PsilocybinPlacebo

Psilocybin-induced changes in cerebral blood flow are associated with acute and baseline inter-individual differences

This study (n=70) aimed to explore the effects of three oral doses of psilocybin (11-15mg) versus placebo on cerebral blood flow (CBF). Changes in blood flow in the brain caused by psilocybin were different for each person and depended on their initial brain conditions and how they felt during the psychedelic experience. This suggests that people have varying responses in their brains to psilocybin.

Authors

  • Duerler, P.
  • Gubser, L. P.
  • Lewis, C. R.

Published

Scientific Reports
individual Study

Abstract

Research into the use of psilocybin for the treatment of psychiatric disorders is a growing field. Nevertheless, robust brain-behavior relationships linking psilocybin-induced brain changes to subjective drug-induced effects have not been established. Furthermore, it is unclear if the acute neural effects are dependent on individual heterogeneity in baseline characteristics. To address this, we assessed the effects of three oral doses of psilocybin vs. placebo on cerebral blood flow (CBF) using arterial spin labeling in healthy participants (N = 70; n = 31, 0.16 mg/kg; n = 10, 0.2 mg/kg; n = 29, 0.215 mg/kg). First, we quantified psilocybin-induced changes in relative and absolute CBF. Second, in an exploratory analysis, we assessed whether individual baseline characteristics and subjective psychedelic experience are associated with changes in CBF. Psychological and neurobiological baseline characteristics correlated with the psilocybin-induced reduction in relative CBF and the psilocybin-induced subjective experience. Furthermore, the psilocybin-induced subjective experience was associated with acute changes in relative and absolute CBF. The results demonstrated that inter-individual heterogeneity in the neural response to psilocybin is associated with baseline characteristics and shed light on the mechanisms underlying the psychedelic-induced altered state. Overall, these findings help guide the search for biomarkers, paving the way for a personalized medicine approach within the framework of psychedelic-assisted therapy.

Unlocked with Blossom Pro

Research Summary of 'Psilocybin-induced changes in cerebral blood flow are associated with acute and baseline inter-individual differences'

Introduction

Classic psychedelic psilocybin acts primarily as a serotonin 5-HT2A/1A receptor agonist and produces a range of altered conscious states including visual phenomena, synesthesia, feelings of unity, and insightfulness. Prior neuroimaging work has reported widespread acute effects of psychedelics on brain activity and connectivity — for example increased global functional connectivity in sensory areas and altered regional metabolism — but clear, robust brain–behaviour relationships linking psilocybin-induced neural changes to the subjectively reported psychedelic experience remain unresolved. It is also uncertain whether acute neural responses to psilocybin depend on inter-individual baseline characteristics. Rieser and colleagues set out to address these gaps by assessing how oral psilocybin affects cerebral blood flow (CBF) and by testing whether individual baseline neurobiological and psychological measures relate to acute CBF changes and to the subjective psychedelic experience. Using arterial spin labelling (ASL) perfusion MRI in healthy participants, the study aimed to quantify both relative CBF (rCBF), which normalises voxel-wise perfusion to global gray matter perfusion, and absolute CBF (aCBF), and to explore correlations between these imaging measures, baseline psychological traits, and acute subjective effects measured with a standard altered-states questionnaire.

