Ketamine-Associated Brain Changes: A Review of the Neuroimaging Literature
This review (2018) examines the neural correlates of ketamine-associated brain changes in patients with depression. Although ketamine affects different areas of the brain in various ways, its most notable effects were found in the subgenual anterior cingulate cortex, posterior cingulate cortex, prefrontal cortex, and hippocampus. Ketamine affects emotional blunting, which may be associated with reduced limbic responses to emotional stimuli, and increase neural activity in reward processing. It also reduces brain activation in regions, such as the Default Mode Network (DMN), associated with self-monitoring, which may be linked to its dissociative effects.
Authors
- Cusin, C.
- Deckersbach, T.
- Felicione, J. M.
Published
Abstract
Major depressive disorder (MDD) is one of the most prevalent conditions in psychiatry. Patients who do not respond to traditional monoaminergic antidepressant treatments have an especially difficult-to-treat type of MDD termed treatment-resistant depression. Interestingly, subanesthetic doses of ketamine-a glutamatergic modulator-have shown great promise for rapidly treating patients with the most severe forms of depression. As such, ketamine represents a promising probe for understanding the pathophysiology of depression and treatment response. Through neuroimaging, ketamine’s mechanism may be elucidated in humans. Here, we review 47 articles of ketamine’s effects as outlined by neuroimaging studies. Taken together, some important brain areas emerge, especially the subgenual anterior cingulate cortex. Furthermore, ketamine may decrease the ability to self-monitor, increase emotional blunting, and increase activity in reward processing. However, further studies are necessary to elucidate ketamine’s mechanism of antidepressant action.
Research Summary of 'Ketamine-Associated Brain Changes: A Review of the Neuroimaging Literature'
Introduction
Major depressive disorder (MDD) is common and often debilitating; a substantial subgroup—treatment-resistant depression (TRD), typically defined as failure to respond to at least two adequate antidepressant trials—carries high personal and economic burden. Subanesthetic doses of ketamine produce rapid (within hours), robust and often short‑to‑medium term antidepressant effects, with clinical studies reporting about 50% of TRD patients exhibiting substantial symptom reduction within 24 hours of a single intravenous dose. Preclinical work implicates NMDA receptor antagonism, an acute glutamate surge and downstream activation of synaptogenic pathways such as mTOR, but human neuroimaging findings about ketamine’s mechanism have been inconsistent and incomplete. Ionescu and colleagues set out to review the human neuroimaging literature to identify convergent brain regions and functional changes associated with ketamine, emphasising studies of patients with MDD but also including research in healthy volunteers because of the relative paucity of patient imaging. The review focuses on multiple imaging modalities (PET, MRS, fMRI, rsfMRI, MEG, diffusion and structural MRI), and aims to relate neuroimaging findings to clinical metrics (for example dissociation, baseline activity, and treatment response) to better characterise ketamine’s antidepressant mechanism and to suggest regions for future study.
Methods
The authors performed a Medline search through December 2016 using combinations of terms including "depression and ketamine and neuroimaging," "ketamine and imaging," and related phrases. Only studies in English and adult human research were considered. The initial search yielded 966 records; after removing duplicates and non-human studies, 47 papers met the inclusion criteria and were reviewed. Ionescu and colleagues organised the extracted literature into three overarching result sections: (1) ketamine and neuroimaging in depression (clinical patient studies), (2) ketamine in non-depressed subjects using non-task resting-state scans, and (3) ketamine in non-depressed subjects using task-based scans. The review considered multiple imaging modalities; where studies used more than one technique, findings were synthesised across modalities rather than treated separately. The Methods text in the extracted file does not report formal quality assessment or meta-analytic pooling procedures, indicating a narrative review rather than a quantitative synthesis.
