Meditation Trips: A Thematic Analysis of the Combined Naturalistic Use of Psychedelics With Meditation Practices
This survey study (n=1315) of psychedelic users finds that a majority (67%) also meditated and nearly 40% combined both. From written accounts (n=256), six themes were identified, including compatibility between states, enhancement of experiences, positive changes in relating to the world, negative effects, meditation as a preparatory tool, and contextual considerations. Findings suggest meditation techniques could facilitate combining psychedelics, enabling lower, therapeutically important doses.
Authors
- Azmoodeh, K.
- Kamboj, S. K.
- Thomas, E.
Published
Abstract
Similarities between meditative and psychedelic states have long been recognized. Recently, parallels in the psychological mechanisms mediating the beneficial effects of mindfulness and psychedelic treatments-as well as their potential therapeutic complementarity-have been noted. However, empirical research in this area remains limited. Here, we explore the naturalistic use of meditation practices among psychedelic users recruited outside of treatment/retreat or research settings. Participants with ≥1 psychedelic drug experience(s) were included in an online survey. The majority (n = 875; 66.5%) indicated that they engaged in meditation, 39.4% (n = 345) of whom had combined psychedelic use with meditation practices on ≥1 occasion. The majority (74.2%; n = 256) provided written accounts describing their experiences of “psychedelic-meditation,” which were the basis for the present thematic analytic study. Six overarching themes were identified: (1) Compatibility Between Psychedelic and Meditative States; (2) Enhancement of the Meditative and Psychedelic Experience; (3) Beneficial Changes in Relating to the Internal and External World (encompassing acceptance, connection, peacefulness, and transformation); (4) Negative Effects of Combined Use; (5) Meditation as a Preparatory and Navigational Tool; and (6) Contextual Considerations (including reflections upon, and practical advice about, combining meditation and psychedelics). Participants’ experiences appear to support recent empirical and theoretical work on the parallels and complementarity between psychedelic drug effects and meditation. The findings identify facilitating conditions for combining psychedelics with meditation, which may have implications for their combined therapeutic use. For example, the use of meditation techniques might represent a “psychedelic-sparing” strategy, potentially enabling therapeutically important psychedelic effects to emerge at lower doses.
Research Summary of 'Meditation Trips: A Thematic Analysis of the Combined Naturalistic Use of Psychedelics With Meditation Practices'
Introduction
Meditative and psychedelic states have long been noted to share phenomenological features such as loosening of self-boundaries, feelings of unity and transcendence, and reductions in attachment to a fixed self. Earlier research has documented overlaps in psychological mechanisms (for example, increased mindfulness, nonreactivity, and decentering) and a handful of experimental studies have begun to test combinations of psychedelics and contemplative practices in retreat or laboratory contexts. Nevertheless, empirical work investigating how people combine psychedelics and meditation in naturalistic settings remains sparse. Azmoodeh and colleagues set out to explore how people who use classic psychedelics also use meditation outside formal therapeutic or retreat settings, and what subjective effects they report when meditating in close temporal proximity to psychedelic consumption. Using free-text responses collected within a larger online survey of psychedelic users, the study aimed to generate themes describing users' attitudes, behaviours, perceived benefits, harms, and practical considerations around what the authors term "psychedelic-meditation." This exploratory, hypothesis-generating approach was chosen because of the limited prior work on naturalistic combined use.
Methods
This qualitative study analysed free-text comments provided within a larger cross-sectional online survey of people with lifetime use of classic psychedelics. The research received University College London ethics approval and was not preregistered. Recruitment used convenience sampling via social media and newsletters related to psychedelics; the advertisement invited people to a survey about psychedelic experiences and mystical phenomena but did not mention meditation explicitly. Inclusion criteria required participants to be aged 18 or older with at least one lifetime classic psychedelic use. Of 1,315 respondents to the full survey, 875 (66.5%) reported practising some form of meditation; 345 of those indicated they had ever taken a psychedelic shortly (minutes or hours) before a formal meditation, and 256 provided free-text comments about using psychedelics before meditating. The online system prevented multiple responses from the same browser, IP addresses were not stored, and no material incentives were offered. The survey included demographic items, drug-use history, and a deliberately broad definition of "meditation"; participants selected one psychedelic they associated with meditating and then answered an open-ended prompt: "any comments you might have about using psychedelics before meditating." Type of meditation was not recorded, and respondents were not asked to describe a specific episode. Thematic analysis was performed by two authors (KA and ET) who independently examined the full set of text responses to develop an initial code set. Codes were applied, aggregated into themes and subthemes, and the structure was iteratively refined and mapped back onto the data to assess fit and prevalence. No qualitative responses were excluded prior to analysis. Quantitative summary data referenced in the paper (for example, counts of occurrences of subthemes) are available from the corresponding author upon request.
