Assessing the psychedelic “after-glow” in ayahuasca users: post-acute neurometabolic and functional connectivity changes are associated with enhanced mindfulness capacities
This open-label study (n=16) investigated neurometabolic and connectivity modifications after a single ayahuasca use and their association with mindfulness measures. The results support the involvement of glutamate neurotransmission in the effects of ayahuasca. Furthermore, changes in the posterior cingulate cortex (default network) and connection of the posterior cingulate cortex and the medial temporal lobe (emotion & memory) may contribute to the effects of ayahuasca.
Authors
- Jordi Riba
Published
Abstract
Background: Ayahuasca is a plant tea containing the psychedelic 5-HT2A agonist N,N-dimethyltryptamine and harmala monoamine-oxidase inhibitors. Acute administration leads to neurophysiological modifications in brain regions of the default mode network, purportedly through a glutamatergic mechanism. Post-acutely, ayahuasca potentiates mindfulness capacities in volunteers and induces rapid and sustained antidepressant effects in treatment-resistant patients. However, the mechanisms underlying these fast and maintained effects are poorly understood. Here, we investigated in an open-label uncontrolled study in 16 healthy volunteers ayahuasca-induced post-acute neurometabolic and connectivity modifications and their association with mindfulness measures.Methods: Using 1H-magnetic resonance spectroscopy and functional connectivity, we compared baseline and post-acute neurometabolites and seed-to-voxel connectivity in the posterior and anterior cingulate cortex after a single ayahuasca dose.Results: Magnetic resonance spectroscopy showed post-acute reductions in glutamate+glutamine, creatine, and N-acetylaspartate+N-acetylaspartylglutamate in the posterior cingulate cortex. Connectivity was increased between the posterior cingulate cortex and the anterior cingulate cortex, and between the anterior cingulate cortex and limbic structures in the right medial temporal lobe. Glutamate+glutamine reductions correlated with increases in the “nonjudging” subscale of the Five Facets Mindfulness Questionnaire. Increased anterior cingulate cortex-medial temporal lobe connectivity correlated with increased scores on the self-compassion questionnaire. Post-acute neural changes predicted sustained elevations in nonjudging 2 months later.Conclusions: These results support the involvement of glutamate neurotransmission in the effects of psychedelics in humans. They further suggest that neurometabolic changes in the posterior cingulate cortex, a key region within the default mode network, and increased connectivity between the anterior cingulate cortex and medial temporal lobe structures involved in emotion and memory potentially underlie the post-acute psychological effects of ayahuasca.
Research Summary of 'Assessing the psychedelic “after-glow” in ayahuasca users: post-acute neurometabolic and functional connectivity changes are associated with enhanced mindfulness capacities'
Introduction
Psychedelics have regained research interest for their potential therapeutic effects in psychiatry. Ayahuasca is an Amazonian brew combining DMT, a 5-HT2A agonist, with β-carbolines that inhibit monoamine oxidase and enable oral activity of DMT. Acute ayahuasca administration produces intense introspective states and measurable neurophysiological changes in nodes of the default mode network (DMN), particularly the posterior cingulate cortex (PCC), while radiotracer studies point to increased activity in limbic and cingulate regions involved in emotion and memory. Previous clinical reports have also documented rapid and sustained antidepressant effects and post-acute increases in mindfulness-related capacities after single doses, but the neural mechanisms that might underlie these sustained or "after-glow" effects remain unclear. Sampedro and colleagues set out to characterise post-acute (within 24 hours) neurometabolic and resting-state functional connectivity changes after a single ayahuasca session in healthy volunteers, and to test whether those neural changes relate to enhancements in mindfulness capacities measured immediately and at a 2-month follow-up. They focused on the PCC and anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) as a priori regions of interest and hypothesised: (1) post-acute decreases in Glx (combined glutamate plus glutamine) and energy metabolites in PCC and ACC reflecting prior excitatory effects; (2) reduced PCC–ACC anticorrelation (increased coupling) paralleling neurometabolic changes; and (3) correlations between neural changes and increases in mindfulness measures both post-acutely and at follow-up. The study is an open-label, within-subject pre/post assessment in experienced ayahuasca users.
