PTSDAyahuascaAyahuasca

Prevalence and therapeutic impact of adverse life event reexperiencing under ceremonial ayahuasca

Among 339 ayahuasca retreat participants, reexperiencing of adverse life events during ceremonies was common—particularly sexual assault among women, combat trauma among veterans and in those with lifetime PTSD—and was linked to cognitive reappraisal, psychological flexibility and acute discomfort. Those who reexperienced adverse events showed larger reductions in trait neuroticism at follow-up, suggesting such reexperiencing may contribute to the therapeutic effects of ceremonial ayahuasca.

Authors

  • Campbell, W. K.
  • Erritzoe, D.
  • Weiss, B.

Published

Scientific Reports
individual Study

Abstract

AbstractThe present study examined the safety and efficacy of the ceremonial use of ayahuasca in relation to reports of heightened life event reexperiencing under psychedelics. The study examined (1) the prevalence of specific types of adverse life event reexperiencing, (2) characteristics predictive of reexperiencing, (3) the psychological character of reexperiencing, and (4) the impact of reexperiencing on mental health. Participants were recruited from three ayahuasca healing and spiritual centers in South and Central America (N = 33 military veterans, 306 non-veterans) using self-report data at three timepoints (Pre-retreat, Post-retreat, 3-months post-retreat). Reexperiencing adverse life events under ayahuasca was common, with women showing particularly high probability of reexperiencing sexual assault, veterans reexperiencing combat-related trauma, and individuals with a self-reported lifetime diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder exhibiting a substantively higher prevalence of reexperiencing. Reexperiencing was associated with states of cognitive reappraisal, psychological flexibility, and discomfort during ceremonies, and participants who reexperienced adverse life events exhibited greater reductions in trait neuroticism following their ceremonies. Clinical implications of these results for the application of psychedelics to mood and stress disorders are discussed.

Unlocked with Blossom Pro

Research Summary of 'Prevalence and therapeutic impact of adverse life event reexperiencing under ceremonial ayahuasca'

Introduction

As psychedelic therapies gain acceptance as tools for mental health care, important questions about safety and efficacy in relation to individual vulnerability factors remain incompletely addressed. One such factor is the potential for psychedelic experiences — particularly at moderate to high doses — to surface autobiographical memories of adverse life events, including trauma. Understanding whether such reexperiencing occurs, who is most susceptible, and what its psychological consequences are has direct relevance to screening, preparation, and support protocols in both ceremonial and clinical settings. This study examined the prevalence of adverse life event reexperiencing during ayahuasca ceremonies, identified demographic and clinical characteristics predictive of reexperiencing, and evaluated whether reexperiencing confers therapeutic benefit or poses psychological harm, using a prospective design in a naturalistic retreat sample.

Methods

Three hundred and fifty-one participants were recruited from three ayahuasca retreat centres across South and Central America, with the assistance of centre intake directors and the Heroic Hearts Project. Participants completed pre-ceremony questionnaires and post-ceremony follow-ups. Adverse life events were assessed using an adapted nine-item version of the Life Event Checklist for DSM-5 (LEC-5), covering categories including natural disaster, transportation accident, physical and sexual assault, illness or injury, loss of loved ones, and combat. Participants retrospectively reported whether specific adverse life events were reexperienced during ceremonies. Lifetime PTSD diagnosis was self-reported. Neuroticism was assessed at baseline and at post-ceremony and three-month follow-up. Ceremonial characteristics (intensity of experience, ayahuasca dose) were also recorded. Statistical analyses included logistic regression for predictors of reexperiencing and moderation analyses for the effect of reexperiencing on neuroticism change.

Results

Of the valid sample of 339 participants, a substantial proportion reported reexperiencing adverse life events during ayahuasca ceremonies. Participants with a self-reported lifetime PTSD diagnosis reported all adverse life event types at significantly higher rates and showed significantly higher rates of ceremony-induced reexperiencing (X² = 6.83, p = 0.024) than those without a PTSD diagnosis. Women were significantly more likely than men to reexperience adverse life events during ceremonies, a difference driven substantially by women's higher rate of reexperiencing sexual assault. Across the full sample, a significant reduction in neuroticism was observed from baseline to post-ceremony and three-month follow-up. Critically, participants who reported reexperiencing adverse life events during ceremonies showed at least as large a reduction in neuroticism as those who did not, with moderation analyses indicating that reexperiencing did not attenuate — and may have enhanced — the ceremonial reduction in neuroticism. This pattern was consistent in both post-ceremony and three-month follow-up assessments.

