Ayahuasca and Public Health: Health Status, Psychosocial Well-Being, Lifestyle, and Coping Strategies in a Large Sample of Ritual Ayahuasca Users
This survey (n=380) focuses on psycho-social well-being, lifestyle, and coping strategies in a large sample of long-term ayahuasca users. The participants in this study associated long-term ayahuasca use with a higher positive perception of health or with a healthy lifestyle, among others. The study offers insight into the long-term effects of ayahuasca on public health and proposes incorporating a communitarian approach into society to benefit public health to ensure a respectful and controlled use of psychedelics.
Authors
- José Carlos Bouso
- Rafael Guimarães dos Santos
Published
Abstract
Introduction: Assessing the health status of ayahuasca users has been challenging due to the limitations involved in randomized clinical trials and psychometric approaches. The main objective of this study is the implementation of an approach based on public health indicators.Methods: We developed a self-administered questionnaire that was administered to long-term ayahuasca users around Spain. The questionnaire was administrated face-to-face to participants (n = 380) in places where ayahuasca ceremonies were occurring. Public health indicators were compared with Spanish normative data, and intergroup analyses were conducted.Results: Long-term ayahuasca use was associated with higher positive perception of health or with a healthy lifestyle, among other outcomes. Fifty-six percent of the sample reported reducing their use of prescription drugs due to ayahuasca use. Participants who used ayahuasca more than 100 times scored higher in personal values measures.Discussion: The main conclusion of this study is that a respectful and controlled use of hallucinogenic/psychedelic drugs taken in communitarian settings can be incorporated into modern society with benefits for public health. This new approach, based on the use of health indicators that were not used in previous ayahuasca studies, offers relevant information about the impact of long-term exposure to ayahuasca on public health.
Research Summary of 'Ayahuasca and Public Health: Health Status, Psychosocial Well-Being, Lifestyle, and Coping Strategies in a Large Sample of Ritual Ayahuasca Users'
Introduction
Ayahuasca is a traditional Amazonian decoction typically combining Banisteriopsis caapi with plants that contain N,N-dimethyltryptamine (DMT); its use has spread from indigenous and Brazilian religious settings into diverse international contexts. Earlier research has examined clinical trials of serotonergic psychedelics and population-level survey data, and some naturalistic comparisons of ritual users versus non-users have suggested better outcomes on certain neuropsychological and psychopathological measures. However, there has been little work using public-health indicators to assess the broader bio-psychosocial status of long-term ritual ayahuasca users outside clinical trials. Ona and colleagues set out to address that gap by conducting a face-to-face assessment of long-term ritual ayahuasca users in Spain using a self-administered questionnaire built from standard psychometric instruments and public-health survey indicators. The aim was to describe health status, psychosocial well-being, lifestyle, coping strategies, and personal values in this population and to compare key indicators with Spanish normative data, while also exploring associations with frequency of ayahuasca use, type of ceremony, and gender.
Methods
This was a cross-sectional, naturalistic assessment conducted over a six-month period in locations across Spain where ayahuasca ceremonies occurred. Inclusion required at least six months' ritual communitarian ayahuasca use; exclusion criteria were age under 18 and clinical suspicion of a neurocognitive disorder. The investigators collaborated with ICEERS to engage ceremony leaders and approached participants who planned to attend Santo Daime or neo‑shamanic rituals. Data collection involved a bespoke questionnaire assembled from items drawn from established psychometric scales and health surveys. The instrument covered eight dimensions: General Health (self-perceived health, BMI, chronic disease, physical limitation, sleep, cholesterol/blood pressure, medical/psychology visits, prescription-drug use), Lifestyle (physical activity, transport mode, diet), Positive Mental Health (e.g. meditation/yoga, feeling loved, vital goals, autonomy, happiness), Adjustment (selected items from the Bell Adjustment Inventory), Coping Strategies (items from the CSI and COPE), Cultural Activities and Reading, Social Support (number of close friends/family, availability of companions for medical visits and emotional sharing), and Personal Values (Engaged Living Scale with Valued Living and Life Fulfilment subscales). The General Health Questionnaire-12 (GHQ-12) was also administered as an independent mental-health measure. Questionnaires were completed face-to-face, prior to ceremonies, with trained psychologists or anthropologists obtaining informed consent; procedures received approval from the Universidad Autónoma de Madrid ethics committee. For analysis, descriptive statistics were presented and selected indicators were compared with Spanish normative data from recent health surveys. The multivariate General Linear Model (GLM) tested differences by number of ayahuasca uses, ceremony type (Santo Daime vs neo‑shamanic), and gender, with effect sizes (Cohen's d) calculated. A stepwise linear regression examined predictors of GHQ-12 scores. Significance was set at p < .05 with Bonferroni correction; IBM SPSS v21.0 and an online effect-size calculator were used.