Methods

Data were pooled from three randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, cross-over studies conducted at the Psychiatric University Hospital Zurich. The final analysed sample comprised N = 70 healthy, right-handed adults (mean age 25.3 years, 29 female) who passed medical, psychiatric, and drug-screening assessments; participants with current or lifetime major psychiatric disorders, close family history of such disorders, pregnancy, or more than ten lifetime psychedelic uses were excluded. In the cross-over design each participant received oral placebo and psilocybin in counterbalanced order, with sessions at least 10 days apart. Psilocybin doses administered were 0.16 mg/kg (n = 31), 0.20 mg/kg (n = 10), and 0.215 mg/kg (n = 29); placebo formulations varied across studies but were lactose or mannitol-based. All participants gave informed consent and studies had ethical approval. Behavioural measures included the Symptom Checklist 90-R (SCL-90-R) completed at screening to estimate baseline psychopathological symptoms (global score and subscales) and the Five Dimensional Altered States of Consciousness questionnaire (5D-ASC) completed 360 minutes post administration to capture the acute subjective psychedelic experience across 11 subscales and a global score. Neuroimaging used a Philips 3 T scanner with T1-weighted anatomy and pseudo-continuous ASL (pCASL) acquired 80–100 minutes after drug administration; sequence parameters and image resolutions varied slightly across participants and studies. Standard preprocessing steps were applied (realignment, smoothing, perfusion calculation, normalization to MNI space); three participants were excluded for extreme T2*-corrected gray matter CBF values and one for failed co-registration, yielding the reported final sample. CBF quantification produced voxel-wise aCBF maps and rCBF maps, the latter obtained by dividing each voxel's aCBF by the individual's mean gray-matter CBF within a gray-matter mask. Statistical analyses first tested for dose effects using one-way ANOVAs; because dose did not significantly affect CBF outcomes, dose was not included in subsequent analyses. Paired t-tests compared psilocybin versus placebo for voxel-wise rCBF and aCBF with cluster-level family-wise error (FWE) correction (p < 0.05, primary voxelwise p < 0.001, k > 250); a more conservative peak-level threshold was used for aCBF clusters. Extracted cluster eigenvalues (psilocybin minus placebo) were Pearson-correlated with behavioural measures. To examine whether baseline (placebo) CBF related to psilocybin-induced changes without mathematical coupling, the Oldham method was used, correlating the mean of the two measurements with their difference. Correlations were treated as exploratory and reported at p < 0.05 uncorrected.

Results

Imaging comparisons revealed both increases and decreases in rCBF after psilocybin versus placebo. Increased rCBF was observed in frontal and limbic regions, notably the inferior frontal gyrus and hippocampus (cluster-level pFWE < 0.05). Decreased rCBF was detected predominantly in parietal regions (postcentral gyrus) and temporal cortex (superior temporal gyrus); the temporal lobe showed a mixed pattern with increased rCBF in the fusiform gyrus alongside decreases in the superior temporal gyrus. For absolute perfusion, no psilocybin-induced increases were found; instead, aCBF showed widespread decreases in parietal (postcentral gyrus, rolandic operculum), limbic (putamen), and frontal regions (middle frontal gyrus), with these clusters surviving FWE correction. Dose did not significantly affect the CBF outcomes, and body weight showed no consistent influence on rCBF once dose was accounted for; an initial partial correlation suggested a negative association between body weight and decreased aCBF (r = -0.33, p = 0.005), but a full-brain regression did not identify a significant effect and body weight was not included thereafter. Behavioural–neural correlations produced several associations centred on the inferior frontal gyrus (IFG). Baseline global symptom severity (SCL-90-R global score) correlated positively with psilocybin-induced increased rCBF in the right IFG (r = 0.25, p = 0.034), indicating larger rCBF increases in participants reporting higher baseline symptom levels. Multiple 5D-ASC measures correlated with increased rCBF in the IFG: the 5D-ASC global score (r = 0.30, p = 0.001), experience of unity (r = 0.26, p = 0.029), disembodiment (right IFG r = 0.33, p = 0.005; left IFG r = 0.24, p = 0.048), and complex imagery (right IFG r = 0.29, p = 0.016; left IFG r = 0.26, p = 0.031). A single participant with an extreme score drove the impaired control and cognition correlation; exclusion of that participant rendered the association non-significant. For aCBF, elementary imagery was negatively correlated with reduced aCBF in the left postcentral gyrus (r = -0.25, p = 0.04), meaning higher elementary imagery corresponded to a stronger decrease in aCBF in that region. Examining baseline neurobiology, placebo rCBF in regions later showing psilocybin-induced increases was positively associated with the magnitude of psilocybin-induced rCBF increases: participants with higher placebo rCBF in the inferior frontal gyrus and hippocampus showed larger psilocybin-induced rCBF increases (r = 0.46, p < 0.001). No significant associations were found between placebo and psilocybin values for decreased rCBF (r = 0.05, p = 0.652) or aCBF changes (r = 0.07, p = 0.584). Finally, placebo CBF measures correlated with some subjective outcomes: placebo rCBF in the left IFG showed a modest negative association with disembodiment (r = -0.24, p = 0.049), and placebo aCBF in the left postcentral gyrus was positively associated with reported audio-visual synesthesia (r = 0.24, p = 0.046). Correlation analyses were exploratory and reported without correction for multiple comparisons.