Discussion

The finding that adverse life event reexperiencing is relatively common during ayahuasca ceremonies — particularly among individuals with a PTSD history and women who have experienced sexual assault — has important implications for the screening, preparation, and facilitation practices of both ceremonial and clinical psychedelic programmes. The heightened vulnerability of these groups suggests that dedicated trauma-informed preparation and support are warranted. However, the observation that reexperiencing was associated with equivalent or greater reductions in neuroticism challenges a simplistic harm model. The data are more consistent with a therapeutic model in which psychedelic-facilitated recontact with adverse memories, in a supportive ceremonial context, may promote psychological processing and adjustment. This interpretation is consistent with qualitative accounts from ayahuasca users and with theoretical models of psychedelic therapy that emphasise the adaptive function of emotionally significant material arising during the experience. Limitations include the absence of a control condition and reliance on retrospective self-report of adverse life events.

Conclusion

This prospective study demonstrates that adverse life event reexperiencing during ayahuasca ceremonies is prevalent, particularly among women and those with a lifetime PTSD diagnosis, and that it appears to confer therapeutic benefit — evidenced by greater reductions in neuroticism — rather than psychological harm. These findings underscore the importance of trauma-informed screening and facilitation in psychedelic contexts and support the view that emotionally significant material arising during psychedelic ceremonies may play a constructive role in the psychological changes that follow.

View full paper sections

METHODS

Study procedure, recruitment, and participants. Three-hundred-fifty-one participants were recruited from three ayahuasca retreat centers across South and Central America: Arkana Spiritual Center (Requena, Loreto, Peru), Soltara Healing Center (Gulf of Nicoya, Costa Rica), and La Medicina (Cordilliera Escalera mountain range, Peru) with the assistance of center intake directors and the Heroic Hearts Project, which sponsors alternative mental healthcare options for veterans. Participants were emailed two weeks before the date of their ayahuasca retreat with an invitation to enroll. In the recruitment consent form, participants were informed that some of the study questionnaires would include questions relating to previous "traumatic experiences" and to "their experiences during the use of ayahuasca in ritual context. " They were informed that some of the questions may be sensitive in nature, and that they had the ability to opt out of answering any questions they did not feel comfortable answering for any reason. Inclusion criteria included being above 18 years of age. Participants were informed that they would be compensated with entry into a raffle for a week-long retreat (valued at $1580.00). Further monetary incentives of $20.00 and $30.00 were additionally offered with the second and third survey reminders, respectively, to promote compliance and reduce attrition. On average, study surveys were administered nine days before the retreat start date (baseline), five days after the retreat end date (post), and three months following the retreat end date (~ ± 114 days after retreat end date; follow-up). Data was collected using online surveys supported by the Qualtrics web platform. For full details on study design and procedure, see Weiss and colleagues. All participants provided online informed consent in accordance with the Common Rule and the Declaration of Helsinki. All procedures were performed in accordance with the relevant guidelines and regulations of the University of Georgia Institutional Review Board.