Results
Overall, 47 neuroimaging studies were reviewed: 13 papers addressed unipolar depression and two addressed bipolar depression; the remainder studied healthy volunteers. Among patient studies using fMRI and connectivity metrics, several findings emerged. One study found that ketamine increased neural responses to positive emotions in the right caudate, with greater post‑ketamine caudate connectivity linked to clinical improvement. Abdallah and colleagues reported reduced global brain connectivity in the prefrontal cortex (PFC) at baseline in MDD versus controls, and ketamine increased global connectivity in the right lateral PFC while decreasing it in the left cerebellum; responders showed increased connectivity in lateral PFC, caudate and insula compared to non‑responders. Downey and colleagues observed increased BOLD signal in the subgenual anterior cingulate cortex (sgACC) after ketamine that predicted symptom change at 24 hours and 1 week, although that study had no significant antidepressant effect and showed strong placebo and baseline imbalance. Structural and diffusion imaging provided additional predictive markers: smaller left hippocampal volume at baseline correlated with greater antidepressant response at 24 hours in one study. Diffusion MRI measures (fractional anisotropy, mean diffusivity and radial diffusivity) in cingulum, forceps minor and frontostriatal tracts at baseline predicted symptom improvement 24 hours after infusion. MEG studies implicated the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC): higher baseline ACC cortical activity to fearful faces (particularly pregenual ACC, pgACC) and lower baseline amygdala activation predicted larger early antidepressant responses; lower pgACC engagement during increasing working-memory load and lower pgACC–left amygdala coherence likewise predicted response. Other MEG work showed decreased amygdala–insulo‑temporal connectivity post‑ketamine, and increased somatosensory cortical excitability (an index of synaptic plasticity) in responders. PET studies of whole‑brain metabolism reported heterogeneous correlations with clinical outcomes. NIMH investigators linked reduced anhedonia post‑ketamine with increased metabolism in the hippocampus and dorsal ACC (dACC) and decreased metabolism in orbitofrontal cortex (OFC). Other PET findings included decreased metabolism post‑ketamine in the right habenula, right insula, right ventrolateral PFC and dorsolateral PFC; clinical improvements correlated with increased metabolism in superior and middle temporal gyri and cerebellum and decreased metabolism in parahippocampal and inferior parietal regions. In bipolar depression samples (patients maintained on lithium or valproate), decreased anhedonia correlated with increased dACC and putamen metabolism; larger antidepressant gains associated with increased ventral striatum metabolism, and sgACC metabolism correlated positively with symptom improvement. In healthy volunteer resting‑state and non‑task studies (21 papers, mainly MRI and MRS), ketamine altered cerebral blood flow (CBF) and connectivity. Several studies reported reduced hippocampal CBF and increased CBF in ACC and prefrontal regions; other reports showed reduced CBF in OFC and sgACC, with one study finding a very strong correlation (r=0.90) between sgACC CBF reduction and dissociation measured by the Clinician‑Administered Dissociative States Scale (CADSS). Resting‑state fMRI showed decreased connectivity within auditory and somatosensory networks relative to pain‑processing regions, reduced pACC–dPCC connectivity correlated with psychotomimetic effects during infusion, and disruption of functional network connectivity among pgACC, medial PFC and bilateral dorsomedial PFC persisting 24 hours after infusion. Ketamine produced hippocampal hyperconnectivity in networks vulnerable to mood and cognitive disorders, and acute increases in hippocampal Glx (glutamate+glutamine) measured by MRS accompanied decreased fronto‑temporal and temporo‑parietal functional connectivity. Pharmacological imaging contrasts (ketamine minus placebo) showed increased BOLD in bilateral midcingulate, ACC, insula and right thalamus. MEG during infusion revealed increased gamma power, decreased beta activity (noted in thalamus, hippocampus and fronto‑cortical regions) and increased thalamocortical information transfer (measured by transfer entropy). Task‑based imaging in non‑depressed subjects (15 papers, 14 using fMRI) produced mixed but thematically consistent results. Emotion‑processing tasks often showed attenuated amygdalo‑hippocampal BOLD responses, particularly to negative stimuli; the magnitude of acute psychedelic effects predicted the reduction in responsiveness to negative images. In some cases pgACC activation increased 24 hours post‑infusion during negative picture viewing, especially in participants with lower distraction ability. Ketamine reduced insula activation (right insula across valences; left insula and right dorsolateral PFC for negative stimuli only) and impaired self‑monitoring associated with reduced left superior temporal cortex activation. Working‑memory and episodic memory tasks produced heterogeneous outcomes: some studies found increased fronto‑parietal and PFC activation associated with correct encoding under ketamine, while others documented impaired working‑memory performance with reduced PFC activation and connectivity related to poorer task performance. Verbal fluency was generally impaired under ketamine, with altered activation in temporal, frontal and parietal regions depending on task type.
