Ketanserin reverses the acute response to LSD in a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover study in healthy subjects
In a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled crossover study in 24 healthy subjects, a single 40 mg oral dose of the 5‑HT2A antagonist ketanserin given one hour after 100 µg LSD rapidly reversed the acute psychedelic response—shortening subjective effect duration from 8.5 to 3.5 hours and attenuating visual/auditory alterations, ego dissolution, cardiovascular effects and mydriasis—without altering LSD pharmacokinetics or BDNF elevations. These findings support that LSD’s acute effects depend on 5‑HT2A receptor occupancy and indicate ketanserin can serve as a planned or rescue agent to shorten or mitigate LSD experiences in research and therapy.
Authors
- Becker, A. M.
- Duthaler, U.
- Eckert, A.
Published
Abstract
Abstract Background Lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD) is currently being investigated in psychedelic-assisted therapy. LSD has a long duration of acute action of 8–11 hours. It produces its acute psychedelic effects via stimulation of the serotonin 5-hydroxytryptamine-2A (HT2A) receptor. Administration of the 5-HT2A antagonist ketanserin before LSD almost fully blocks the acute subjective response to LSD. However, unclear is whether ketanserin can also reverse the effects of LSD when administered after LSD. Methods We used a double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled, crossover design in 24 healthy participants who underwent two 14-hour sessions and received ketanserin (40 mg p.o.) or placebo 1 hour after LSD (100 µg p.o.). Outcome measures included subjective effects, autonomic effects, acute adverse effects, plasma brain-derived neurotrophic factor levels, and pharmacokinetics up to 12 hours. Results Ketanserin reversed the acute response to LSD, thereby significantly reducing the duration of subjective effects from 8.5 hours with placebo to 3.5 hours. Ketanserin also reversed LSD-induced alterations of mind, including visual and acoustic alterations and ego dissolution. Ketanserin reduced adverse cardiovascular effects and mydriasis that were associated with LSD but had no effects on elevations of brain-derived neurotrophic factor levels. Ketanserin did not alter the pharmacokinetics of LSD. Conclusions These findings are consistent with an interaction between ketanserin and LSD and the view that LSD produces its psychedelic effects only when occupying 5-HT2A receptors. Ketanserin can effectively be used as a planned or rescue option to shorten and attenuate the LSD experience in humans in research and LSD-assisted therapy. Trial registry ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT04558294)
Research Summary of 'Ketanserin reverses the acute response to LSD in a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover study in healthy subjects'
Introduction
Classic serotonergic psychedelics such as lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD) and psilocybin are under investigation as adjuncts to psychotherapy. Both produce their acute subjective effects primarily via activation of the serotonin 5-HT2A receptor, but LSD has a substantially longer acute duration (typically ~8.5–11 h at common doses) than psilocybin. Ketanserin, a 5-HT2A antagonist with additional affinity for adrenergic α1A and histamine H1 receptors, reliably prevents the subjective effects of psychedelics when given before dosing, but it is unknown whether ketanserin can attenuate or shorten an LSD experience once the psychedelic effects are already established. The question is clinically relevant because a safe, effective antagonist could shorten long sessions or serve as an emergency rescue medication for intolerable acute effects. Becker and colleagues therefore tested the predefined hypothesis that oral ketanserin (40 mg) administered 1 hour after oral LSD (100 µg) would shorten the subjective response to LSD. The primary outcome was the duration of the subjective effect as measured by a visual analogue scale (VAS) for “any drug effect.” Secondary measures included other subjective scales, autonomic measures, plasma biomarkers (BDNF), and pharmacokinetic assessments to examine whether ketanserin’s effects occur despite continued systemic presence of LSD.
