5-HT2A Agonists: A Novel Therapy for Functional Neurological Disorders?
This paper (2017) argues that 5-HT2A agonists should be investigated as a potential treatment for functional neurological disorders.
Authors
- Bryson, A.
- Carter, O.
- Kanaan, R. A.
Published
Abstract
Functional neurological disorders are frequently encountered in clinical practice. They have a poor prognosis and treatment options are limited. Their etiology is unknown, but leading theories propose a disturbance of somatic self-representation: the mind perceives dysfunction of a body region despite intact motor and sensory pathways. Central to this model is the concept of an abnormal top-down cognitive influence upon sensorimotor function. There is growing interest in the use of 5-HT2A agonists in the management of neuropsychiatric conditions. Recent studies have shown that these agents induce changes in neural activity that disrupt hierarchical brain dynamics and modulate networks subserving self-related processing. Converging evidence suggests they may hold unique therapeutic potential in functional neurological disorders. This is of importance given the considerable personal and societal burden of this condition and we argue a clinical trial to test this hypothesis is warranted.
Research Summary of '5-HT2A Agonists: A Novel Therapy for Functional Neurological Disorders?'
Introduction
Functional neurological disorders (FNDs) are common conditions at the interface of neurology and psychiatry that are associated with a poor prognosis and limited, inconsistently effective treatments. Bryson and colleagues describe prevailing theoretical accounts that implicate a disturbance of somatic self-representation and an excessive top-down cognitive influence on sensorimotor processes as central to FND pathophysiology. These models—supported by behavioural studies and functional neuroimaging—help explain clinical features such as loss of motor agency and symptom variability with attentional focus. This paper sets out to synthesise evidence from cellular, neurophysiological and neuroimaging studies of 5-HT2A agonists and to argue that these agents may have unique therapeutic potential in FNDs. The authors propose that because 5-HT2A agonists perturb hierarchical brain dynamics and modulate networks involved in self-related processing, they could weaken pathological higher-order priors and restore more adaptive sensorimotor integration; on that basis the paper argues a clinical trial is warranted.
Methods
The extracted text does not present a formal Methods section or a description of a systematic literature search; the paper is a narrative, mechanistic review and theoretical argument rather than a primary empirical study. Bryson and colleagues synthesise findings from cellular neurophysiology, EEG and fMRI studies, and behavioural and clinical observations of FNDs to construct a cross-level account linking 5-HT2A receptor pharmacology to the proposed pathophysiology of FND. Rather than reporting new experimental data, the authors combine prior experimental findings on receptor expression and single-neuron effects, macroscopic imaging/EEG studies of 5-HT2A agonists, and existing neuroimaging and behavioural literature on FNDs. Where relevant, they interpret these data within neurobiological and computational (Bayesian) models of perception and agency to derive testable clinical hypotheses. The extracted text does not detail inclusion/exclusion criteria, search dates, or risk-of-bias assessment because it is not a systematic review.
Results
The paper summarises clinical and mechanistic findings from prior literature relevant to FNDs and 5-HT2A agonists rather than presenting novel results. Clinically, FNDs are defined by neurological symptoms without structural pathology and include presentations such as functional weakness, visual disturbance and movement disorders. Diagnosis rests on normal investigations and characteristic inconsistencies on examination (for example, symptom improvement with diversion of attention). Psychiatric comorbidity may be present but is not required, and conventional treatment options (psychotherapy, physiotherapy) have limited evidence; overall prognosis is often unfavourable and the condition imposes substantial individual and healthcare burdens. Neuroimaging and behavioural studies discussed in the paper implicate disturbances in motor agency, self-monitoring and somatic self-representation. In particular, reduced activation of the right temporo-parietal junction (TPJ) in patients with functional motor symptoms contrasts with normal TPJ activation in feigned weakness, consistent with a mismatch between movement intention and outcome. Behavioural research shows heightened body vigilance and a tendency to resolve ambiguous sensory input in favour of somatic explanations. Corresponding neuroimaging findings include increased activity in nodes of the default mode network (DMN)—notably the ventromedial prefrontal cortex, precuneus and insula—which are involved in introspective and self-related processing. The authors present the leading neurobiological model alongside a Bayesian formulation: both posit that excessively precise higher-order priors (abnormal somatic representations) exert pathological top-down influence over lower-order sensorimotor signals, producing persistent functional symptoms that are reinforced by attentional focus. Summarising evidence on 5-HT2A agonists, Bryson and colleagues report cellular findings that activation of the 5-HT2A receptor increases excitability of pyramidal neurons (with prominent receptor expression in prefrontal and association cortex and a subcellular localisation favouring proximal apical dendrites), and may alter interneuronal synchrony. At the network level, neuroimaging and EEG studies show that 5-HT2A agonists reduce activity and functional connectivity within higher-order networks such as the DMN, an effect that correlates with subjective ego-dissolution. Concurrently, these agents increase global brain connectivity and strengthen functional coupling between lower-order sensorimotor regions and higher-order areas, producing a "flattening" of hierarchical topography. EEG information‑theoretic analyses suggest a shift in effective connectivity: reduced top-down constraint from frontal regions and increased influence from lower-order centro-posterior areas. The paper links these two evidence streams by proposing that 5-HT2A agonists could weaken pathological higher-order somatic priors and enhance bottom-up sensory signalling, thereby reducing abnormal self-representation and the maladaptive influence of cognition on sensorimotor function. The authors note experiential effects commonly reported with these drugs—hallucinations, synaesthesia and ego dissolution—which they interpret as consistent with the described neural dynamics. They also acknowledge safety and ethical concerns related to the hallucinogenic properties and argue these may be mitigated within controlled clinical settings. The extracted text does not report quantitative effect sizes or clinical trial data demonstrating efficacy of 5-HT2A agonists in FNDs.