Results
Sample characteristics: The analysed sample comprised N = 256 participants who provided text responses. Ages ranged from 18 to 72 years (mean 31.8, SD 10.8). Most respondents were male (n = 168; 65.6%), nonreligious (n = 166; 64.8%), and of White ethnicity (77.6%). Educational attainment was high (83.6% with at least a bachelor's degree). Nationalities were predominantly North American (46.5%) or British (16.8%). Psychedelic and meditation history: Participants reported a mean of 11.2 years since first psychedelic use (mean age at first use 20.6), with the most recent use on average 0.5 years prior to the survey and the most significant psychedelic experience occurring on average 4.1 years earlier. Meditation practice had been started on average 8.8 years prior; typical practice frequency was 15.9 days/month for a mean of 32.3 minutes per day. The psychedelics most commonly cited as being used prior to meditation were primarily psilocybin or LSD (specific counts in the extract refer to a table not included in the text provided). Thematic analysis identified six overarching themes, each with subthemes. Theme 1, Compatibility Between Psychedelic and Meditative States, captured participants' reports of qualitative similarity between the two states and the view that they can ‘‘work in harmony’’; many described a spontaneous drive to meditate after consuming psychedelics, including embodied or movement-based practices (Subtheme 1.1). Theme 2, Enhancement of the Meditative and Psychedelic Experience, was prevalent (103 occurrences) and described reciprocity whereby meditation amplified psychedelic effects and psychedelics deepened meditation. Reported enhancements included intensified visuals, stronger mystical or transcendent feelings, and faster onset of feelings of oneness. Subtheme 2.1 (Enhanced Meditation Experience) covered reports that psychedelics increased meditative ability, producing detached awareness or ‘‘defusion,’’ improved focus on the present, and sustained attention. Subtheme 2.1.2 (Enhanced Depth/Quality) described easier access to deep meditative states; Subtheme 2.1.3 characterised psychedelics as a "shortcut" or catalyst to meditative states that might otherwise require extended practice. Theme 3, Beneficial Changes in Relating to the Internal and External World, encompassed four subthemes. Acceptance (3.1) covered increased self-acceptance and willingness to surrender to difficult emotions; Connection (3.2) referred to a felt unity with self, others, or the universe; Peacefulness (3.3) captured enhanced calm, timelessness, and relaxation; and Transformation (3.4) described enduring shifts in perspective, compassion, and behaviour reported to extend beyond the acute episode. Theme 4, Negative Effects of Combined Use, included Becoming Overwhelmed (4.1), where some participants said the combined state could be ‘‘too intense’’ or precipitate loss of cognitive coherence, and Difficulty Meditating (4.2), where others reported impaired capacity to concentrate or maintain a meditative stance while under the drug, with some noting dose-dependent effects. Theme 5, Meditation as a Preparatory and Navigational Tool, had two subthemes. Meditation as Preparation (5.1; n = 33) described use of meditation to calm come-up anxiety, set intentions, and establish receptivity prior to psychedelic onset. Meditation to Navigate the Psychedelic Experience (5.2) captured reports that meditative skills helped manage unsettling material, eased acceptance of ego dissolution, and enabled a more controlled engagement with visuals and emotions during the trip. Theme 6, Contextual Considerations, comprised Reflections on Personal Processes (6.1) and Advice for Implementation (6.2). Participants described settings (alone, group, darkened room), ritualised approaches, and practical recommendations: attend to set and setting, have a sitter or guide, use a safe environment, and commonly favour a ‘‘right’’ or relatively low dose. Several respondents emphasised the need for proficiency or prior experience in both meditation and psychedelics to combine them safely and effectively.