Methods
This was an open-label, uncontrolled within-subject MRI study in 16 healthy volunteers (6 females) with prior ayahuasca experience. Exclusion criteria included current or past psychiatric disorder, substance dependence, significant illness, and pregnancy. All participants provided written informed consent and the protocol was approved by a local ethics committee. A single, chemically analysed batch of ayahuasca was administered to all participants. Mean intake was 148 ± 29 mL, corresponding to mean doses of 45 ± 9 mg DMT and quantified amounts of harmine, tetrahydroharmine and harmaline; the reported DMT dose is approximately 0.64 mg/kg for a 70-kg person. No placebo or control condition was used; analyses compared post- vs pre-ayahuasca values within participants. Each participant underwent MRI twice: a baseline scan within 24 hours before the ayahuasca session and a post-acute scan within 24 hours after the session, scheduled at approximately the same time of day. Imaging on a 3T Siemens TIM Trio included high-resolution T1, single-voxel 1H magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) in three volumes of interest (VOIs: PCC, ACC, cerebellum), and 7-minute resting-state BOLD for functional connectivity. MRS quantified absolute concentrations of Cr (creatine), Cho (choline), Ins (inositol), Glx (glutamate plus glutamine), and NAA-NAAG (N-acetylaspartate plus N-acetylaspartylglutamate). Absolute metabolite levels rather than ratios were used to avoid potential confounds with creatine. Resting-state functional connectivity analyses used CONN software. Seed-to-voxel maps were computed for three spherical seeds (10-mm radius): PCC at MNI 0,-56,28; dorsal ACC (dACC) at 5,14,42; and superior rostral ACC (srACC) at 0,15,30. Preprocessing and first-level analyses produced individual z-maps which entered paired-samples second-level t tests comparing post- vs pre-ayahuasca. Cluster-level family-wise error correction (FWE) was applied with threshold FWE < 0.05 and minimum cluster size 20 voxels. Psychological measures comprised the Spanish versions of the Five Facet Mindfulness Questionnaire (FFMQ), the Experiences Questionnaire (EQ), and a short Self-Compassion (SC) scale; a Mindsens Composite Index was computed from FFMQ and EQ items. Questionnaires were completed at baseline, within 24 hours post-intake, and at a 2-month follow-up (14/16 participants responded). Acute subjective effects were assessed retrospectively at the post-acute visit using the Hallucinogen Rating Scale (HRS) and compared to previously collected laboratory data for verification of psychoactivity. Statistical analyses: MRS concentrations were analysed with repeated-measures ANOVA (factors: ayahuasca intake and metabolite type) per VOI, followed by pair-wise t tests when appropriate; significance set at P < .05 and FDR correction reported. Connectivity changes used paired t tests on z-maps with FWE cluster correction. Mindfulness changes were tested with paired t tests; follow-up analyses were noted as exploratory due to smaller sample. Exploratory correlations used difference scores (post-minus-pre) between neural measures and questionnaire or HRS scores; no multiple comparisons correction was applied for these exploratory correlations and results were interpreted cautiously.