Discussion
Ionescu and colleagues interpret the literature as indicating recurring involvement of a set of regions—particularly the subgenual ACC (sgACC), posterior cingulate cortex (PCC), prefrontal cortex (PFC) and hippocampus—in ketamine’s neural effects, which overlap with networks implicated in the pathophysiology of depression. Across modalities, ketamine appears to reduce activity in regions tied to self‑monitoring, produce an emotional blunting or attenuation of limbic responsiveness to negative stimuli, and increase activation of regions associated with reward processing. Together these effects are hypothesised to shift processing away from internally focused, aversive states and rumination toward altered perceptual and reward‑related processing. The authors note inconsistencies in specific findings, using the sgACC as an example: some studies report immediate reductions in sgACC coupling and blood flow that predict dissociation, while PET studies at about 120 minutes post‑infusion have reported increased sgACC metabolism correlated with clinical improvement or no change in sgACC metabolism. Ionescu and colleagues suggest that timing of scans relative to infusion (acute dissociative window versus later post‑infusion) may account for some discrepancies and that dissociation itself could mediate aspects of antidepressant response by transiently "disconnecting" excessive aversive visceromotor states from cognition. They also highlight evidence that ketamine disrupts default mode network (DMN) hyperconnectivity and pACC–dPCC coupling—networks associated with rumination—and that responders show increased frontal connectivity (for example lateral PFC, caudate, insula) consistent with restored frontal regulation over limbic regions. Metabolic correlates of clinical improvement varied across studies, including increased metabolism in hippocampus and dACC and decreased OFC metabolism in some datasets, while other work linked improvements to temporal and cerebellar metabolic changes. Several limitations are emphasised. Most neuroimaging studies to date involve healthy volunteers rather than patients with depression, many task studies enrolled only male participants, and sample sizes are generally small (the largest depression imaging study in the review included 24 participants). Heterogeneity in dose regimens, use of racemic versus S‑ketamine, timing of imaging relative to infusion, and the rapid time course of ketamine’s antidepressant effect complicate chronological interpretation of which brain changes reflect direct pharmacology versus secondary mood improvement. These factors limit generalisability and interpretability. Finally, the authors recommend further controlled, larger‑scale imaging studies in depressed patients, focused on sgACC, PCC, PFC and hippocampus, to clarify ketamine’s mechanism and to inform new models of depression and potential drug discovery. They frame ketamine as a valuable probe for advancing neurobiological understanding because of its rapid and robust clinical effects.
View full paper sections
INTRODUCTION
Major depressive disorder (MDD) is devastating, serious, and prevalent. Treatment-resistant depression (TRD)-often defined as failure to respond to at least two standard antidepressant treatment trials of adequate dose and duration-encompasses up to 30% of patients with MDD.Not only is TRD highly debilitating for patients and their families, economic strain from TRD accounts for nearly $200 billion dollars a year from lost productivity. The more treatment failures a patient experiences, the less likely they are to respond to subsequent treatment trials-perpetuating the cycle of disability. For these reasons, it is critical to find fast and effective treatments for patients with TRD. One such compound that holds promise for TRD is ketamine. While commonly thought of as a dissociative anesthetic, subanesthetic doses of ketamine stand out among other pharmacological interventions for MDD. While most commonly used psychiatric medications (e.g. SSRIs, SNRIs, TCAs, MAO inhibitors) require multiple weeks to take full effect, subanesthetic doses of ketamine have rapid (within hours), robust (across a variety of symptoms), and relatively sustained (typically up to one week) antidepressant effects-even in patients with TRD.Clinical studies show that about 50% of patients with TRD have a significant decrease in symptoms within 24 hours of a single intravenous subanesthetic ketamine dose.Animal models show that ketamine's antidepressant effects are likely mediated by its antagonism of NMDA receptors through increased AMPA-mediated glutamatergic signaling. This triggers activation of intracellular synaptogenic pathways, most notably in the mTOR signaling pathway, which also has implications in many other psychiatric disorders.In fact, ketamine was first used to probe the glutamatergic system as it relates to the pathophysiology of schizophrenia. The original neuroimaging studies on ketamine's mechanism were thus used as working models for schizophrenia because excess glutamate has been linked to the development of schizophrenia and psychosis.In terms of MDD, decreased glutamate has been noted in various prefrontal regions, including the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (dlPFC), dorsomedial PFC (dmPFC), and the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) when compared to controls.This makes ketamine an ideal treatment for MDD; by creating a surge in glutamate levels in regions of the brain that suffer from a glutamate deficit, ketamine may provide some normalization of glutamate levels in patients with MDD. This "glutamate surge" hypothesis has dominated as the primary theory of ketamine's antidepressant mechanism. However, the glutamate surge hypothesis is met with some controversy. Neuroimaging studies specifically examining how ketamine modulates glutamate and