Discussion
Bryson and colleagues interpret the converging cellular, neurophysiological and imaging evidence as supporting the plausibility of 5-HT2A agonists as a novel therapeutic approach for FNDs. They argue that these agents target the two processes central to leading models of FND: (1) abnormal self-representation, through diminished activity and connectivity within networks subserving self-related cognition, and (2) pathological top-down constraint over sensorimotor processing, through enhancement of bottom-up connectivity and reduced frontal-to-posterior influence. Positioning their argument relative to earlier research, the authors note that the neuroimaging correlates of ego dissolution and the observed reversal of hierarchical brain dynamics under 5-HT2A agonists provide a mechanistic bridge to the Bayesian and neurobiological models of FND. On this basis they propose that transient perturbation of brain network dynamics by intermittent dosing could weaken excessively precise priors and increase the salience of sensory evidence, producing clinical benefit. The paper acknowledges key uncertainties and limitations: there is no direct clinical trial evidence for efficacy in FNDs reported in the extracted text, and the therapeutic hypothesis rests on mechanistic inference from disparate literatures. Ethical and safety concerns associated with the hallucinogenic effects are recognised, and the authors recommend mitigation via controlled settings. For future research they recommend a carefully designed clinical study in a well-defined, homogeneous patient cohort (for example, refractory functional hemiparesis without psychiatric comorbidity) combined with best-practice physiotherapy and psychotherapy, using intermittent dosing schedules modelled on existing depression trials. The authors state that such a trial would test whether transient perturbation of network activity produces superior symptom recovery compared with non‑drug controls.
View full paper sections
INTRODUCTION
Functional neurological disorders (FNDs) are a common condition that exist on the borderland of neurology and psychiatry. They tend to be poorly managed and there are few proven therapeutic options. Most leading theoretic models implicate an impairment of somatic self-representation in their psychopathology. 5-HT 2A agonists have recently emerged as a plausible adjunct therapy for major depression, anxiety, and drug addiction. Use of these agents was first predicated on observed clinical benefit, and imaging studies have begun to unravel the neural basis of their psychoactive effects. Based on current understanding of FND pathophysiology and the effects of 5-HT 2A agonists on brain function, we argue there is a convergence of evidence to support their use in the management of this condition.
FNDS: CLINICAL BACKGROUND
FNDs are defined by the appearance of neurological symptoms without underlying structural pathology. These symptoms may take varied forms including hemiparesis, visual impairment, or movement disorders. Their nomenclature has undergone historical change and encompasses terms including hysteria, psychogenic movement disorder, and conversion disorder. FNDs are distinct from feigning or malingering as they are considered a psychiatric condition and the patient's complaint is not consciously produced. Although psychiatric comorbidity is associated with FNDs it is neither necessary nor sufficient for onset. Diagnosis of an FND relies on normal neurological investigations and characteristic inconsistencies in the clinical examination. Diverting attention from the affected body part, for example, often leads to symptom improvement. Unfortunately treatment options are limited, prognosis is unfavorable, and clinicians have historically adopted a distrustful attitude toward these patients. Psychotherapy is typically offered but there is minimal evidence for benefit. Physiotherapy may assist with recovery of motor manifestations. FNDs account for a substantial proportion of patients referred to specialty medical clinics and pose a significant burden on both the individual and healthcare system. Incurred costs and impact on quality of life are comparable with "organic" neurological disease.