Results
All 16 participants completed baseline and post-acute assessments; no drop-outs or exclusions for movement in the fMRI data were reported. MRS data availability varied due to signal-to-noise limitations: usable Glx data in the PCC for 12 participants, ACC for 13, cerebellum for 11; most other metabolites quantified in 14 participants. In the PCC VOI, repeated-measures ANOVA showed a significant metabolite-type effect and an interaction between intake and metabolite type. Pair-wise comparisons indicated significant post-acute decreases in creatine (Cr) and NAA-NAAG; Glx (glutamate+glutamine) was reduced in an initial t test (P = .041) but this effect became marginal after FDR correction (P = .068). Inositol and choline showed no changes. In the ACC and cerebellum VOIs there were no significant effects of ayahuasca intake on metabolite concentrations apart from the expected metabolite-type differences. Resting-state connectivity analyses found several post-acute changes. Prior to ayahuasca, the PCC seed showed positive correlations with DMN regions and negative correlations (anticorrelations) with ACC and task-positive networks (TPNs). Post-acutely, the negative correlation between PCC and ACC was markedly reduced, indicating decreased orthogonality of their BOLD activity. Cluster-level increases in PCC seed connectivity were observed in the ACC and a large occipital visual cluster where connectivity shifted from negative to positive; additional increases emerged in pre- and post-central gyri, superior temporal gyrus and insula. No clusters showed decreased connectivity for the PCC seed in the second-level analysis. Using the dACC seed, post-acute increases in connectivity appeared with medial parietal cortex including precuneus/PCC, while connectivity with visual association areas (BA 18/19) decreased. The srACC seed showed increased coupling with medial temporal lobe (MTL) limbic structures on the right — parahippocampal gyrus, hippocampus, amygdala — as well as left parietal and medial parietal (PCC) regions; srACC–visual cortex coupling was reduced post-acutely. On psychological measures, paired comparisons showed post-acute increases in FFMQ subscales nonjudging [t(15) = -2.92, P = .011; FDR P = .021] and nonreacting [t(15) = -2.61, P = .020; FDR P = .031]. The EQ increased post-acutely [t(15) = -3.58, P = .003; FDR P = .011], the Mindsens composite rose [t(15) = -3.63, P = .002; FDR P = .011], and self-compassion scores increased [t(15) = -3.00, P = .009; FDR P = .020]. At the 2-month follow-up (n = 14), only the nonjudging FFMQ score remained significantly higher than baseline by paired t test [t(13) = -2.22, P = .045], though this did not survive FDR correction (P = .495); other scales returned to baseline. Retrospective HRS data confirmed significant acute psychoactive effects; in comparison with prior laboratory data at 0.75 mg DMT/kg, most HRS subscales matched that medium dose except cognition which was higher in the present sample (t(26) = 4.25, FDR P < .01). Exploratory correlations linked neural and psychological changes. Greater decreases in PCC Cr and in NAA-NAAG correlated with higher HRS-Cognition scores (Cr: n = 14, r = -0.735, r2 = 0.540, P = .003; NAA-NAAG: n = 14, r = -0.622, r2 = 0.387, P = .018). Glx decreases in the PCC correlated with increases in the FFMQ nonjudging subscale post-acutely (n = 12, r = -0.589, r2 = 0.506, P = .044) and at 2 months (n = 11, r = -0.740, r2 = 0.548, P = .009). Functional connectivity increases between srACC and PCC correlated with post-acute increases in nonjudging (n = 16, r = 0.604, r2 = 0.365, P = .013) and nonreacting (n = 16, r = 0.522, r2 = 0.272, P = .038); srACC–MTL connectivity increases correlated with nonjudging (n = 16, r = 0.637, r2 = 0.406, P = .008), nonreacting (n = 16, r = 0.656, r2 = 0.430, P = .006), and self-compassion (n = 16, r = 0.514, r2 = 0.264, P = .042). Post-acute increases in srACC–PCC and ACC–MTL connectivity were also positively associated with sustained nonjudging at follow-up (srACC–PCC: n = 14, r = 0.584, r2 = 0.341, P = .028; ACC–MTL: n = 14, r = 0.566, r2 = 0.320, P = .035). The authors note these correlation analyses were exploratory and not corrected for multiple comparisons.
Discussion
Sampedro and colleagues interpret their findings as evidence that ayahuasca induces measurable neurometabolic and functional connectivity changes that persist into the post-acute "after-glow" period and relate to enhanced mindfulness capacities. The post-acute reductions in Glx in the PCC (Glx = combined glutamate plus glutamine) together with decreases in Cr and NAA-NAAG are consistent with a model whereby acute 5-HT2A-driven excitatory glutamatergic activity is followed by a relative post-acute reduction in metabolite levels. The authors argue this pattern fits prior electrophysiological reports of decreased inhibitory alpha rhythms during acute psychedelic states and with other data suggesting acute glutamatergic activation. Functionally, the data showed reduced anticorrelation and increased coupling between DMN (PCC) and ACC/TPN regions, plus enhanced srACC connectivity with medial temporal limbic structures. According to the authors, these changes provide a neural substrate for the observed psychological effects: reduced self-referential, judgmental and reactive processing, increased decentering and self-compassion, and greater interplay between cognitive control and memory/emotion circuits. They note parallels with mindfulness training, which also reduces DMN–TPN anticorrelation, and propose that such neural reorganisation could help explain rapid and sustained antidepressant effects reported in clinical studies. The authors acknowledge several limitations. The sample was small and open-label with no placebo or time-control condition, so effects could reflect non-specific or expectancy influences. MRS Glx quantification suffered from signal limitations that reduced sample size for some analyses. All participants had prior ayahuasca experience and presented relatively high baseline mindfulness scores, which may both bias results and constrain the magnitude of potential increases. Correlational findings were exploratory and not corrected for multiple comparisons. Finally, only a subacute window was sampled (within 24 hours post-intake), so connectivity changes cannot be assumed to reflect persistent network reorganisation over longer timescales. For future research, the authors recommend larger, double-blind, placebo-controlled designs and inclusion of ayahuasca-naive participants to disentangle prior exposure effects. They conclude that the observed post-acute neurometabolic decreases in PCC and increased inter-network connectivity were associated with enhanced mindfulness facets, providing tentative neurobiological clues to how ayahuasca and similar psychedelics might exert therapeutic effects.