RESULTS

Participant sample. Of 351 participants who were recruited, 2% (N = 6) did not meet the validity criteria (see Measures), and 2% (N = 6) did not report on previous adverse life events, leaving a final sample of 339 validly responding participants with adverse life event information. Three-hundred-thirteen participants of these responded at baseline and at least one subsequent time point (i.e., post, 3-months post-experience), and were thus eligible for prospective analyses. Sample size was originally determined on the basis of obtaining statistical power to detect a change in trait neuroticism of at least 0.20 standard deviations. Non-veteran sample. The final non-veteran sample consisted of 306 participants. Two-hundred-eighty-one participants of these responded at baseline and at least one subsequent time point, and were thus eligible for prospective analyses (mean age = 34.97 ± 10.03; ethnicity: 91% non-Hispanic White, 2% Black, 6% Asian American/Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander, 7% Latinx, and 3% Indian). Because a larger number of participants reported on two timepoints versus all three, datasets were used to examine the change between baseline and post (N full = 273; N adverse life events endorsing = 229), and baseline and 3-month follow-up (N full = 249; N adverse life events endorsing = 207). The sample consisted of 183 participants who self-identified as males (N adverse life events endorsing = 153) and 121 who self-identified as females (N adverse life events endorsing = 106). Approximately 19% of participants reported an annual income of less than $30,000, 29% reported annual income greater than $30,000 but less than $60,000, 15% reported greater than $60,000 but less than $90,000, and 31% greater than $90,000. Approximately 28% of participants reported completing some high school, 38% reported graduating high school, 16% reported completing some college, and 17% reported obtaining at least a bachelor's degree. Approximately 11% of participants had self-reported diagnoses of major depression, 4% with PTSD, and 5% with anxiety disorder. Veteran sample. The final veteran sample consisted of 33 participants. Thirty-two participants of these responded at baseline and at least one subsequent time point, and were thus eligible for prospective analyses (N = 30 at baseline and post, N = 30 at baseline and 3-month follow-up; mean age = 34.97, SD ± 10.03; ethnicity: 97% non-Hispanic White, 15% Latinx, and 6% Indian). The sample consisted of 30 participants who self-identified as males and three as self-identified females. In total, 16 Army veterans (including two Green Berets, seven Rangers, one Special Air Serviceman, one Mortarman), 10 Marine veterans (including one Scout Sniper), three Navy veterans (including two SEALs), two Air Force veterans (including two Pararescuers), one Canadian Army special forces veteran, and one British Army Special Air Service veteran participated in retreats. Fifty-two-percent of the sample had a special operations forces background, 85% of veterans reported combat exposure, and 67% of veterans disclosed a lifetime PTSD diagnosis. Diagnosis was not directly assessed by study personnel. Approximately 15% of participants reported an annual income of less than $30,000, 30% reported annual income greater than $30,000 but less than $60,000, 15% reported greater than $60,000 but less than $90,000, and 39% greater than $90,000. Approximately 33% of participants reported completing some high school, 36% reported graduating high school, 15% reported completing some college, and 15% reported obtaining at least a bachelor's degree. Approximately 24% of participants had self-reported diagnoses of major depression, 67% post-traumatic stress disorder, and 12% anxiety disorder. Examining the prevalence of adverse life events and reexperiencing. Non-veteran sample. Of the 306 non-veteran participants, the majority (85%) reported previous experiences of ALEs, and 53% reported previous experiences of severe ALEs. The most prevalent ALE was stressful experience, reported by 54% of participants, whereas the most prevalent severe ALE was loss of a significant other, reported by 35% of participants. The most commonly reported ALEs ranged from 5% (perpetration) to 54% (stressful experience). Of the 85% of non-veteran participants who endorsed a previous ALE, 42% reported reexperiencing a previous ALE during their ceremony experiences while under the acute effects of ayahuasca (mean intensity 3.94 ± 0.94). Of the 53% of participants who endorsed previous experiences of severe ALEs, 27% reported reexperiencing a severe ALE during ceremony (mean intensity 3.92 ± 1.07). The proportion of ALE-endorsing participants who reported reexperiencing at least one ALE ranged from 2% (disaster) to 39% (stressful experience). The proportion of severe ALE-endorsing participants who reported reexperiencing at least one severe ALE ranged from 2% (disaster) to 33% (sexual assault). Notably, among severe ALE types, sexual assault carried the highest reexperiencing rate, such that among the 17% of participants endorsing previous sexual assault, 33% reported reexperiencing during ayahuasca ceremony (mean intensity = 3.86 ± 0.95). Sexually uncomfortable experiences were endorsed by 32% of participants, with 24% reexperiencing (mean intensity 3.38 ± 1.28). Figureand Tableillustrate the percentage of experiencing and reexperiencing associated with each ALE type and the mean intensity of participants' recollections. Veteran sample. Of the 33 veteran participants, all reported experiencing severe ALEs prior to their participation in the study. The most commonly reported ALEs ranged from 15% (sexual assault) to 88% (stressful experience). Six of the nine ALE types were endorsed by more than 50% of veterans, including disaster, accident, physical assault, loss, perpetration, and stressful experience. Fifty-nine percent of veterans reported reexperiencing an ALE during ceremonies (mean intensity 3.79 ± 1.18), and 47% reported reexperiencing a severe ALE (mean intensity 3.95 ± 1.33). The proportion of ALE-endorsing participants who reported reexperiencing at least one ALE ranged from 0% (sexual assault) to 54% (loss). Veterans reported reexperiencing illness/injury, loss, and perpetration at a proportion above 50%. Figureand Tableprovide detailed results. Comparing the prevalence of adverse life events and reexperiencing between veterans and non-veterans. Veterans reported previous severe ALEs at significantly higher rates than non-veterans. Higher prevalence was observed for ALEs including disaster, accident, physical assault, illness/injury, loss, perpetration, and stressful experience (p < 0.005). Veterans also exhibited a higher rate of reexperiencing severe ALEs (X 2 = 12.09, p = 0.004), disaster (X 2 = 37.34, p < 0.001), accident (X 2 = 18.80, p < 0.001), physical assault (X 2 = 13.73, p = 0.001), illness/injury (X 2 = 20.32, p < 0.001), loss (X 2 = 24.25, p < 0.001), and perpetration (X 2 = 36.23, p < 0.001). Figure, Table Comparing the prevalence of adverse life events and reexperiencing between males and females. Male and female non-veteran participants were relatively similar in their reporting of previous ALE history. Of the 121 female participants, 88% endorsed at least one ALE, and 57% of women reported reexperiencing at least one severe ALE. Of the 183 male participants, 84% endorsed at least one ALE, and 52% endorsed at least one severe ALE. However, female participants exhibited a higher prevalence of previous ALEs involving sexual assault (32% vs 7% for males; X 2 = 30.69, p < 0.001), and sexually uncomfortable experience (52% vs 20% for males; X 2 = 33.35, p < 0.001). Females generally reexperienced ALEs (57% females vs 32% males; X 2 = 9.99, p = 0.008) at significantly higher rates than males. Contributing to this pattern, female participants reexperienced sexual assault at a significantly higher rate (41% females vs 10% males; X 2 = 14.73, p = 0.001). The veteran sample only included three individuals who identified as female; therefore, comparisons could not be validly undertaken. All three female participants reported previous sexual assault and sexually uncomfortable experience. However, reexperiencing rates could not be validly estimated as only one woman (33%) reported re-experiencing sexually uncomfortable behaviour, whereas two out of three did not volunteer a response. Figure, Table, and Tablesandpresent these results.

