT,), which encompasses various initiatives developed by journal editors, epidemiologists, and clinical trialists to alleviate the problems arising from inadequate reporting of randomized control trials. If not stated otherwise, all voxel-wise findings are reported at the joint cluster and extent probability thresholds of p<0.05 and p<0.01 uncorrected. Analogously to the intra-network connectivity approach, changes in inter-network connectivity were assessed by subtracting the baseline inter-network functional connectivity value from the post-session value. The change in inter-network functional connectivity was subsequently compared across groups via two-sample t-tests (p<0.02 uncorrected). Because the use of liberal statistical thresholds in neuroimaging studies has been recently shown to be prone to inflate falsepositive results, we additionally assessed group differences in functional connectivity through nonparametric permutation tests as implemented using the FSL package Randomise () (p<0.05 threshold-free cluster enhancement uncorrected and FWE corrected for multiple comparisons). Two-sample t-tests were used to assess group differences in demographic variables, head mean framewise displacement, and HRS subscales (p<0.05, corrected for multiple comparisons if not specified otherwise). Average functional connectivity changes were derived from clusters identified with the voxel-wise two-sample t-tests using an uncorrected joint cluster and extent probability threshold of p<0.05 for the default mode network and a more stringent joint cluster and extent probability threshold of p<0.01 for the salience network. Partial correlation coefficients corrected for the difference in head mean framewise displacement between the second and first scan were used to associate intra-and inter-network functional connectivity changes with HRS subscale scores (p<0.05 if not specified otherwise).

RESULTS

In total, 43 ayahuasca-naïve participants assigned either to ayahuasca (n=22) or placebo (n=21) passed our neuroimaging data quality check (Table). All participants were assessed with tf-fMRI 1 day before and 1 day after dosing (Figure(a)), and salience, default mode, visual, and sensorimotor networks maps were individually derived by seeding bilateral regions-of-interest (Figure(b), Supplementary Table). Participants were comparable in terms of age, gender distribution, and head mean framewise displacement at both sessions (Table). We found significant between-group differences for all HRS subscales, with significant increases in the ayahuasca compared to the placebo group in levels of altered somesthesia (p<0.0005), affect (p<0.005), perception (p<0.0005), cognition (p<0.0005), volition (p<0.009), and intensity (p<0.0005) (Table). All HRS subscale comparisons survived multiple correction testing (p<0.008) with the exception of the volition subscale.

SUBACUTE SALIENCE AND DEFAULT MODE CONNECTIVITY CHANGES

We next explored differences in brain network functional connectivity between the ayahuasca and the placebo groups. A voxelwise two-sample t-test revealed significant increased functional connectivity in the ayahuasca group compared to placebo within the salience network (t = 1.3; joint cluster and extent probability thresholds of p<0.05 and p<0.01) (Figure(a), red and yellow maps, Supplementary Table). Functional connectivity increases with our seed of interest were located bilaterally within the anterior cingulate cortex and superior frontal gyrus, with a tendency towards the left hemisphere (Figure(a), first three brain slides and Supplementary Table). Conversely, we found functional connectivity decreases within the default mode network in the ayahuasca group compared to placebo, predominantly affecting our seed of choice in the posterior cingulate cortex (Figure(c) and Supplementary Table). Average levels of functional connectivity changes derived from the clusters identified in FiguresSimilar results were derived by adding the difference in head mean framewise displacement as a covariate of no interest in the two-sample t-test models (Supplementary Figureand Supplementary Table), suggesting no influence of head motion in functional differences was found across groups. Similar functional connectivity differences to our seeds of choice in the salience network and default mode network were also found when using nonparametric permutation-based tests (Supplementary Figureand Supplementary Table). Furthermore, consistent with our seed-based findings, ICA revealed patterns of increased anterior cingulate cortex and superior frontal gyrus functional connectivity for the salience network (t = 1.7; joint cluster and extent probability thresholds of p<0.05, Supplementary Figure(a) and (b) and Supplementary Table) and a trend in decreased posterior cingulate cortex functional connectivity of the default mode network in the ayahuasca group (t = 1.3; joint cluster and extent probability thresholds of p<0.1, Supplementary Figure) and (d) and Supplementary Table). Inter-network functional connectivity analyses (Figure) revealed increased functional connectivity between the salience and default mode networks in the ayahuasca group compared t placebo (t = 2.5; p<0.02). Intra-network functional connectivity of primary sensory networks (visual and sensorimotor) and inter-network functional connectivity of primary sensory networks with the default and salience networks did not differ significantly between ayahuasca and placebo, suggesting some level of specificity of the subacute functional changes elicited by ayahuasca on the salience and default mode networks.