Results
A total of 380 long-term ritual ayahuasca users completed the questionnaire; 47% were women, mean age was 44 years (SD = 10), and 32.5% reported membership of Santo Daime communities. Lifetime frequency of ayahuasca use varied: 34.2% had used it one to 10 times, and 29.7% reported more than 100 lifetime uses. In the previous six months the modal use was one to two times (38%), with 9.3% reporting more than 20 uses; the mean fell between three and five uses. Regarding subjective impact, 67% described ayahuasca's influence on their life as "very positive," 30.7% as "positive," and 1.7% as "no influence;" no participants reported a negative influence. Nearly half (49.7%) had used drugs other than ayahuasca in the prior six months, most commonly cannabis (31%), followed by MDMA (11%), psilocybin mushrooms (7.1%), and San Pedro cactus (7.1%). On general health indicators, 96.6% rated their health as good, very good, or excellent. Mean BMI was 22.6 (SD = 4.1), within the Spanish normal range. Only 7.4% had been told by a professional they had high cholesterol or blood pressure, a proportion lower than national figures reported by the authors. Nearly half (47.5%) did not visit a doctor in the previous six months and 47% visited one to three times; 81% had not visited a psychologist or psychiatrist in that period. More than half reported reducing use of medical services (53.5%) and mental-health services (57.3%) since using ayahuasca, and 56% reported a reduction in prescription-drug use. Regarding prescription medication in the prior six months, 57.2% reported no use, 39.6% used fewer than five drugs, and 3.2% used more than five. Lifestyle data showed 45.4% considered themselves less physically active than they wished. Modes of transport to work were: private vehicle 36%, walking 32.8%, bicycling 14%, and public transport 12.8%. Sleep problems in recent weeks were reported by 31.2%. Dietary attention was high, with 88.4% attempting healthier eating; 73% consumed one to three daily servings of fruit and 60% consumed one to three daily servings of vegetables. Measures of positive mental health were also high: 86.3% practised meditation or yoga, 98.2% reported having someone who loved them, 97% reported having vital goals, 92.6% reported personal autonomy, and 90.4% reported being quite to immensely happy (43.7% "quite happy," 39.2% "very happy," 7.5% "immensely happy"). On adjustment items the mean score was 3.4 (SD = 0.7) with only 5.3% scoring at levels interpreted as poor adjustment. Coping strategy items yielded a mean of 9.3 (SD = 1.8), with 1.1% scoring five or less and 45% scoring 10 or more. Cultural engagement was reported by 38%–42.5% and 86.2% had read one or more books in the prior six months. Social support indicators were strong: only 2% reported having no close friends or family, 39.4% reported four to six close contacts, and 22% reported 10 or more; 96.3% had someone to accompany them to medical visits, 97% had someone expressing affection, 96.8% could share feelings of joy or sadness, and 96.6% had someone with whom to share private fears and worries. On the Engaged Living Scale, Valued Living mean was 42.6 (SD = 4.6), Life Fulfilment mean was 24.4 (SD = 3), and total engaged-living mean was 67 (SD = 10), with 30% scoring above 70. The GHQ-12 mean was 1.3 (SD = 2.3), and 82.7% scored three or less. Multivariate GLM analyses showed no significant differences by number of lifetime ayahuasca uses overall; those reporting more than 100 uses differed primarily by being older and scoring higher on personal values measures. Participants in Santo Daime ceremonies had fewer mental-health visits in the prior six months than neo‑shamanic participants. Stepwise linear regression identified Valued Living, Engaged Living, and Self-Perceived Health Status as predictors of GHQ-12 scores.