Methods
The investigators used a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover design with two 14-hour experimental sessions per participant. In each session subjects received oral LSD (nominally 100 µg; analytically confirmed mean content ~92.5 µg) at 09:00 and, one hour later (10:00), either oral ketanserin 40 mg or matching placebo. Treatment order was randomised and counterbalanced; sessions were separated by at least 10 days (mean 23 days). Participants and investigators were blinded and a double-dummy method was used; participants were asked to guess treatment assignment at the end of sessions. Twenty-four healthy participants completed the study (12 women, 12 men; mean age 34 ± 12 years, range 25–64). Exclusion criteria included pregnancy, major personal psychiatric disorders or a first-degree family history of psychosis, current use of interfering medications (e.g., antidepressants, antipsychotics, sedatives), significant physical illness, heavy smoking (>10 cigarettes/day), lifetime hallucinogen use > 20 times, and recent illicit drug use. Participants were instructed to limit alcohol and were monitored by urine drug tests; eleven had prior hallucinogen experience and three had previously used LSD 1–2 times. Subjective effects were assessed repeatedly by VAS (including an “any drug effect” item) at baseline and multiple post-dose timepoints (0.5, 1, 1.5, 2, 2.5 h and additional times), with onset, tmax (time to maximal effect), offset and effect duration defined on individual effect–time plots using a 10% of individual maximum threshold. Additional instruments included the Adjective Mood Rating Scale (AMRS) at 3, 6, 9, 12 h, the 5D-ASC (12 h) with its 3D-OAV total, and the States of Consciousness Questionnaire including MEQ30 (12 h) for mystical-type experiences. Autonomic measures (blood pressure, heart rate, tympanic temperature, pupil size) were recorded repeatedly; adverse effects were documented using the List of Complaints. Plasma brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) was measured at baseline and 6, 9, and 12 h. Plasma concentrations of LSD and its metabolite O‑H‑LSD, and ketanserin, were measured up to 12 h and non-compartmental pharmacokinetic parameters were estimated. The primary endpoint was the duration of the subjective response on the VAS “any drug effect.” Peak effects (Emax), peak change from baseline (ΔEmax) and area under the effect curve (AUEC) were computed for repeated measures and compared between LSD+ketanserin and LSD+placebo using paired two-sided t-tests. Analyses were conducted in RStudio, significance set at p < 0.05, and no correction for multiple testing was applied because outcomes were predefined. A priori power calculations indicated >16 subjects were required for the primary endpoint; the sample of 24 aimed to provide additional power for secondary, more exploratory analyses.
Results
Primary outcome: ketanserin markedly shortened the duration of the subjective LSD response. Mean duration of “any drug effect” was reduced from 8.5 h in the LSD+placebo condition to 3.5 h in the LSD+ketanserin condition, a reduction of approximately 60%, and this difference was statistically significant. The peak magnitude (Emax) of LSD’s effect was not significantly reduced by ketanserin, but reductions in mean VAS ratings were apparent from 2 h after LSD administration and thereafter. Subjective secondary outcomes: ketanserin substantially reduced AUEC values (60–70% reductions) for multiple LSD-typical subjective effects, including “good drug effects,” stimulation, auditory and visual alterations, synesthesia, alterations in time perception, ego-dissolution and nausea. On the AMRS, ketanserin reversed LSD-induced changes in introversion, emotional excitation and concentration. On the 5D-ASC, ketanserin reduced the 3D-OAV and the 5D-ASC total scores relative to placebo. By contrast, ketanserin did not significantly alter the MEQ30 total score (mystical-type experiences) produced by LSD in this study. Autonomic and adverse effects: ketanserin reduced the overall (AUEC) LSD-induced elevations in blood pressure and rate–pressure product but did not significantly change peak autonomic responses. Ketanserin reversed LSD-induced mydriasis (pupil dilation). On the List of Complaints there was no significant difference in acute adverse effects between conditions; the most commonly reported complaints within 12 h were fatigue, lack of concentration and lack of energy, with similar counts across conditions. Notably, VAS ratings of tiredness were significantly lower in the ketanserin condition. BDNF: LSD increased peak plasma BDNF levels compared with baseline in both conditions, and ketanserin given after LSD did not attenuate this LSD-associated increase in BDNF. Pharmacokinetics: ketanserin did not alter the pharmacokinetics of LSD or O‑H‑LSD. Mean time to maximal plasma concentration of LSD was approximately 2 h in both conditions. Plasma ketanserin concentrations typically reached a maximum at a median of 2 h (range 1–5 h) and declined with an apparent half-life of about 3.5 h. Reported pharmacokinetic parameters and concentration–time curves are provided in the paper’s tables and figures.