AYAHUASCA-INDUCED SUBACUTE CHANGES IN FUNCTIONAL CONNECTIVITY CORRELATE WITH ACUTE ALTERATIONS IN SOMESTHESIA, AFFECT, AND VOLITION

Average functional connectivity changes were derived from the previously identified clusters in the salience network and the default mode network, and associated with HRS subscores assessed during the acute effects in an explorative way. Partial correlation analyses corrected for the difference in head mean framewise displacement between the second and first scanning session revealed significant positive associations between increases in salience network functional connectivity and somesthesia in the ayahuasca group but not in the placebo group (PR aya = 0.55, p<0.01; PR pla = 0.01, p=0.95) (Figure). Positive trend correlations were found between increased salience network functional connectivity and affect in the ayahuasca group and volition in the placebo group (Supplementary Table). Subacute changes in default mode network functional connectivity showed a significant negative correlation only with volition in the ayahuasca group and a trend in placebo (PR aya = -0.59, p<0.005; R pla = -0.43, p=0.06) (Figure, Supplementary Table). Further, subacute changes in functional connectivity between the salience and default mode networks correlated significantly with affect in the ayahuasca but not in the placebo group (PR aya = 0.47, p<0.03; R pla = -0.06, p = 0.81) (Figure, Supplementary Table). Trend correlations were found also to cognition in the ayahuasca and to perception in the placebo group (Supplementary Table). We subsequently estimated multiple linear regression models over all participants, using somesthesia as the dependent variable, and within salience network connectivity change, the difference in head mean framewise displacement between sessions, and a categorical group variable as predictors. This analysis revealed a main effect of group (β = -0.51, t = -3.00, p<0.005) indicating that the two slopes associating within salience network connectivity change and somesthesia scores significantly differ across the ayahuasca and the placebo groups. An analogous analysis exploring the association between affect and functional connectivity between the salience and default mode networks revealed a similar main effect of group (β = -0.39, t = -2.64, p<0.02) indicating significant group differences in the slopes. Using volition as the dependent variable and within-default mode network functional connectivity change as a predictor revealed that the main effect of group was not significant (β = -0.13, t = -0.88, p = 0.383), indicating the slopes do not differ across groups.

DISCUSSION

Neuroimaging techniques provide a unique opportunity to study the neural correlates of altered states of consciousness induced by psychedelic agents. In this study, ayahuasca-naïve participants were randomly assigned to a single session with either ayahuasca or placebo, and functional connectivity of different large-scale brain networks was assessed with tf-fMRI 1 day before and 1 day after the dosing session. We found (a) salience network connectivity increases within the anterior cingulate cortex and between the anterior cingulate cortex and the superior frontal gyrus in ayahuasca compared to placebo; (b) increased connectivity between the salience and default mode networks in the ayahuasca group; and (c) default mode network connectivity decreases within the posterior cingulate cortex in the ayahuasca group. Ayahuasca-induced subacute functional connectivity increases in the salience network correlated with altered levels of somesthesia, which reflects somatic changes including interoceptive, visceral, and tactile effects induced by psychedelics. Reduced default mode network connectivity correlated with altered levels of volition, proposed to reflect the subject's capacity to willfully interact with his/her 'self' during the psychedelic experience. Increased connectivity between the salience and default mode networks correlated with altered levels of affect reflecting emotional responses during the acute psychedelic session. No subacute inter-and intra-network connectivity differences were detected in primary sensory brain networks, suggesting specificity of the observed changes in the salience and default mode networks. Although little is known on the long-term functional impact of psychedelics on large-scale brain networks, these findings suggest that ayahuasca has sustained effects on neural systems supporting interoceptive, affective, and self-referential processes.