CONCLUSION

Using a large sample of ayahuasca retreat-goers, the present study set out to investigate whether ceremonial ayahuasca promotes autobiographical reexperiencing of adverse life events, how well reexperiencing can be predicted from individual characteristics, and the impact of reexperiencing on mental health. Understanding psychedelic-induced autobiographical reexperiencing holds substantial clinical relevance as recollections of adverse or traumatic events could pose psychological harm under unsupportive conditions, and/or may hold therapeutic value within the context of trauma-focused psychedelic treatment. Does psychedelic experience in the ceremonial ayahuasca context amplify autobiographical reexperiencing of adverse life events? Our principle finding was that reexperiencing adverse life events was common among all participants, with four in ten non-veteran participants reporting reexperiencing of adverse life events, and over a quarter reporting reexperiencing of more severe adverse life events, i.e., excluding stressful experiences and sexually uncomfortable experiences. These observations are consistent with observations from clinical trialsand naturalistic studiesof autobiographical reexperiencing under psilocybin and ayahuasca. Participants notably rated their reexperiences at a relatively high intensity (i.e., average rating of 3.94 out of 5 for adverse life events), which is consistent with Carhart-Harris and colleagues'observations of functional hyperactivation of visual and sensory brain areas and vivid subjective recollections under LSD when cued to recollect autobiographical memories. Our observations are the first to show the relative prevalence of different types of adverse life event reexperiencing. Approximately a quarter or more of non-veteran participants reexperienced sexual assault, sexually uncomfortable events, loss of significant others, and general stressful experiences. The contents of participants' reexperiences was not precisely examined in our study, but participants who reported reexperiencing were more likely to report experiences of discomfort, as well as constructive engagement with challenging emotional material during ceremony (i.e., reappraisal, psychological flexibility), including discovering positive meaning in past trauma and feeling gratitude for previous life challenges. Although these associations could be suggestive that psychedelic reexperiencing is generally characterized by qualities of reappraisal and discomfort, it could also be the case that psychedelic experiences of reappraisal and discomfort prime the emergence of adverse life event recollections. The latter possibility is supported by evidence that negative mood states promote mood-congruent (i.e., negative) memories (;c.f.), and the fact that acute experiences of reappraisal and discomfort were measured globally (i.e., degree of acute experience), whereas reexperiencing was measured discretely (i.e., presence or absence of discrete episodes). Given that reexperiencing has been associated in the literature with multiple substances that share serotonergic 2A agonism as a cellular mechanism of action, we believe the present findings respecting ayahuasca are likely to generalize to other classic psychedelic substances. Nevertheless, other factors associated with the use of ayahuasca may influence the emergence of autobiographical memories, including ceremonial elements, group context, molecules unique to ayahuasca (e.g., harmine), and/or spiritual forces (recognized within Shipibo metaphysics).

Study Details

Your Library