gamma-aminobutryic acid (GABA) have been reviewed.Despite the immediate glutamate surge during infusions, it is unclear if glutamate levels remain elevated post-infusion. One study finds increased glutamate levels in the ACC 35 minutes post infusion, and another found no change.Multiple studies attempted to find a correlation between antidepressant response and glutamate/GABA levels before, during, and after infusion.However, no such correlations were found. It is possible, then, that ketamine is acting indirectly to produce its antidepressant effect. Ketamine may work through additional receptors, as it is known to have effects on several opioid receptors, adrenergic receptors, and several serotonin and norepinephrine transporters.It is also possible that acute dissociative side effects of ketamine may be mediating antidepressant response. In turn, it is equally possible that small sample sizes among studies utilizing ketamine prevent results from converging. Methodological differences and limitations may also play a role. Due to inconsistent results and ketamine's heterogeneity of action, it is hard to elucidate the mechanism by which ketamine produces its rapid, robust and sustained antidepressant effects. Therefore, further research on ketamine's antidepressant mechanism is needed and theories on the biological and clinical level need to be explored. One salient biological metric that may provide insight into ketamine's mechanism of action is dissociation. Dissociative side effects begin from infusion, reach a peak typically within an hour of infusion, and are completely diminished 230 minutes after infusion.One study has shown increased dissociation and psychotomimetic symptoms immediately following infusion may predict antidepressant response.Further neuroimaging research has the potential to not just inform scientists of ketamine's antidepressant mechanism, but may inform clinicians as to who might best respond to ketamine as an antidepressant. Other biological metrics include baseline brain activity, psychotomimetic effects during infusion, and anxiety somatization levels. The advent of advanced imaging techniques allows non-invasive investigations of neuronal activity in patients with TRD and healthy controls. These imaging results can then be correlated with not just glutamate and GABA levels, but clinical and biological metrics that could provide insight into how ketamine produces its antidepressant effect. Positron emission tomography (PET) and magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) provide the most direct noninvasive methods to measure glutamatergic and GABA-ergic activity. They acquire full volumes of the brain at various time points during and after ketamine infusion. In turn, magnetoencephalogram (MEG) recordings measure small magnetic and electric changes in the brain through sensors placed at the scalp. While MEG is a more indirect measure of GABA and glutamate, it assesses brain function of all regions on a time scale that better reflects real-time neural activity. Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) and resting-state fMRI (rsfMRI) provide less temporal resolution than MEG (full brain volumes are only acquired every ~3 seconds), however provide more precise measurements of subcortical regions of the brain. This is important for studying regions such as the subgenual ACC (sgACC) and amygdala, as they are commonly targeted in MDD.MEG and fMRI also allow investigators to study how brain function changes as subjects undergo in-scanner tasks, such as passive viewing of faces, decision making, etc. Task-based fMRI and MEG can provide more ecologically valid information about what the brain does when faced with real-life situations. It can also tell us more about how the brain's real-life performance is altered in patients with MDD. Finally, diffusion MRI and structural MRI enable tracking of how ketamine may change the brain's anatomy and how structural connections change over time. This is of interest because rapidly induced synaptogenesis has been shown in preclinical models in response to ketamine.Thus, here we review current human neuroimaging literature as it pertains to ketamine's mechanism of action in specific brain areas, with an emphasis on key regions that are implicated in the pathophysiology of MDD. We focus this review on treatment studies of patients with MDD. However, because there is very little literature that specifically examines ketamine's actions in patients with MDD, we are including research with healthy volunteers. Research in healthy volunteers may enable us to understand how ketamine impacts neural organization and activity without psychopathology. We end by summarizing the results as they pertain to the neurobiology of depression and ketamine's antidepressant effects. By understanding the biological basis of disease pathology and treatment response, the field of psychiatry has the potential to practice more precise medicine-ultimately with improvements in patient care and outcomes as a result.
METHODS
A Medline search was conducted for articles through December 2016 using the following search terms: "depression and ketamine and neuroimaging," "depression and ketamine and imaging," "depression and ketamine and MRI," "ketamine and neuroimaging," "ketamine and imaging." All articles reviewed were written and published in English and pertained to adult human research only. A total of 966 were initially found. After duplicate articles and non-human research papers were removed, 47 papers were found to be relevant to this review. In this review, we segment the results into three sections: Ketamine and Neuroimaging in Depression, Ketamine in Non-Depressed Subjects: Non-Task Based Resting State Scans, and Ketamine in Non-Depressed: Task-Based Scans. Though most papers only examined one modality of imaging, several paperstackled more than one imaging technique.