FNDS: PATHOPHYSIOLOGY
Some insight into the neuropathology of FNDs has been gained through functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) and behavioral studies. Findings related to motor agency, selfmonitoring, and self-representation are of particular relevance to theoretic models. Patients with functional motor symptoms experience a loss of volitional control, or agency, over a body part. The perception of motor agency is thought to emerge from an internal matching of task prediction to task outcome and involves recruitment of the right temporo-parietal junction. Reduced activation of this region in patients with FNDs, and normal activation in subjects who feign weakness, suggests a discrepancy between movement intention and realization. An impairment of motor conceptualization or initiation appears present, perhaps due to other disruptive cognitive processes. Both patients and individuals at high risk for developing FNDs show a tendency to divert attentional resources onto the self. Behavioural studies in these groups demonstrate heightened body vigilance, an inclination to experience perceptually ambiguous sensory stimuli, and a preoccupation with somatic symptoms. Neuroimaging findings support this observation, with increased fMRI activity observed within the ventromedial prefrontal cortex, precuneus and insula. These regions comprise nodes of the brain's default mode network (DMN) and subserve introspective cognitive functions including somatic self-representation and the retrieval of self-imagery.
FNDS: THEORETIC MODELS
These findings lay experimental grounding for a leading neurobiological model of FNDs. This model contends that aberrant somatic self-representation, perhaps induced through heightened self-monitoring, exerts excessive influence over normal motor function. Abnormal DMN and supplementary motor cortex activity may reflect neural correlates of these psychological changes. A mismatch between intended and realized motor function accounts for a perceived loss of self-agency and the observed changes in temporo-parietal junction activation. Traditionally the mechanism of dissociation, defined as a disruption of normally integrated psychological functions including body representation and motor control, has been thought to underlie FNDs (American Psychiatric Association, 2013). This model argues for a discrete loss of integrated somatoform function and is consistent with the notion of dissociation. The precipitating reasons for developing an FND remain unclear, although personality factors and maladaptive processing of traumatic life events may play a role. The neurobiological model is also compatible with a Bayesian formulation of FNDs. This computational theory asserts that the brain generates our experience of reality through predictive representations of the self and environment (priors), which are compared and updated against somatic and exteroceptive sensory input, forming posteriors. Emergence of an excessively precise prior may generate a fixed representation that manifests as a functional symptom. This theory accounts for the worsening of symptoms when patients attend to their affected body part: the abnormal prior is strengthened through attentional focus. It also provides explanatory basis for a "jumping to conclusions" bias found during probabilistic reasoning and a susceptibility to the placebo effect. Both phenomena reflect a tendency to favor internal priors over conflicting external evidence. Central to both the neurobiological and Bayesian models is a disturbance of the normal cognitive hierarchy: lower-order sensori-motor function is disrupted by higher-order cognitive processes. One may speculate, therefore, that
SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT
Functional neurological disorders are a common neuropsychiatric condition. We argue there is converging evidence to suggest a role for 5HT 2A agonists in their management. This hypothesis is supported by neuroimaging and behavioural findings, and is of significance given the current lack of treatment options. an intervention capable of disrupting both hierarchical brain dynamics and self-representation could confer a therapeutic benefit. 5-HT 2A agonists appear to impact both processes and emerge as a plausible candidate. We shall first consider the effect of these agents on neural activity at a cellular and network level and, based on these findings, argue for their potential use in FNDs. The 5-Ht 2A Receptor: Single Neurons and Neural Circuits Serotonin (5-hydroxytryptamine or 5-HT) modulates cortical function via widely projecting axons acting on a diversity of receptor subtypes. The 5-HT 2A and 5-HT 1A receptors exert the greatest influence over cortical function. The 5-HT 2A receptor is largely responsible for the psychoactive effect of psychedelic compounds such as psilocybin. Activation of the 5-HT 2A receptor promotes neuron excitability through membrane depolarization and increased action potential probability. There is strong expression of this receptor on excitatory pyramidal cells across most cortical layers, and it has a subcellular distribution favoring proximal apical dendrites, perhaps conferring a role to enhance synaptic input. Expression is weaker in GABAergic interneurons, with the notable exception of parvalbuminpositive subtypes. The 5-HT 2A receptor is found across most macroscopic cortical regions; however, greatest densities have been observed within the prefrontal cortex and association areasThe impact of 5-HT 2A agonists on network function within cortical circuits is incompletely understood. Increased firing rates and spontaneous excitatory postsynaptic potentials have been observed in slice recordings of pyramidal cells. . These neurons form long range cortico-cortical and cortico-thalamo-cortical projections mediating neural information flow between brain regions. 5-HT 2A agonists may also enhance the power of gamma-frequency local field potential recordings, possibly due to enhanced synchrony within populations of parvalbumin-positive interneurons. This frequency band is thought to promote the dynamic binding of neural activity between brain regions. Neuroimaging and electroencephalogram (EEG) studies provide support for a role in enhancing long-range information flow and provide a glimpse into the macroscopic dynamics induced by these agents.