Discussion
Becker and colleagues interpret the findings as evidence that the acute subjective and some autonomic effects of LSD in humans are predominantly mediated by the 5-HT2A receptor and can be reversed even after effects are established. Administering ketanserin 40 mg orally 1 h after LSD 100 µg produced a rapid and substantial reduction in effect duration (from ~8.5 h to ~3.5 h) and lowered overall exposure to subjective effects as indexed by AUEC, while not substantially lowering the peak effect. The authors note that reversal occurred within about 2.5 h after ketanserin dosing and that intravenous administration would likely produce faster antagonism. The differing impact of ketanserin on questionnaire measures is discussed: the 5D-ASC and VAS AUEC (measures of overall response over time) were reduced, whereas the MEQ30 (which the authors suggest primarily reflects peak response) was not significantly changed. This pattern is offered as a possible explanation for why ketanserin diminished integrated measures of LSD response but left some peak-related mystic-type scores intact. Clinical and mechanistic implications are considered. The investigators suggest ketanserin could be used to shorten planned LSD sessions or serve as a rescue medication in cases of acute intolerance, potentially enabling LSD regimens of adjustable duration; timing of antagonist administration could modulate total experience length. The observation that ketanserin did not prevent LSD-induced increases in plasma BDNF leads the authors to propose that neuroplasticity-related effects may be mediated by mechanisms at least partly independent of 5-HT2A receptor activation, raising the question whether blocking the acute subjective experience would preclude longer-term therapeutic effects. Preclinical data are cited to indicate some synaptic/antidepressant-like effects can persist despite 5-HT2A antagonism, but the authors emphasise that whether therapeutic effects are retained in humans when the psychedelic response is blocked remains unknown and requires investigation. Safety and tolerability: known ketanserin adverse effects include sedation and hypotension, but in this study adverse reports were limited (only two participants reported nasal congestion attributable to ketanserin) and measures of tiredness and concentration improved under ketanserin, consistent with its antagonism of LSD effects. Blood-pressure lowering observed could reflect both ketanserin’s direct effects and reversal of LSD-induced elevations; the authors state they cannot fully disentangle these contributions. Strengths and limitations noted by the investigators include the randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled crossover design, GMP-manufactured LSD, and within-subject comparisons as strengths. Limitations are the absence of a true LSD-placebo (i.e., non-LSD) control arm, the enrolment of healthy volunteers only, testing a single LSD dose (100 µg), and the fixed timing of ketanserin administration at 1 h post-LSD, which may not generalise to later antagonist use. The authors conclude that ketanserin can shorten or reverse the acute LSD response and may be useful as a planned adjunct or emergency rescue treatment in psychedelic-assisted therapy, while recognising open questions about the relationship between the subjective experience and any longer-term therapeutic effects.
View full paper sections
RESULTS
The primary study endpoint was the duration of the subjective response as assessed with the VAS "any drug effect". The onset, t max , offset and effect duration were defined in the any drug effect-time plots using a threshold of 10% of the maximum individual response using Phoenix WinNonlin 6.4 and as previously described. Peak (E max and/or E min ), peak change from baseline (ΔE max ) and area under the effect curve (AUEC) values were determined for repeated measures and were compared as additional endpoints. The values were analyzed using paired two-sided t-tests. The data were analyzed using RStudio 1.3.1103 software (RStudio, PBC, Boston, MA, USA). The criterion for significance was p < 0.05. Sex and body weight were not taken into account because previous studies have not reported any differences. No correction for multiple testing was used based on the priori 11 definition of a limited set of outcomes with specific hypotheses. A priori power analysis estimated sufficient power for the primary endpoint with a sample size > 16. A sample size of 24 accounted for the secondary endpoints although these analyses were more exploratory and/or confirmatory of the primary endpoint findings using alternative measures. Additional information on sample size calculation are described in detail in the Supplementary Methods online. The data and statistical analysis comply with the recommendations on experimental design and analysis in pharmacology.