KETAMINE AND NEUROIMAGING IN DEPRESSION
Thirteen papers were found to be relevant to ketamine's effects in patients with unipolar depression, and two papers in patients with bipolar depression. (Table). Among unipolar depression studies, several groups utilized fMRI. With regard to brain connectivity, one study found that in patients with TRD, ketamine increased neural responses to positive emotions in the right caudate; furthermore, greater connectivity in the right caudate post-ketamine was associated with improvements in depression severity.Another study by Abdallah and colleagues found that patients with MDD had reduced global brain connectivity (the average of the correlation between the BOLD time series of a voxel and all other gray matter voxels in the brain) in the prefrontal cortex compared to healthy volunteers at baseline, but increased global brain connectivity in the posterior cingulate, precuneus, lingual gyrus, and cerebellum. Ketamine significantly increased global brain connectivity in the right lateral PFC and reduced global brain connectivity in the left cerebellum. Furthermore, ketamine responders had increased connectivity in the lateral PFC, caudate, and insula compared to non-responders.Downey and colleagues recently found that ketamine increased blood oxygen level dependent (BOLD) signals in the sgACC. Activation of the sgACC predicted depression improvements at 24 hours and 1 week postketamine.However, this group had no significant antidepressant response to ketamine, as well as strong placebo response and significant baseline differences in depression severity between the ketamine and placebo groups. With regard to structural MR results, Abdallah and colleagues found a significant association between smaller left hippocampal volumes at baseline and greater antidepressant responses to ketamine at 24 hours post-infusion in patients with depression.A diffusion MRI study found that at baseline, greater fractional anisotropy (a measure of connectivity strength in the principal axis of the structural connection) in the cingulum projecting the PFC, decreased mean diffusivity (MD, a measure of membrane density) and radial diffusivity (RD, a measure of myelination) in forceps minor, and decreased RD in the frontostriatal tract predicted improvements in depression symptoms 24 hours post ketamine. 26 Other studies that utilized MEG provide more information about the role of the ACC. Salvadore and colleagues found that increased baseline cortical activity to fearful pictures in the ACC-especially the pregenual ACC (pgACC)-and decreased baseline amygdala activation predicted a greater antidepressant response to ketamine at 4 hours post-infusion.Another study from the same group examined baseline predictors of ketamine response during a working memory task. Patients who had the least pre-ketamine engagement of the pgACC with increasing memory load showed the greatest antidepressant improvement to ketamine at 4 hours post-infusion. In addition, those with the lowest coherence between pgACC and left amygdala were most likely to respond to ketamine.Since we would expect healthy controls to have high pgACC activity in response to emotional stimuli and low pgACC activity in response to increased cognitive demands, these data suggest that normal baseline activity in the pgACC predicts better antidepressant outcomes to ketamine. In another MEG study, Nugent and colleagues found decreased connectivity between the amygdala and insulo-temporal regions post-ketamine.Cornwell and colleagues used a tactile stimulation task to indirectly gauge synaptic plasticity in the somatosensory cortex during MEG acquisition at 6.5 hours post-ketamine, since ketamine's antidepressant effects may be the result of rapid increases in synaptic plasticity.Indeed, responders at 4-hours post-infusion had an increase in somatosensory cortical excitability (a measure of synaptic plasticity) compared to non-responders.Several studies explored ketamine's effects on whole brain metabolism using positron emission tomography (PET). Lally and colleagues at the NIMH found that decreased anhedonia post-ketamine was associated with increased metabolism in the hippocampus and the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex (dACC), and decreased metabolism in the orbitofrontal cortex (OFC).Another study from the same NIMH group found that decreased suicidal ideation scores post-ketamine correlated with decreased metabolism in the infralimbic cortex.Furthermore, Carlson and colleagues administered PET scans at 120 minutes postketamine and compared them to baseline scans. Decreased metabolism in the right habenula, right insula, right ventrolateral PFC, and dorsolateral PFC was found post-ketamine. Furthermore, clinical improvements significantly correlated with increased metabolism in the superior temporal gyrus (STG), middle temporal gyrus (MTG), and cerebellum, and with decreased metabolism in the parahippocampal gyrus and inferior parietal cortex.Two studies focused on bipolar depression using PET imaging. Lally and Nugent used PET scans at 120 minutes post-ketamine to measure metabolism in patients with bipolar depression; note, all patients in these studies were maintained on stable doses of either lithium or valproic acid. Specifically, Lally and colleagues found that decreased anhedonia correlated with increased metabolism in the dACC and putamen.Nugent and colleagues found that patients who received ketamine had significantly lower glucose metabolism in the left hippocampus compared to those who received placebo; furthermore, patients with the largest improvement in depression symptoms had the largest metabolic increase in the right ventral striatum post-ketamine compared to placebo. In addition, metabolism of the sgACC positively correlated with improvements in depression scores following ketamine.Ketamine in Non-Depressed Subjects: Non-Task Based Resting State Scans Twenty-one resting state scan papers were found relevant to this review, mostly using MRI and MRS (see Tableand). From MRI studies, some highlights emerged. Several studies examined how ketamine affected cerebral blood flow (CBF). Two studies showed that ketamine reduced CBF in the hippocampus and increased CBF in the ACC and prefrontal regions.Other studies found that ketamine reduced CBF in the OFC and sgACC.In one particular study, this reduction strongly predicted dissociation (r=0.90 with the Clinician Administered Dissociative States Scale (CADSS) scores).In another study, perceptual distortions and delusion ratings following ketamine correlated