Discussion
Ona and colleagues interpret these findings as the first large-scale, public-health‑oriented snapshot of long-term ritual ayahuasca users in Spain. The participants overwhelmingly described the ayahuasca experience as positive and, on many indicators, compared favourably with Spanish normative data: high rates of positive self-rated health, normal mean BMI, lower reported high cholesterol and hypertension, lower prevalence of chronic disease and physical limitations, healthier dietary habits, and strong social support measures. The GHQ-12 distribution was similar to national norms overall, although women in this sample reportedly had better mental-health scores than Spanish population norms. The authors note that prevalence of recent use of other psychoactive drugs in their sample was higher than in the general population (except for alcohol), a result they suggest may reflect the inclusion of non-religious ritual participants; earlier studies that found lower concurrent drug use tended to sample members of ayahuasca religions, where doctrine may discourage other drug use. Despite that higher prevalence, the sample's drug use consisted mainly of cannabis and psychedelics, which the authors characterise as generally associated with less social and physical harm than substances such as alcohol or heroin. Regarding associations, sustained high-frequency participation (>100 lifetime uses) was linked to higher scores on personal values and older age, which the authors interpret as possible reinforcement of values through ongoing involvement in communities that endorse those values. Santo Daime members appeared to use mental-health services less often than neo‑shamanic participants, potentially reflecting doctrinal emphasis on spirituality and healing. The regression analysis indicated that Valued Living, Engaged Living, and Self-Perceived Health Status—rather than ayahuasca use per se—predicted GHQ-12 scores, suggesting personal values and perceived health are important correlates of mental-health status in this group. Key limitations are acknowledged: the self-selected sample may over-represent individuals who derive benefit from ayahuasca and therefore could understate risks; no sample-size calculation was performed; the sample was not stratified by gender or region and thus may not be representative (for example, health-sector workers were over-represented and most participants lived in Catalonia); and national prevalence of ayahuasca use is unknown because national drug surveys do not include it. The investigators caution that these cross-sectional data cannot establish causality and that participants might have had similar profiles prior to starting ayahuasca. Their principal conclusion is cautious: ritual, communal use of ayahuasca in respectful and controlled settings is not associated in this sample with adverse adjustment or poor physical or psychological health, and may be compatible with beneficial public-health indicators; they call for further studies with more representative samples using health indicators to clarify these relationships.
View full paper sections
RESULTS
Descriptive statistics were used to present the data. Data for the most relevant health indicators were compared with Spanish normative data from various health surveys published between 2014 and 2018. Data from the psychometric questionnaires were compared with normative Spanish data. The multivariate General Linear Model (GLM) was performed with the number of times that ayahuasca was used, type of ceremony (Santo Daime vs Neoshamanic groups), and gender as factors, in order to determine differences between groups. The corresponding size effect (Cohen's d) was also calculated. A linear regression model (stepwise method) was performed to find which variables can better predict the mental health status of the sample, measured by GHQ-12. A p value of <.05 was considered statistically significant for both analyses. Bonferroni multiple comparisons correction was applied. IBM® SPSS version 21.0 software package was used. An online calculator of effect size was used ().