Discussion

Rieser and colleagues interpret their findings as evidence that both baseline neurobiological organisation and baseline psychological state relate to the acute neural and subjective effects of psilocybin. The pattern of results replicates earlier reports of psilocybin-induced rCBF increases in frontal and limbic regions and decreases in parietal regions, while temporal regions showed heterogeneous effects. The authors highlight the inferior frontal gyrus as a focal region linking psilocybin-induced neural changes to subjective phenomena: increased rCBF in the IFG was associated with stronger reports of unity, disembodiment, complex visual imagery, and other 5D-ASC dimensions. They suggest the IFG's known involvement in emotion recognition, empathy and bodily awareness may help explain why activity changes there correlate with emotional and perceptual aspects of the psychedelic experience. Baseline rCBF measured under placebo was also predictive: participants with higher resting rCBF in frontal cortices and hippocampus exhibited larger psilocybin-induced rCBF increases, leading the authors to propose baseline rCBF as a candidate predictive biomarker for individual sensitivity to psilocybin's neural effects. They link this to prior work showing that baseline BOLD connectivity can predict psychedelic-induced connectivity changes and propose exploring baseline measures in clinical trials as part of a personalised-medicine approach. The discussion also contrasts rCBF and aCBF findings, noting that rCBF (after global normalisation) appeared more sensitive to brain–behaviour associations, and addresses the methodological debate about global signal removal in perfusion studies. The authors acknowledge several limitations: analyses were exploratory and not corrected for multiple comparisons, so results require replication in hypothesis-driven work; the correlational design precludes directional or causal inferences; and single measurements of baseline and psilocybin conditions may be affected by intra-individual variability, so repeated measures could improve reliability. They position the study as a large ASL dataset that narrows knowledge gaps about how baseline characteristics and acute subjective states relate to psilocybin-induced CBF changes and as a basis for future investigations into mechanisms and predictive biomarkers for psychedelic-assisted therapy.