with increased BOLD response in the parietal cortex.With regard to rsfMRI, one study found that ketamine decreased connectivity in the auditory and somatosensory networks in relation to regions of physical and affective processing of pain (e.g., amygdala, insula, and ACC).During another study, ketamine reduced functional connectivity between the pACC and the dPCC; this reduction in connectivity correlated significantly with increased psychotomimetic effects during the infusion.Ketamine decreased functional network connectivity in healthy subjects; specifically, ketamine disrupted connectivity between the pgACC, mPFC, and the bilateral dmPFC 24 hours after infusion.One study examined the effects of ketamine on brain connectivity with increasing levels of sedation (awake, mildly sedated, heavily sedated). Increased levels of sedation correlated significantly with decreased connectivity in the mPFC with the Default Mode Network (DMN) and also between the left executive control network and the right executive control network. Thalamo-cortical connectivity remained relatively preserved.Ketamine also had significant effects on hippocampal connectivity. One rsfMRI study found that ketamine induced hyperconnectivity in hippocampal networks vulnerable to mood and cognitive disorders.Moreover, another study observed that hyperconnectivity between the PFC and the left hippocampus occurred after acute ketamine challenge.MRS techniques have also implicated ketamine's role in brain connectivity and hippocampal function. Ketamine induced an increase in hippocampal Glx (glutamate+glutamine-an indication of enhanced excitatory neurotransmission), a decrease in fronto-temporal and temporo-parietal functional connectivity. This suggests a possible link between connectivity changes and elevated Glx. These data suggest that NMDA receptor hypofunction may lead to elevated hippocampal glutamatergic transmission and alterations in resting-state network.Ketamine was found to decrease NMDA-and AMPA-mediated frontal-to-parietal connectivity.One study imaged participants using fMRI during both a ketamine infusion and placebo infusion. They analyzed a ketamine -placebo contrast and found that, compared to placebo, BOLD activation increased during the ketamine condition in the bilateral middle cingulate cortex, ACC, and insula, as well as the right thalamus.Finally, with regard to MEG, one study found increased gamma-power during the infusion while beta band activity was decreased. This effect was noted in the thalamus, hippocampus, and fronto-cortical regions. Connectivity, as measured by transfer entropy (how much information is transferred from a source to a target process), increased within the thalamocortical network. This study's results highlight a potential contribution of the thalamocortical pathways in ketamine's initial neuronal dysregulation.
KETAMINE IN NON-DEPRESSED: TASK-BASED SCANS
Fifteen task-based scan papers were found, fourteen of which used fMRI (see Tableand). Several studies examined ketamine's effects during and after emotion tasks. In one study, ketamine attenuated task-induced activation in the amygdalo-hippocampal complex; specifically, reductions in BOLD activation were more marked in response to negative pictures compared to neutral or positive pictures. Furthermore, increased intensity of the acute psychedelic side effects on consciousness during ketamine predicted the reduction in neuronal responsiveness to negative (but not neutral or positive) pictures. The authors suggested that perhaps the emotional blunting ("attenuated limbic hyperactivity") during dissociation plays a role in the alleviation of negative bias in people with depression (though no patients with depression were actually included in the study).During a different emotional pictures task, increased BOLD activation was observed 24hours post-ketamine infusion in the pgACC (but not the posterior control regions) during the negative picture viewing blocks. However, the increase in BOLD activation was more pronounced in subjects with a low ability to apply distraction during the negative experiences.In another emotion task, ketamine significantly reduced BOLD activation in the right insula regardless of emotional valence of the task; there was a reduction in BOLD activation exclusively to negative stimuli in the left insula and right DLPFC.Compared to placebo (in which several brain areas-amygdala, visual processing areas, and cerebellumsignificantly activated during a fearful faces task), the ketamine group only significantly activated the left superior occipital gyrus.These data are somewhat related to another study in which ketamine led to impaired self-monitoring, which was related to reduced activation in the left superior temporal cortex. Together, these data suggest that the NMDA receptor may be involved in the production of the impaired self-monitoring that occurs during hallucinatory or delusional experiences.Several studies examined ketamine's effects on working memory. In one study, ketamine increased activation in fronto-parietal regions (dlPFC, bilateral ventrolateral areas, bilateral parietal cortices, ACC, putamen, and caudate nucleus) compared to placebo during the task phase of manipulation of verbal information (at the easiest point).In another study, ketamine increased activation of the left PFC to deeply encoded items during an episodic memory task. Specifically, correctly identified items during ketamine were associated with increased activation of the right PFC during encoding compared to incorrectly identified items. Items incorrectly identified at retrieval were associated with increased activation of the right PFC and hippocampus under ketamine, but not placebo.In contrast, in one study, ketamine impaired working memory performance. Ketamine reduced task-related activation in the PFC during a spatial task, especially during the encoding and early maintenance phase. Ketamine also reduced connectivity during the task in the network brain areas involved in working memory. Reductions in activation and connectivity were related to performance.Finally, one study found that ketamine induced a general impairment of verbal fluency. During the phonic verbal fluency task, several brain regions (left temporal gyrus, superior frontal gyrus to middle frontal gyrus, medial frontal gyrus, and left inferior parietal lobe) were more activated by ketamine compared to other conditions. During the lexical verbal fluency task, the right frontal and left supramarginal regions were activated significantly more with ketamine.