CONCLUSION
The present study demonstrated that the 5-HT 2A receptor antagonist ketanserin reversed the subjective and autonomic responses to the prototypical psychedelic LSD in humans. Importantly, this was the case when ketanserin was administered after the effects of LSD had already developed. Specifically, ketanserin (40 mg) given orally 1 h after the administration of an oral dose of LSD (100 µg) rapidly and markedly reversed LSD's effects within 2.5 h of ketanserin administration. Ketanserin reduced the effect duration of LSD from an average of 8.5 h to 3.5 h (approximately 60%). The participants mostly reported a rapid normalization of their state of mind (Supplementary Fig.). Ketanserin did not relevantly reduce the peak response to LSD but had a marked effect on the duration and overall response to LSD over time, statistically confirmed by 60-70% reductions of typical effects of LSD on VAS AUEC values (Table). Ketanserin significantly reduced most aspects of the LSD AUEC response on the VAS, whereas there were smaller or no effects of ketanserin on the 5D-ASC and MEQ. In the present study ketanserin significantly reduced effects of LSD on the 5D-ASC but not on the MEQ30 total score. It is possible that the 5D-ASC total score is mainly a measure of the overall response of LSD (similar to the AUEC in the VAS) whereas the MEQ total score mainly assesses the peak response to LSD (similar to the E max in the VAS). The differences are unlikely to reflect selective effects of ketanserin on the response to LSD. In fact, ketanserin pretreatment similarly prevented all aspects of the LSD response in humans. Psilocybin is the most commonly investigated psychedelic in psychiatric research. It is currently preferred over LSD, partly because of its shorter duration of action. The duration of action of 20-25 mg psilocybin, a dose that is equivalent to the 100 µg dose of LSD that was used in the present study, is an average of 5.5-6 hDownloaded fromby guest on 08 November 2022 A c c e p t e d M a n u s c r i p t 14compared with 8.5 h for LSD. The present data demonstrate that acute subjective LSD effects can be shortened to 3.5 h when ketanserin is administered 1 h after LSD administration. Likely, the duration of action could also be adjusted to 4.5 or 5.5 h when ketanserin is administered 2 or 3 h after LSD, respectively. These and regimens including higher doses of LSD remain to be confirmed. The present data suggest the possibility of full reversal of the response to LSD at essentially any time and within 2.5 h after oral ketanserin administration. The intravenous administration of ketanserin would result in an even faster reversal. Additionally, a recent study showed no relevant differences in tolerability or quality of subjective effects of psilocybin and LSD. In conjunction with the present data it can be assumed that the time course and effects of psilocybin (20-25 mg) could likely be fully mimicked by LSD (100 µg) combined with oral ketanserin administration (40 mg) 2-3 h after LSD administration. Full psychedelic effects on the 5D-ASC and MEQ30 can likely be induced by LSD if ketanserin is administered at 2-3 h rather than 1 h after LSD administration. Ketanserin has known adverse effects, including sedation, hypotension, and nasal congestion. However, in the present study, only two participants reported nasal congestion after ketanserin administration. Moreover, ketanserin significantly reduced tiredness (Table) and concentration problems (Supplementary Table) that were associated with LSD. Thus, ketanserin's antagonistic effects on LSD's actions seemed to be more relevant than its sedating properties. We cannot fully determine the extent to which hypotensive effects that were observed compared with placebo resulted from ketanserin administration alone or resulted from its antagonism of the blood-pressure elevation by LSD. However, blood pressure 5 h after ketanserin administration was lower than at the start and end of the test sessions, indicating an effect of ketanserin on blood pressure in healthy subjects. Ketanserin also transiently lowered blood pressure for 3 h when given before LSD and until LSD's effect started in healthy subjects.. LSD increased BDNF levels in the present study compared with baseline values, consistent with previous studies, although the present study did not include a placebo condition for LSD. Interestingly, ketanserin did not reduce LSD-induced elevations of BDNF when administered after LSD in the present study or when administered before LSD in a previous study.
Study Details
- Study Typeindividual
- Populationhumans
- Characteristicsdouble blindplacebo controlled
- Journal
- Compounds
- Topic