EFFECTS OF PSYCHEDELIC SUBSTANCES ON THE SALIENCE NETWORK AND DEFAULT MODE NETWORK

N,N-DMT, one of the major constituents of ayahuasca, has high affinity to the 5HT2A serotonergic receptor, whereas other constituents such as harmine, harmaline, and tetrahydroharmine act as monoamine oxidase inhibitors and serotonin reuptake inhibitors partially by interacting with the serotonin transporter (5-HTT). A recent molecular neuroimaging study involving positron emission tomography acquired in a large sample of healthy individuals revealed in vivo multimodal density maps of serotonin transporter and major serotonin receptors in the human brain. 5HT2A receptors displayed a widespread pattern of distribution spanning the visual cortex, temporal, parietal, and frontal regions overlapping with major hubs of the salience, default mode, and task-control networks, with density of serotonin transporter highest within frontotemporal regions overlapping with the insula and anterior cingulate cortex. Previous studies investigating psychedelics have reported decreased within-salience network functional coupling during the acute effects of psilocybin. Psilocybin-induced reduced functional connectivity was associated with "ego-dissolution," a construct frequently reported as altered by psychedelics, characterized by the feeling that the border between one's self and the external world is dissolving. Similar studies have reported increased salience network entropy levels during the acute effects of LSD. Ketamine, an N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor antagonist, is a common dissociative anesthetic, which at subanesthetic doses has rapid and sustained antidepressant effects. In both healthy participants and patients with depression, acute ketamine administration has been shown to dampen connectivity of key regions of the salience and default mode networks such as the anterior cingulate and posterior cingulate cortices, whereas connectivity between these regions has been shown to increase post-session in patients. A study investigating the structural correlates of long-term ayahuasca use found increased cortical thickness within the anterior cingulate cortex (a region standing out throughout our analyses) of regular ayahuasca users compared to controls, whereas the cortical thickness of default mode network regions such as the precuneus and posterior cingulate cortex was decreased in long-term ayahuasca users. The salience network has been proposed to orchestrate dynamic switching between mentalizing states anchored on the default mode network and externally driven attentional states anchored on the task-control network to guide behavior by segregating relevant internal and extrapersonal stimuli. Intriguingly, increased global coupling and functional connectivity between salience and default mode network nodes have been found under acute psilocybin administrationand subacutely with ayahuasca, but future work, ideally combining multimodal molecular and functional neuroimaging, is needed to elucidate how mid-and long-term functional interactions of both networks are changed by psychedelic agents.