DISCUSSION
Although the extant neuroimaging literature on ketamine's effects is in its early stages, certain themes have emerged. First, we review our findings of convergent brain regions implicated in MDD and how ketamine modulates those areas. Specifically, the sgACC has been a region of interest in many previous studies. In relation to emotion and cognition, ketamine appears to reduce brain activation in regions associated with self-monitoring, increase neural regions associated with emotional blunting, and increase neural activity in reward processing. Overall, ketamine's effects were most notably found in the sgACC, PCC, PFC, and hippocampus. These areas overlap with the growing body of neuroimaging literature that implicates abnormalities of certain brain networks in the pathophysiology of depression (specifically, the dorsal and subgenual ACC, amygdala, hippocampus, and ventral striatum).The sgACC in particular has been a frequently studied area of interest in MDD and ketamine. In healthy male volunteers, rsfMRI and phMRI done during ketamine infusion found significant reduction in sgACC coupling with hippocampus, RSC, and thalamus. Immediate reductions in sgACC blood flow and focal reductions in OFC blood flow strongly predicted dissociation.However, some other imaging studies of the sgACC seem to provide contradictory results. NIMH studies using PET 120 min post infusion have found that increased metabolism in the sgACC was positively correlated with improvements in depression scores post ketamine.However, a different PET study in MDD found no change in sgACC metabolism post ketamine.These inconsistent results not just indicate the need for larger, more controlled studies, but also may suggest that the timing of the scan matters. Changes in sgACC activation may be related to ketamine's acute side effects, which begin during infusion, reach a peak typically within an hour of infusion, and are completely diminished 230 minutes after infusion. Following this, perhaps sgACC activation decreases during and immediately after ketamine, but changes a few hours post infusion. Analysis of resting state scans in healthy volunteers further suggests that dissociation may be responsible for ketamine's antidepressant effects because it may disconnect the excessive aversive visceromotor state on cognition and self-a hallmark of depression.Related, one study found that ketamine may dampen brain regions involved in rumination via reduction of the functional connectivity between the pACC and the dPCC.Ketamine also disrupts the "hyperconnectivity" of the DMN (e.g., by decreasing connectivity between the mPFC and DMN) found in patients with MDD. DMN hyperconnectivity is commonly associated with increased rumination.This study also found decreased connectivity between the left and right executive control networks, which are involved in internal and external sensory processing.One ongoing study (ClinicalTrials.gov ID: NCT02544607) aims to investigate this further in patients with TRD before and after a ketamine infusion. In other words, these studies suggest that ketamine causes a "disconnect" in several circuits related to affective processing, perhaps by shifting focus away from the internal states of anxiety, depression, and somatization and more towards the perceptual changes induced by ketamine. Similarly, during an emotional task, ketamine attenuated responses to negative pictures, suggesting that the processing of negative information is specifically altered in response to ketamine.By taking the focus off of "oneself" and placing the focus on other stimuli, perhaps ketamine decreases awareness during negative experiences. Perhaps most interesting is ketamine's effects on brain connectivity as it relates to selfmonitoring behaviors. Reduced connectivity between the pACC and dPCC was associated with increased dissociation during infusion, and reduced activation in the left superior temporal cortex was associated with impaired self-monitoring.Such self-monitoring is disruptive to patients with psychotic illness-especially those with chronic symptoms of psychosis. However, perhaps the transient dissociation experienced by depressed patients during a ketamine infusion is essential for dampening what could be considered as hyperactive self-monitoring that results from depressive illness. During ketamine administrations, subjects experience emotional blunting, which may be associated with reduced limbic responses to emotional stimuli.Perhaps by decreasing the activity of deep limbic structures (thought to be involved in the pathophysiology of depression, such as the amygdala), ketamine acutely alleviates the emotional resources required to perpetuate the symptoms of depression. Ketamine may play a role in reactivating reward areas of the brain in patients with MDD. This may be especially important, as reward areas in MDD have been characterized by decreased