-HT 2A AGONISTS: NEUROIMAGING AND EEG STUDIES
Subjects receiving 5-HT 2A agonists report a range of experiential phenomena. Most common are hallucinations, synesthesia, and ego dissolution: the experience of a diminished sense of self;. The neural correlates of these psychoactive effects have been explored with fMRI and EEG. Under resting conditions, macroscopic functional brain networks display a modular and hierarchical topography. Connectivity within a distinct network tends to be dense, forming a module, whereas connectivity between modules is sparse. 5-HT 2A agonists induce a reduction in fMRI activity and functional connectivity within higher-order modules including the DMN. The magnitude of these changes correlates with the intensity of ego dissolution, consistent with the role of these regions in sustaining self-related cognition. Concurrently, 5-HT 2A agonists increase global brain connectivity by increasing functional connectivity between lower and higher-order modules. This produces a flattening of the brain's hierarchical topography. Lower-order sensori-motor and association cortex, in particular, develop robust functional connectivity with higher-order modules. Information theoretic analyses performed on EEG recordings have revealed specific changes in neural dynamics that extend these fMRI findings. Neural activity recorded from higher-order frontal brain regions appears to exert less constraint over activity within lower-order centro-posterior regions. Conversely, activity within lower-order regions has greater influence over higher-order areas. This represents a reversal of normal hierarchical brain dynamics. It may also provide a mechanistic explanation for intrusive sensory experiences and feelings of loss of separation from the environment: sensory information is allowed to seep across functional boundaries. 5-Ht 2A Agonists: A Novel Therapy for Functional Neurological Disorders? These findings have a compelling application to FNDs. 5-HT 2A agonists appear to modulate the two processes of central importance to theoretic models: self-representation and the influence of higher-order cognitive processes upon lower-order sensorimotor function. Firstly, these agents diminish fMRI activity and functional connectivity within networks subserving self-related cognitive processing. The experience of ego dissolution, a measure of integrated self-representation, substantiates this neuroimaging finding. This would be anticipated to weaken an abnormal somatic representation underlying functional symptoms. 5-HT 2A agonists also enhance functional connectivity between hierarchical brain networks, and the influence of neural activity from lower-order upon higher-order regions. In effect, higher-order constraints are removed, and unregulated neural activity within sensori-motor and association cortex is observed. Synesthetic and intrusive sensory experiences support this empirical finding. More importantly, it may resolve a pathological influence of the mind over the body, leading to an improvement of symptoms. A benefit is also apparent when considering FNDs from a Bayesian perspective. In this framework, the brain generates experiences of reality through a balance of top-down and bottom-up input. 5-HT 2A agonists suppress the former by diminishing the influence of higher-order brain regions, and enhance the latter by promoting connectivity and neural information flow originating from lower-order regions. According to the Bayesian model, this would be expected to weaken abnormally precise higher-order representations and increase the salience of sensory input. A functional symptom may therefore be alleviated.
SUMMARY AND FUTURE DIRECTIONS
There is strong interest in the therapeutic potential of 5-HT 2A agonists in mood disorders and drug addiction. The use of these agents was first predicated on promising case reports; however, clinical and experimental evidence to support their use is now accumulating. Based on the known impact of these agents on brain activity and our current understanding of FND neuropathology, these agents appear particularly suited for the management of this condition. This may be of considerable importance given the current lack of treatment options available. Studies utilizing 5-HT 2A agonists raise legitimate ethical and safety concerns due to risks associated with their hallucinogenic properties. These may be mitigated in a controlled environment. We see a need for a study examining a carefully selected and homogeneous patient cohort, such as refractory functional hemiparesis in the absence of psychiatric comorbidity, in conjunction with best-practice treatment including physiotherapy and psychotherapy. Intermittent dosing schedules similar to existing trials in depression could be employed. The study hypothesis would be that use of 5-HT 2A agonists to transiently perturb brain network activity would enhance symptom recovery relative to a non-drug patient control group.
Full Text PDF
Study Details
- Study Typemeta
- Populationhumans
- Characteristicscommentary
- Journal