View full paper sections

RESULTS

To assess whether dose impacts CBF outcome, we conducted three one-way ANOVAs to compare the effect of dose (0.6 mg/kg, 0.2 mg/kg, 0.215 mg/kg) on CBF (increased rCBF, decreased rCBF, decreased aCBF). In a first step, using the Levene's test, we assessed the homogeneity of variances of the groups. The variances of the groups were equal (increased rCBF: F(1, 67) = 0.143, p = 0.867; decreased rCBF: F(1,67) = 0.671, p = 0.515; decreased aCBF: F(1,67) = 0.739, p = 0.481). The one-way ANOVAs revealed no statistically significant difference in rCBF and aCBF between different doses. More specifically; increased rCBF resulted in F(1,67) = 1.595; p = 0.211; decreased rCBF in F(1,67) = 2.387; p = 0.09, and decreased aCBF revealed F(1,67) = 0.236; p = 0.79. Therefore, dose was not taken into account in further analyses. The unthresholded difference maps between the participants receiving the low (0.16 mg/kg) and high dose (0.215 mg/kg) are presented in the Supplementary Fig.. To assess whether body weight influences CBF, we ran a partial correlation between body weight and CBF, correcting for dose. In line with a previous publication, which was based on a subsample of the current data, no relationship between body weight and rCBF, corrected for dose, was revealed (see Supplementary Fig.). However, we found a significant association between body weight and decreased aCBF, corrected for dose (r = -0.33, p = 0.005, see Supplementary Fig.). To further investigate this, we conducted a full brain multiple regression analysis on the effect of bodyweight on aCBF. The analysis showed no effect of bodyweight on aCBF (p FWE < 0.05). Given these results together with a previous publication reporting no influence of body weight on pharmacokinetics, body weight was not taken into account in the following analyses. Lastly, scatterplots reporting the association between dose, 5D-ASC global score, and CBF-changes are presented in Supplementary Fig.. For the second level analysis, a paired sample t-test was applied to compare psilocybin vs. placebo conditions. We report significant changes with a threshold of p < 0.05 cluster-level FWE corrected with a primary threshold of p < 0.001, k > 250. To avoid the merging of clusters, a peak-level threshold of p < 0.05 (FWE-corrected) and k > 100 was used for aCBF. The eigenvalues from each significant cluster were exported (psilocybin-placebo) and Pearson-correlated with behavioral measures (SCL-90-R and 5D-ASC). Next, we investigated whether interindividual variation in placebo CBF was related to the strength of psilocybin-induced changes in CBF. For placebo measures, the Oldham's method (OH) was used to avoid the problem of mathematical coupling due to repeated measurement in the same participants. To this end, we used the mean of the two measurements and their difference. Thus, we correlated the averaged psilocybin-induced increased rCBF, decreased rCBF, and decreased aCBF with the corresponding values following placebo ((placebo CBF + psilocybin CBF)/2), (OH). Lastly, we assessed the relationship between placebo CBF in clusters that were significantly altered by psilocybin and subjectively experienced altered state of consciousness following psilocybin using Pearson-correlations. R was used for statistical analyses of behavioral and neural correlations and the package corrplot (version 0.92) for the correlation matrices. Correlations were considered significant at p < 0.05 (two-tailed). Given the exploratory nature of this correlation analysis, no correction for multiple comparisons was applied.