CONCLUSION
The study results are described in terms of a series of indicators that assessed bio-psychosocial factors among a large sample of long-term ritualistic ayahuasca users. Previous studies that assessed the mental health status of psychedelic users analyzed data from national surveysor from naturalistic studies comparing users with non-users. This is the first study in which a large sample of psychedelic users has been assessed using indicators from a public health perspective. Almost all of the participants described their experience with ayahuasca as "very positive" or "positive," whereas no participants described it as "negative" or "very negative." Regarding the use of other drugs, the prevalence of use in the previous six months was considerably higher than the Spanish general population, excepting alcohol, both for the total sample and when stratifying by age (OEDA 2017). These results are in disagreement with previous studies, except regarding alcohol intake. The reason for the disagreement may be that the earlier studies were conducted with samples of participants who belonged to ayahuasca religions, and the influence of religious doctrine may be a protective factor against the misuse of psychoactive drugs. In our sample, only 32.5% were members of an ayahuasca religion. These results are interesting because ayahuasca has been proposed as a treatment for drug dependence. Since psychedelic experiences are context-dependent, the achievement of a positive outcome seems not to be an inherent property of the substance. Although in disagreement, our results do not contradict those of earlier studies, since our participants seem to engage in the responsible use of other psychoactive drugs, as reflected in the better scores obtained by this study's participants on most of the assessed health indicators relative to the general population. Moreover, participants described using mostly cannabis and psychedelics, which are substances associated with less social and physical harm to the individual and to society when compared to other drugs such as alcohol, crack cocaine, and heroin. Compared to the general Spanish population, our participants scored higher in terms of perceiving their health status positively (ENSE 2017), had BMIs within the normal range (SEEDO 2018), and had lower levels of cholesterol and hypertension (ENSE 2017), both for the general sample and when stratified by age. In addition, the prevalence of chronic diseases was lower among our sample, as compared to the general Spanish population. Our sample was mostly composed of people who live in the Catalonia territory (69.7%), and the prevalence of chronic disorders is also lower in the general Catalonian population (38%) than in the general Spanish population (60%). Our sample scored lower than the general Catalonian population in terms of chronic disease prevalence, both for the general sample and when stratified by age (OSG 2014). The prevalence of physical limitations was half that compared with the general sample and when stratified by age (INEBase 2014). More than the half of the sample reported reducing their use of medical and/or mental health services due to ayahuasca use. Reportedly, 52.5% of our sample visited a doctor in the previous six months, while 86.8% of the general Spanish population visited a doctor in the previous 12 months (ENSE 2017). Furthermore, 56% of the sample reported reducing their use of prescription drugs due to ayahuasca use. Some authors claim that there is a crisis in psychopharmacology because the mechanistic models of molecules do not satisfactorily explain the causes of diseases and, thus, there are no optimal treatments for most mental disorders. With the renaissance occurring in psychedelic therapy, where substances like MDMA, psilocybin, and ayahuasca are showing promise for the treatment of disorders like PTSD and major depression (dos, some authors are proposing that psychedelics may be the "cure" to this crisis. Our results can be interpreted as preliminary evidence that psychedelics offer promise for the treatment of mental health problems. Regarding lifestyle indicators, our sample used their own vehicle as a mode of transportation less than the general Spanish population (CONAMA 2016), and their daily intake of fruits and vegetables was considerably higher (5aldía 2018). In this study, participants also completed the GHQ-12, an instrument widely used to determine a person's risk of having a diagnosable psychiatric disorder. The results in our study were similar to the Spanish normative data. Most participants (82.7%) scored below the cut-off point for having a diagnosable psychiatric disorder. The prevalence of a degree of mental disturbance is very similar between ayahuasca users and the general population (18.5% and 19.4%, respectively). However, Good Mental Health (a score below 3) for the women in our sample was more than five points better than for the Spanish general population. These results regarding mental health are in agreement with previous studies that assessed the mental health status of ayahuasca users, where there were no differences found to exist between users and non-usersor between users and the general population. More than 85% of our participants engaged in activities that we categorized as having a positive effect on mental health, like yoga (which is practiced regularly by 12% of the general Spanish population (AOMM 2014)) or meditation. Our participants were also relatively interested in cultural activities, and their book-reading habits (86.2%) are above the mean for the general Spanish population (which is 65.8%; CONECTA 2018). Furthermore, positive self-perceptions of happiness were reported by over 90% of respondents, which