IMPACT OF PSYCHEDELICS ON INTEROCEPTION, AFFECT, AND SELF-REFERENTIAL PROCESSES

Psychedelic substances modulate blood pressure, body temperature, and heart rateby interacting with the sympathetic and parasympathetic autonomic nervous system, and have been shown to impact emotional and affective functions by improving clinical symptoms in mood disorders. By which mechanisms may ayahuasca mediate changes in interoception, affect, and self-referential processes? Hubs of the salience network, such as the insula and the anterior cingulate, have been consistently associated with emotional processingand dysfunctions in these regions underlie depression and anxiety in various affective disorders. Increased connectivity in the salience network has been associated with early heightened emotional contagion in preclinical Alzheimer's disease, whereas widespread salience network functional and structural degeneration is observed in behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia, a neurodegenerative disease characterized by loss of empathy, socioemotional symptoms, and autonomic dysfunctions. Based on these studies, the salience network has been proposed to support socioemotional-autonomic processing through its interoceptive afferents in the anterior insula processing autonomic activity streams regarding the "moment-tomoment" condition of the body. The anterior cingulate cortex subsequently receives integrated anterior insula input and serves to mobilize visceromotor responses to salient socioemotional stimuli to guide behavior. Critically, our findings of subacute default mode network functional connectivity decreases with ayahuasca are in contrast with a previous study reporting subacute default-mode network connectivity increases with psilocybin in treatment-resistant depression. Previous works have reported both default mode network connectivity increases and decreases in major depression, with heightened connectivity being associated with altered self-referential thoughts such as rumination and negative internal representations. Although in healthy subjects, our findings provide preliminary evidence that ayahuasca may have a sustained effect on dampening functional connectivity of systems involved in self-referential processes associated with the characteristic symptoms of depression. We propose that future studies combining longitudinal tf-fMRI and autonomic recordings in healthy and neuropsychiatric populations could shed light on the acute and long-term impact of psychedelic agents on brain networks supporting interoceptive, affective, and self-referential processes.

LIMITATIONS

An important limitation of our study is the use of liberal voxelwise statistical thresholds when assessing group differences in subacute functional connectivity across distinct brain networks. Recent research has shown that liberal cluster-extend thresholds are prone to inflate false-positive results, questioning the validity of weakly significant neuroimaging findings. The low power attained in our study may have been caused by the small number of participants involved and by the moderate strength of the MRI scanner (1.5 Tesla), urging for future studies involving larger sample sizes and state-of-the-art neuroimaging acquisition. Further, weak effects on functional connectivity were to be expected after a single ayahuasca session in a sample of cognitively healthy participants. Future studies implementing longitudinal sessions and the inclusion of neuropsychiatric populations could help overcome this limitation. We performed, however, several control analyses to mitigate methodological and statistical concerns. First, we assessed the reliability of our findings by controlling for the methodological approach used, which revealed similar functional connectivity changes when comparing findings from the seed-based versus ICA approach. To address concerns related to the liberal statistical threshold, we applied nonparametric permutation tests replicating the main findings in this study. Second, we assessed the impact of head movement on intra-network functional connectivity differences across groups and on the association between altered states of consciousness and subacute functional connectivity changes through the use of partial correlation analyses. These analyses revealed that head movement in the scanner, a common confounder in tf-fMRI studies, did not significantly impact our findings. However, findings of decreased functional connectivity, particularly within the default mode network need to be interpreted with caution, because they did not survive more stringent statistical thresholds. Further, the volition subscale of the HRS has been shown to have a low internal consistency. Given the exploratory nature of the correlational analyses and the associated danger of false-positive inflation, we advise caution in interpreting the association between altered acute levels in the volition scale and subacute default mode network functional connectivity decreases induced by ayahuasca. In particular, both the ayahuasca and the placebo groups exhibited a comparable relationship between changes in default mode network functional connectivity and volition. Although studies suggest the anterior cingulate cortex, rather than posterior brain regions, has a critical role in modulating generalized responses, our findings could potentially reflect general placebo effects.

CONCLUSION

Psychedelic substances have sustained effects on affect and selfreferential processes in healthy and clinical populations days to weeks after dosing. The novelty of our study resides in elucidating the subacute effects of the psychedelic ayahuasca on functional organization of the salience and default mode networks, two brain systems distinctly involved in interoceptive, affective, and self-referential functions. Although primary sensory networks did not show subacute changes in functional connectivity, increased functional connectivity of the salience network 1 day after the session with ayahuasca related to altered acute somesthesia levels, decreases in default mode network functional connectivity related to altered levels of volition, whereas salience network-default mode network connectivity increases related to altered affect levels. Our findings suggest that ayahuasca may have long-lasting effects on mood by modulating those neural circuits supporting interoceptive, affective, and self-referential functions.

Study Details

Your Library