View full paper sections
RESULTS
All 16 participants completed the baseline and post-acute assessments. There were no drop-outs in the study.
CONCLUSION
Here we investigated the neural correlates of the psychedelic "after-glow" induced by ayahuasca in healthy volunteers. Using 2 different MRI techniques, we evidenced significant neurometabolic and functional connectivity changes hours after the acute effects of ayahuasca had disappeared. These modifications were associated with immediate changes in the psychological sphere that were marginally maintained 2 months later. Our results replicate previous findings of enhanced mindfulness capacities, including increased "decentering," and decreased judgmental and reactive attitudes during the post-acute phase of ayahuasca. Ayahuasca had the power to increase FFMQ, EQ, and Mindsens scores in individuals with already high baseline scores. We also found increases in selfcompassion, a previously unexplored facet in this context. MRS showed neurometabolic changes in the PCC, a region rich in 5-HT 2A receptorsand a target region of psychedelics. Glx levels in the PCC were lower in the post-acute assessment compared with baseline values, an effect that was however only marginally significant when corrected for multiple comparisons. We thus obtained partial evidence for the previously postulated involvement of glutamate neurotransmission in the effects of psychedelics. While we did not measure Glx levels during the acute psychedelic phase, our MRS findings are compatible with increased glutamate levels during the acute stage. Cortical glutamate levels increase in periods of external perceptual stimulation or during active cognitive tasks, while they fall below baseline levels during stimulation-or task-free periods. Also, acute psilocybin decreases brain aspartate, a neurotransmitter whose levels vary in an anticorrelated fashion with those of glutamate. The post-acute Glx decreases in the PCC may result from increased excitatory activity during the acute phase. EEG and MEG studies in humans have shown a decrease of alpha oscillations, an inhibitory rhythm, in the parieto-occipital cortex during the acute effects of psychedelics. The post-acute Glx reductions in the PCC are also consistent with the observed reductions in Cr, NAA, and NAAG. Cr and N-acetyl compounds have been associated with metabolic activity, and NAAG has been directly linked to glutamatergic pathways. Additionally, the inverse correlation found between Cr and NAA-NAAG variations and scores on the HRS-Cognition subscale suggest a relationship between the intensity of acute effects and subsequent neurometabolic reductions. Neurometabolic changes may have contributed to the antidepressant effects reported for ayahuasca. Depressed patients show abnormally high glutamate levels in the parieto-occipital cortex. Glutamate reductions in these areas correlate with clinical improvement in depression. The functional connectivity analysis also evidenced postacute changes. Activity in the PCC and associated areas within the DMNhas been associated with the personal sense of "self." Psychedelics acutely loosen the boundaries of the "self" and increase the cross-talk between networks. Here, we found a post-acute increase in coupling between the PCC and a subregion of the ACC pertaining to the TPNs. While DMN and TPN activity are typically anticorrelated, psilocybin and LSD acutely increase DMN-TPN connectivity, and general inter-network connectivity. Our results suggest that cross-talk lingers beyond the acute stage and contributes to the "after-glow," reflected as enhanced mindfulness capacities. Increased DMN-TPN connectivity correlated with reduced judgmental processing, inner reactivity, and increased self-kindness, providing a neurobiological basis for these modifications. Conventional mindfulness training also increases DMN-TPN connectivity. Visual areas showed increased coupling with the PCC but reduced with the ACC. This pattern suggests a greater interplay between internally generated visual information and spontaneous mind-wandering, and a reduction in cognitive control. These effects could explain increased phosphenes or "entoptic activity" persisting days after ayahuasca use. A previous neuroimaging study found increased activity in the visual cortex under ayahuasca. The superior rostral ACC (srACC) seed also demonstrated increased functional coupling with parahippocampal, hippocampal, and amygdalar areas of the MTL. Prior studies had identified these areas as targets of acute ayahuasca. LSD acutely decreases