is similar to the general Spanish population (CIS 2017). Regarding social support, only 2% of the sample reported not having any close friends or family members, while 97% reported having someone who expressed affection to them. The perception of having strong social bonds is an indicator of positive mental health. Finally, we selected specific items from several validated rating scales to assess adjustment, coping and personal values. Regarding adjustment, only 5.3% of the sample obtained scores indicating poor general adjustment. Regarding coping strategies, only 1.1% showed poor coping strategies. Furthermore, regarding personal values, there is no Spanish normative data with which to make a comparison, but high scores were obtained for the three scales. We were interested in collecting this kind of data, since personal values can guide one's goals and actions, and could thus be related to some of the other analyzed variables. Under the ACT model (a "third wave" cognitive behavior therapy), it is assumed that personal values play a vital role in the interpretation of thoughts and experiences, acting like a modulating variable that changes potential relationships with them. Similar studies used this approach in ayahuasca users) and when analyzing practices like sweatlodge ceremonies or the use of other psychedelic drugs like peyote in Navajo communities, finding that psychedelic practices performed in ritualistic communitarian contexts share some of the assumptions or concepts of the ACT model, such as the process of acceptance and commitment to the "true ways" of a community. Therefore, these rituals can clarify values and promote commitment to community. Multivariate GLM showed no significant differences based on the number of times ayahuasca was used. Those who had taken ayahuasca more than 100 times only differed in age (as they tended to be older) and in personal values (demonstrating more valued living and general engaged living). The finding regarding personal values suggests a reinforcement of personal values through a sustained participation in contexts where those values are endorsed. Participants in Santo Daime ceremonies visited mental health services fewer times in the previous six months than participants in neo-shamanic groups, which may be explained by their adherence to a religious group) in which, besides spirituality, healing is one of the main goals of the doctrine (MacRae 1998). A linear regression model was also used to determine if any variables could be seen as predictors of the sample's mental health status. One of our main interests was to see if the use of ayahuasca could predict mental health status, following findings obtained in clinical contexts. However, only Valued Living, Engaged Living, and Self-Perceived Health Status could be included in the model as predictor variables. While the latter is reasonable, it is surprising to find personal values highly correlated with mental health status. However, early research in this field found similar results, showing moderate to high correlations between psychological well-being and variables closely related to what was measured here as engaged living. Finally, the positive results obtained in this study cannot be attributed to an eventual higher socioeconomic position of our sample, since there were no differences with regard to the general Spanish population in experiencing financial difficulties (24.3%; INEBase 2017). The main limitation of this study is that the sample was self-selected. It is possible that only those who obtain some benefit from the regular use of ayahuasca are able to maintain this practice, so we may be underestimating potential risks and overestimating potential benefits. A study focused on people who used ayahuasca but then stopped using it at some point is necessary. Another limitation is that no sample-size calculations were conducted and the sample was not stratified by gender or region, so our sample may not be representative of the general Spanish population. For example, more than 20% of the sample worked in the health sector (whereas only 5.6% of the general Spanish population works in this sector; Fedea 2014) and almost 30% lived in towns with fewer than 5,000 inhabitants (the majority of the Spanish population lives in cities with 20,000 to 50,000 people; INEBase 2016). Similarly, the number of ayahuasca users in Spain cannot be known, since national surveys concerning drug use have not included ayahuasca. To our knowledge, this is the first study to assess regular ayahuasca users from a communitarian public health perspective. The data suggest that the study participants had high levels of general, mental, and positive health, and showed excellent levels in terms of adjustment and coping strategies, in addition to having healthy lifestyle habits. Study results do not suggest the possible effects of ayahuasca, but they show how the ritualistic use of a drug considered a hallucinogen is not associated with negative consequences in terms of adjustment or physical and psychological health. It is possible that the sample would have scored similarly even before starting to use ayahuasca, and that this practice had been adopted as another self-care activity that allows them to achieve a healthy lifestyle. The main conclusion of this study is that a respectful and controlled use of hallucinogenic/ psychedelic drugs taken in communitarian settings can be incorporated into modern society with potential benefits for public health. Studies using health indicators with more representative samples of psychedelic users in communitarian settings are warranted.
Study Details
- Study Typeindividual
- Populationhumans
- Characteristicssurvey
- Journal
- Compounds
- Authors