CONCLUSION

Psilocybin is increasingly investigated in the treatment of psychiatric disorders (e.g.). To understand its mechanisms of action, various brain imaging studies have started to shed light on acute neurobiological changes induced by psilocybin (e.g.). However, we still lack an understanding of how these acute changes relate to subjective drug effects. Furthermore, it is unclear whether individual baseline characteristics are related to the neurobiological effects induced by psilocybin. To help narrow these knowledge gaps, we leveraged the largest neuroimaging dataset to date collected under the acute influence of three different doses of psilocybin, including 70 healthy participants assessed with ASL. We investigated whether altered brain CBF is related to individual baseline characteristics and the psilocybin-induced altered state of consciousness. We show that: (1) psychological and neurobiological baseline characteristics are associated with psilocybin-induced increases in rCBF, (2) acute subjective effects correlate with changes in rCBF and aCBF, and (3) acute subjective experiences are linked to baseline CBF. In line with a previous publication, which was based on a subsample of the current data, we show that psilocybin acutely increases rCBF in frontal and limbic brain regions, and decreases rCBF mainly in parietal regions. In temporal regions, both increased and decreased rCBF was observed. Specifically, increased rCBF in temporal regions included the fusiform gyrus and decreased rCBF involved the superior temporal gyrus. Interestingly, psilocybin-induced changes in BOLD rsfMRI connectivity were reported in overlapping brain areas, namely hyperconnectivity in the left postcentral gyrus and right superior temporal gyrus. While Preller et al.reported hyperconnectivity in these regions, the present study shows that psilocybin decreases rCBF in the same brain areas. Therefore, future studies should investigate whether alterations in rCBF are coupled with psilocybin-induced changes in the synchronization of brain regions. Without adjusting for global brain perfusion, we found wide-spread decreases in aCBF in parietal, limbic, and frontal regions, which is in line with previous studies that administered psilocybin orallyand intravenous. Regressing out global signal perfusion as a confound or nuisance variable in fMRI analyses addresses artefacts such as head motion, respiration, cardiac rhythms, and scanner-related artifacts. Global signal removal remains an ongoing debate, especially regarding resting-state BOLD data. For pharmacological ASL it has become common practice to control for global signal and report analyses with and without a global signal covariate (e.g.). Controlling for the global signal in ASL studies has been shown to improve reproducibility and signal-to-noise ratio in particular when measuring drug effects. This is in line with our current results, showing that rCBF is more sensitive to brain-behavior associations (see below). To investigate whether neurobiological characteristics are associated with psilocybin-induced changes in CBF, we quantified the correlation between placebo CBF and changes in CBF induced by psilocybin. While we did not find any associations between placebo aCBF and psilocybin-induced changes in aCBF, placebo rCBF was positively correlated with increased psilocybin-induced rCBF. Specifically, participants with high rCBF in the frontal brain cortices and hippocampus in their regular waking state showed the strongest increase in rCBF under psilocybin. Therefore, baseline rCBF after placebo administration could be a predictive marker of the intensity of psilocybin-induced neuronal effects. This is in line with a recent study showing that placebo BOLD rsfMRI connectivity is associated with psilocybin-induced changes in connectivity. Together, these results suggest that the effects of psilocybin may depend on measurable blood flow characteristics of the organization of each individual's brain. While it is still unclear how acute psilocybin-induced effects map onto symptom improvements in clinical populations, in line with a personalized medicine approach, baseline rCBF should be explored as a predictive biomarker in clinical studies to identify patients most likely to benefit from psychedelic-assisted therapy. In a next step, we explored the correlation between behavioral and neural effects. We found that the inferior frontal gyrus plays a key role in psilocybin-induced behavioral effects. We analyzed the association between baseline psychological state markers and acute changes in CBF. Self-rated psychological symptoms at baseline were correlated with psilocybin-induced increased rCBF in the right inferior frontal gyrus. Specifically, participants with higher levels of symptoms showed greater increases in rCBF. Although we investigated healthy participants who did not score high on these scales, it is possible that baseline psychological states may influence the acute reaction to psychedelics in patient populations. Given that acute subjective psilocybin-induced effects have not consistently been linked to neural effects, next, we explored the correlation between changes in CBF and subjective alterations of consciousness. Increased rCBF in the inferior frontal gyrus was related to experience of unity, disembodiment, impaired control and cognition, and complex imagery. Several studies showed the involvement of the inferior frontal gyrus in language processing, motor control, and more recently also in the processing of empathy. More specifically, the inferior frontal gyrus has been associated with emotion recognition, their evaluation, and emotional empathy. Given that psychedelics lead to increased emotional empathy (e.g.) and the consistent connection between inferior frontal gyrus and behavioral effects shown in this paper, the inferior frontal gyrus might be an underlying driving force for increasing emotional empathy by triggering disembodiment and visual imagery. However, the association between empathy, behavioral, and neural effects needs to be tested in future studies to gain understanding of the underlying processes. Participants with increased self-reported experience of unity showed increased rCBF in the right inferior frontal gyrus. Experience of unity or feelings of unity is considered a subdimension of mystical-type experiences. This type of experience has been reported by some participants after the administration of