fear recognition, an effect mediated by the amygdala, and psilocybin increases synchronization between the hippocampus and the ACC. Our data suggest that during the "after-glow" there is an enhanced interplay between the ACC, participating in executive tasks and in the binding of cognitive and emotional information, with limbic structures with key roles in emotion and memory processes. This finding is particularly relevant in the interpretation of the antidepressant effects of ayahuasca. Other researchers have found abnormal interactions between the srACC and the amygdala in depressed patients, possibly indicating decreased cognitive control over negative emotions. Our data show for the first time that the modification induced by psychedelics on brain dynamics leads to changes in its neurometabolic, functional, and psychological balance beyond the acute stage. As previously reported, the post-acute phase in our study showed positive psychological effects, highlighting the paradoxical nature of psychedelics. While the acute inebriation shares features with psychosis, psychedelics may lead to mid-term increases in psychological well-being. Increasing mindfulness capacities is clearly a desirable effect, especially in a psychotherapeutic context. Here post-acute scores were above values reported for meditators, a population that also shows a pattern of decreased DMN-TPN anticorrelation. Considering that maladaptive ruminations in depression have been associated with greater DMN "dominance" over TPN activity, our results provide another interesting link between psychedelic-induced neural modifications and the therapeutic potential of ayahuasca. The post-acute phase of the psychedelic experience had received little attention from modern neuroscience. Although investigators had postulated the capacity of psychedelics to modulate brain plasticity, most research had assessed mid-and long-term effects only from a psychological perspective. The changes in personality and life attitudes reported in the 1960shave recently been replicated as increases in trait openness. Also, in a structural neuroimaging study of regular ayahuasca users, we found a cortical thinning of the PCC, the area showing neurometabolic decreases in the present study. PCC thinning was inversely correlated with increased self-transcendence, a personality trait closely related to openness. Our MRS and connectivity data provide a biological basis for the therapeutic effects of ayahuasca. Its potential to influence brain dynamics at multiple levels suggests its usefulness to treat disorders that are highly refractory to therapeutic intervention. Its combined effect on the psychological and neural spheres may be particularly well suited to treat addiction disorders, where high impulsivity and self-centeredness coexist with alterations in brain function and structure. Our study has several limitations that need to be mentioned. We assessed a small sample of individuals before and after ayahuasca intake, with no control for placebo or time effects. The difficulties associated with Glx quantification allowed measurement in an even smaller sample. All participants had previous experience with ayahuasca, which may have biased our sample to individuals who usually experience positive effects after intake. Additionally, participants showed high baseline scores on several mindfulness facets. While this could be considered a limitation, it is also true that these capacities show "ceiling" effects and are difficult to increase in high scorers. The correlation analysis should be considered exploratory and interpreted with caution. Finally, our study investigated only the subacute stage of ayahuasca effects. The observed connectivity modifications cannot be interpreted as indicating persistent network changes. Future studies should consider using larger samples and double-blind, placebo-controlled designs. Also, the role of prior exposure to ayahuasca could be better established by recruiting less experienced or even ayahuasca-naive individuals To conclude, the present results indicate that ayahuasca and potentially other psychedelics induce neural modifications beyond the time frame of the acute inebriation. Neurometabolic decreases in the PCC and the increased inter-network connectivity were associated with enhanced mindfulness facets. These associations provide hints to a potential biological basis for the therapeutic effects of ayahuasca.
Study Details
- Study Typeindividual
- Populationhumans
- Characteristicsopen labelbrain measures
- Journal
- Compounds
- Author