Discussion
Azmoodeh and colleagues interpret their findings as broadly consistent with prior experimental and theoretical work on parallels and complementarity between meditation and psychedelic states. They note that a degree of compatibility between the two states appears to be a necessary condition for mutual enhancement, and point to experimental studies (including psilocybin administration in retreat or meditative contexts) that have reported increases in meditation depth and trait mindfulness when psychedelics are combined with contemplative practice. The authors suggest clinical implications cautiously: meditation might operate as a "psychedelic-sparing" strategy in therapeutic settings, enabling therapeutically relevant subjective states (for example, mystical experiences) at lower psychedelic doses. They also propose a mechanism for enduring benefit whereby ongoing, drug-free meditation practice rehearses and consolidates adaptive changes initiated during psychedelic-meditation episodes, thus supporting longer-term transformation. At the same time, the discussion highlights safety concerns the authors acknowledged in the data. Some participants reported being overwhelmed or finding meditation and psychedelics mutually impairing; the investigators suggest this may occur when meditators lack well-developed ‘‘protective awareness’’ or when individuals are vulnerable to adverse responses to consciousness-altering practices. They stress that both meditation and psychedelics can independently provoke distressing experiences and that combined use may amplify psychological risk for some individuals. The authors emphasise limitations that temper interpretation: convenience recruitment via the internet and self-selection likely biased the sample toward people with prior positive experiences; the cross-sectional design does not permit causal inference; and the survey did not collect detailed quantitative data on timing, dosing, type of meditation, frequency of combined use, or whether different drugs interact differently with meditation. They also acknowledge that the open-ended prompt (which asked about meditating after psychedelic use) may have biased responses toward that temporal pattern. Strengths cited include a relatively large qualitative sample and independent coding by two researchers, but the authors conclude that their findings are exploratory and hypothesis-generating, pointing to conditions that may facilitate or hinder combined psychedelic and meditative practice and suggesting directions for future controlled research.
View full paper sections
METHODS
The study received ethical approval from the University College London's research ethics committee and was part of a larger crosssectional survey examining the association between a number of mindfulness-related (e.g., decentering, trait mindfulness, acceptance) and mental health variables (anxiety, depression, substance use) among psychedelic users. The latter data are not presented here. This study was not preregistered.
CONCLUSION
The present study describes a thematic analysis, based on a large qualitative data set of participants' experiences of meditation in the context of psychedelic use. Here, we attempt to link our findings to related theory and empirical work. In the interest of brevity, we focus our current discussion on a limited number of salient (sub)themes described above. As outlined in the Results section, the themes of Compatibility and Enhancement were closely related. Indeed, a degree of compatibility can be understood as a necessary condition for enhancement of meditation effects by psychedelics and vice versa. This is highlighted in previously published studies examining the combined effects of compassion-oriented meditative techniques and the nonclassic, mild psychedelic, MDMA, in naturalistic settings. These studiesproposed that the additive effects of MDMA and compassionate imagery on feelings of self-compassion relied on the experiential consistency (or compatibility) between the meditative and MDMA-induced subjective states. As such, meditative practices might provide a suitable set for psychedelic experiences (see below), and conversely (and more directly relevant to the present study), psychedelics may themselves produce a conducive set for meditation. The theme of Compatibility aligns with recent literature exploring the parallels between the effects and outcomes of psychedelics and meditation, especially in relation to psychological disorders. Overelaborated and inflexible self-conceptualization plays a particularly important etiological role in psychopathology, and meditation techniques are thought to alleviate suffering and promote well-being by loosening one's ties to a rigid self-concept. This is achieved through various cognitive and attentional meditation techniques, which allow habitual patterns of thinking, feeling and perceiving to be noticed, and for a more clear-eyed understanding of these modes of experience to emerge (i.e., insight or meta-awareness;. Similar, but more sudden and dramatic insights into the nature of the mind and reality are thought to be a consequence of psychedelic-induced mystical experiences. In addition, as discussed in the introduction, psychedelic use produces similar outcomes to those found following periods of extended meditation. Recently, research trials have either examined the combined effects of psychedelics and meditation (referred to as "spiritual practices," which incorporated aspects of attentional, insight, and mantra meditation;or compared psychedelic effects with meditation-based psychosocial treatment (mindfulnessbased stress reduction;. These studies suggest that in the absence of any meditation practice, psychedelics alone mimic the effects of meditation, although this might not be a unique characteristic of psychedelics. Findings fromalso highlight the ability of psilocybin treatment to enhance meditation outcomes (state/trait mindfulness), partially in line with the present study's observed theme of Enhanced Meditation Experience. The notion that psychedelic drugs are a "shortcut" to meditative states (Subtheme 2.1.3) was highlighted in a separate subtheme under Enhancement. It should be noted that this subtheme is generally distinct from the apocryphal notion that psychedelics could substitute for thousands of hours of monastic practice, although infrequent examples of this idea also appeared in the data (see Results section: Subtheme 2.1). Instead, participants seemed to have a realistic view of psychedelics as catalysts for achieving