psychedelics. While experience of unity itself has not been shown to be related to therapeutic effects, the mystical-type experience has. Experiencing a strong psychological effect including insight, blissfulness, and feelings of unity has been associated with symptom decrease in depression, substance use disorder, and anxiety (i.e.. It is therefore possible that changes in activity of the inferior frontal gyrus contribute to clinical efficacy of psychedelics. In addition, participants experiencing high visual imagery showed high psilocybin-induced rCBF in the right and left inferior frontal gyrus. Historically, visual alterations induced by psychedelic substances have mainly been associated with changes in visual networks. More specifically, the intensity of visual alterations was linked to LSD-induced resting-state functional connectivity (i) within the primary visual cortexand (ii) between the thalamus and the fusiform gyrus. Increased aCBF in the visual cortex was associated with experiencing complex imagery after LSD administration. Our results demonstrate that increased rCBF in frontal brain regions also contributes to visual alterations. The involvement of frontal regions in visual imagery has also been reported in previous studies. In particular, increased elementary imagery was associated with reduced BOLD activation in the left superior frontal gyrus and right precentral gyrus in response to a Go/No-Go task. Furthermore, elementary imagery was negatively associated with aCBF in the left postcentral gyrus. Participants reporting stronger visual changes showed a stronger decrease of aCBF in this region. Alterations in activity and connectivity of the postcentral gyrus have repeatedly been reported after the administration of psychedelic substances (e.g.), however, they have not been linked to psychedelic-induced visual alterations, yet. From a psychiatric perspective, patients with addiction, major depression, or anxiety often exhibit an imbalance of visual imagery, such as diminished positive imagery and reduced vividness. The subsequent elicited negative emotions associated with imagery strengthen maladaptive behavior patterns such as rumination, avoidance, and suppression. The beneficial effects of therapeutic approaches that target visual imagery in clinical settings underpin the importance of imagery in psychiatric disorders, i.e. therapeutic approaches that include imagery rescripting or promoting positive imagery. As psychedelics consistently induce visual alterations, strengthening visual imagery during and after the acute experience may increase its therapeutic potential. In addition, participants reporting higher ratings of disembodiment showed increased rCBF in the left and right inferior frontal gyrus. The inferior frontal gyrus has been discussed in heautoscopy, which is the reduplication of one's body, meaning to see one's body at a distance. Furthermore, lesion studies revealed its relation to somatoparaphrenia, where a patient beliefs that a limb does not belong to their body. Therefore, our findings are coherent with the notion of the inferior frontal gyrus being involved in bodily awareness. Lastly, we investigated whether subjective psilocybin-induced effects are related to inter-individual differences in CBF without pharmacological challenge. Placebo CBF was associated with acutely experienced, psilocybin-induced disembodiment and audio-visual synesthesia. In combination with the finding above, both baseline and acute rCBF in the inferior frontal gyrus were associated with psilocybin-induced disembodiment. Therefore, experiencing disembodiment might be partially driven by baseline neural characteristics. Audio-visual synesthetic experiences can occur without any intervention in some people or can be induced experimentally. Psychedelics often induce audio-visual synesthesia even in participants who are not experiencing any synesthesia during their regular conscious state (e.g.). The underlying mechanisms, however, remain largely unknown. One explanation suggests that drug-induced synesthesia is based on the destabilized thalamic projections of sensory inputs leading to an inaccurate integration of multisensory stimuli. The second explanation is based on the assumption that non-synaesthetes suppress other sensory senses that are associated with the stimuli. Following psychedelics, the inhibition of other senses may be reversed by a decreased attentional discrimination towards incoming stimuli and induce the experienced synesthesia. Our results suggest that the strength of experiencing audio-visual synesthesia following psilocybin administration may be explained by inter-individual differences in the baseline organization of the individual's brain. Given that parietal structures including the postcentral gyrus-which was also related to synesthesia under psilocybin in this study-have been identified to differ functionally between audio-visual synaesthetes and matched controls, it is possible that individuals who are more prone to experiencing synesthesia also have stronger psilocybin-induced synesthetic effects. The following limitations need to be acknowledged: Given the exploratory nature of the study, we did not correct our analyses for multiple comparisons. Furthermore, the correlational analysis does not allow for directional interpretation of the effects. Therefore, this work serves as a basis for future targeted, hypothesis-driven investigations. Lastly, we are evaluating single measurements of baseline and psilocybin conditions. Intra-individual variations may affect results and repeated measurement of both placebo and psilocybin conditions may increase reliability and reproducibility. The present study replicated previous findings of psilocybin-induced changes in CBFand demonstrated that baseline psychological symptoms and rCBF are associated with a psilocybin-induced increases in rCBF. Furthermore, acutely experienced feelings of unity, disembodiment, and visual imagery were correlated with altered rCBF and aCBF following psilocybin. In addition, variation in placebo CBF was associated with the strength of psilocybin-induced disembodiment and visual-auditory synesthesia. These results help to narrow down key knowledge gaps in our understanding of the relationship between behavioral measures and psilocybin-induced alterations in brain CBF, and thus point to potential mechanisms of action of psychedelics and baseline CBF as

Study Details

Your Library