subcortical and limbic activity and an increased cortical response to reward paradigms.In resting-state scans, BOLD activation in the cingulate gyrus, hippocampus, insula, thalamus, and midbrain increased after ketamine.In addition, ketamine increases neural activation in the bilateral MCC, ACC, and insula, as well as the right thalamus.Activation of these areas is consistent with activation of reward processing areas, suggesting that ketamine may play a role in activation of reward neurocircuitry.Though convergence onto a specific brain area is elusive in depression, ketamine affects different areas of the brain in various ways, which may contribute to overall mood improvements. For example, at baseline, patients with MDD had reduced global connectivity in the PFC and increased connectivity in the posterior cingulate, precuneus, lingual gyrus, and cerebellum compared to healthy volunteers; responders had increased connectivity in the lateral PFC, caudate, and insula post ketamine.Perhaps this represents ketamine's ability to reclaim frontal control over deeper limbic structures, thus resulting in the ability to have more cognitive control of emotions that enables a decrease in depression symptoms. Similarly, TRD patients had reduced insula and caudate responses to positive emotions at baseline compared to healthy volunteers, which normalized in the caudate post-ketamine.Furthermore, while one study showed increased connectivity in the lateral PFC, caudate, and insula in ketamine responders, another found decreased connectivity between the amygdala and insulo-temporal regions.Improvements are correlated with increased metabolism in the hippocampus, dACC, and decreased metabolism in the OFC.Yet another group found that improvements correlated with increased metabolism in the STG/MTG and cerebellum, and decreased metabolism in the parahippocampal gyrus and inferior parietal cortex.Further investigation of these seemingly sporadic results may provide further insight into ketamine's antidepressant effects. Several limitations in this review warrant discussion. First, it is hard to extrapolate information about ketamine's antidepressant properties from the extant literature, because the majority of published studies are from healthy volunteers. Second, most of the taskbased healthy volunteer studies used male volunteers only. Third, most of the studies completed have very low numbers of participants; the depression study with the most number of participants was still only 24 subjects. Given the immense heterogeneity of depression, further studies with larger sample sizes will be necessary in order to capture the full range of patients with depression. Fourth, it is still difficult to chronologically parse out which findings occur due to ketamine's mechanism alone versus which changes are due to alterations in mood post ketamine. This may be especially relevant to ketamine imaging due to its rapid antidepressant effect (within hours). Fifth, although most studies used racemic ketamine, several others used the S-ketamine enantiomer. This may be an important difference because S-ketamine may have greater affinity to the NMDA receptor than its enantiomer, R-ketamine.Finally, it is important to note that most depression studies use subanesthetic ketamine doses of 0.5mg/kg over 40 minutes because this dose effectively treats depression. However, many studies with non-depressed patients used alternative doses. Though a study for ketamine's optimal antidepressant dose was recently completed (ClinicalTrials.gov ID: NCT01920555), the results are pending. Nonetheless, these reasons make it difficult to generalize the results of this review to large patient populations with depression. Further research is necessary to uncover ketamine's antidepressant mechanism of action and address the aforementioned limitations. This may be particularly helpful as it may uncover new working models of the biological substrates of depression and enable new drug discovery. Specifically, based on this review, future studies may focus on ketamine's action in the sgACC, PCC, PFC, and hippocampus as regions of interest. Furthermore, it has been suggested that depression is the result of underactive prefrontal and limbic mood regulation networks and over-reactive subcortical limbic networks involved in emotional and visceral responses.Perhaps these network abnormalities in depression-and their resulting improvements with treatment-can be further elucidated with the use of ketamine. Indeed, ketamine's remarkable rapid, robust, and sustained antidepressant effects are considered to be "arguably the most important discovery in half a century" for depression research.Given this, ketamine's potential use for uncovering important advances in depression research are very promising.
Full Text PDF
Study Details
- Study Typemeta
- Populationhumans
- Characteristicsliterature review
- Journal
- Compound