desired meditative states, rather than as substitutes for meditation practice. In addition, the notion of overall enhancement of the psychedelic experience through the use of meditation is worth considering in terms of its clinical implications. We suggest that meditation might act as a "psychedelic-sparing" strategy in psychedelic psychotherapy, enabling therapeutically important subjective (e.g., mystical) states to emerge at lower doses. Within the subtheme of Beneficial Changes, the analysis indicated that psychedelic-meditation might support experiences of (self-)acceptance, in line with research findings that psychedelics alone (without meditation) increase specific facets of mindfulness (nonjudgment and nonreactivity;. Relatedly, acceptance is a defining feature of mindfulness, as well as a putative mediator of its therapeutic benefits. Our analysis also highlighted that acceptance of emotions arising during the psychedelic experience might be aided by meditation. The subtheme of Transformation was related to experiences of insight, shifts in emotional state, and a sense that desirable effects persist beyond the acute psychedelic-meditative state. Experimental MEDITATION TRIPS studies with healthy volunteershave shown moderate-sized, enduring (>12 months) positive effects attributable to a single or small number of psychedelic doses. On the other hand, some researchershave expressed understandable skepticism that one-off or infrequent psychedelic treatment (coupled with low intensity psychological support) could produce lasting symptomatic improvement in patients with treatment-resistant mental health difficulties. However, theoretically driven treatments that target etiologically important mechanisms can indeed have enduring effects on chronic symptomatology (e.g.,. In the context of the present study, psychedelics may "[initiate] an often-dramatic reorientation toward more adaptive values, attitudes, and behaviors". Openness to (or acceptance of) these dramatic effects is likely facilitated by mindfulnesstype meditation (or trait mindfulness) during acute psychedelic effects. In terms of enduring benefits, state (memory)-dependent effects might enable the adaptive changes occurring during psychedelic-meditation to arise (i.e., be recalled) during subsequent drug-free meditation practice. To expand on this, what we mean here by "meditation practice" is an ongoing, intentional, and committed use of meditation techniques outside of the psychedelic context. A tendency to practice during the psychedelic state could reflect the intuitive drive to meditate referred to in the Results section (Subtheme 1.1), but this might not itself be the primary mechanism by which enduring, transformational effects occur (other than by facilitating openness to the psychedelic experience). Instead, we suggest that lasting beneficial effects of psychedelic-meditation are likely to rely upon ongoing meditation practice, which, in addition to promoting benefits arising from meditation per se, also allows rehearsal and strengthening of any adaptive learning that occurred during the psychedelic-mediation experience(s). We also acknowledge that for some, the combined effects of meditation and psychedelics might be overwhelming or mutually impairing. Based on our (admittedly limited) data summarized under the Negative Effects subtheme, a sense of feeling overwhelmed might be understood as a confrontation with typically avoided internal events, beyond the individual's capacity to tolerate these. One possibility is that those who experienced such negative effects might be less experienced meditators. Such participants might have a less well-developed "protective awareness," namely, the capacity to discern potentially harmful contents and processes of mind. Such discernment might be important for enabling the individual to wisely steer their psychedelic experience in a benign or beneficial direction, especially in the absence of a guide or therapist. The theme of Negative Effects is also a reminder that individually, meditation or psychedelics can cause distressing experiences. For example, experiences of fear, grief, and physical distress are not uncommon after psychedelic use. A recent reviewexamining the potential harms of psychedelic drugs notes that while medical risks are minimal, adverse psychological events may occur more readily in unsupportive environments. Meditation alone should also not be considered universally beneficial or benign. A nontrivial proportion of participants undergoing meditation-based or "mind-body" interventions suffer from adverse effects (usually in the form of symptoms indicative of affect dysregulation, e.g., hyperarousal, insomnia, panic; see. Given their separate potential for causing adverse effects, and the fact that their effects may be mutually synergistic, it is likely that those who are susceptible to adverse responses to either meditation or psychedelics alone may experience augmented negative responses with psychedelic-meditation. In addition though, adverse responses to one consciousness-altering practice might be indicative of a more general vulnerability to negative effects of such practices/interventions. For example (speculatively), psychedelic naïve individuals who experience adverse effects of meditation alone might consider this diagnostic of their potential response to psychedelics and should perhaps avoid these drugs. The subtheme of Peacefulness was relatively common and expressed an enhanced state of equanimity (relative to any relaxing effects produced by meditation or psychedelics alone). Further, the use of meditation and establishing a sense of peace/calm was considered to be part of forming a preparatory set for the psychedelic experience. The presence of this subtheme was noteworthy because participants were primed to discuss meditating after psychedelic consumption. This might explain references to the use of meditation "On the come up … " (i.e., in the acute postconsumption phase; see Table: Subtheme 5.1, Meditation as Preparation). Participants' responses also highlighted the value of meditation in managing anxiety, building focus, and supporting a grounded position and intention setting. These effects suggest that meditation can provide an appropriate "set" prior to the onset of psychedelic effects. The value of preparatory meditation practices in the months preceding psychedelic use was recently demonstrated in an experimental, lab-based study.
Study Details
- Study Typeindividual
- Populationhumans
- Characteristicssurveyqualitative
- Journal