3,4-Methylenedioxymethamphetamine facilitates fear extinction learning
This rodent study appraises the psychotherapeutic gains facilitated by MDMA and investigates its effects on fear extinction learning, which is a key process in exposure-based therapies for PTSD. The authors propose that MDMA improves fear memory extinction via a BDNF-dependent mechanism. The study highlighted the potential of MDMA as a useful adjunct to exposure-based therapies for PTSD and other anxiety disorders marked by altered fear learning.
Authors
- Andero, R.
- Howell, L. L.
- Ressler, K. J.
Published
Abstract
AbstractAcutely administered 3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine (MDMA, ‘ecstasy’) has been proposed to have long-term positive effects on post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms when combined with psychotherapy. No preclinical data support a mechanistic basis for these claims. Given the persistent nature of psychotherapeutic gains facilitated by MDMA, we hypothesized that MDMA improves fear extinction learning, a key process in exposure-based therapies for PTSD. In these experiments, mice were first exposed to cued fear conditioning and treated with drug vehicle or MDMA before extinction training 2 days later. MDMA was administered systemically and also directly targeted to brain structures known to contribute to extinction. In addition to behavioral measures of extinction, changes in mRNA levels of brain-derived neurotrophic factor (Bdnf) and Fos were measured after MDMA treatment and extinction. MDMA (7.8 mg kg−1) persistently and robustly enhanced long-term extinction when administered before extinction training. MDMA increased the expression of Fos in the amygdala and medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC), whereas increases in Bdnf expression were observed only in the amygdala after extinction training. Extinction enhancements were recapitulated when MDMA (1 μg) was infused directly into the basolateral complex of the amygdala (BLA), and enhancement was abolished when BDNF signaling was inhibited before extinction. These findings suggest that MDMA enhances fear memory extinction through a BDNF-dependent mechanism, and that MDMA may be a useful adjunct to exposure-based therapies for PTSD and other anxiety disorders characterized by altered fear learning.
Research Summary of '3,4-Methylenedioxymethamphetamine facilitates fear extinction learning'
Methods
The experiments were performed in male C57BL/6 mice (10–16 weeks old) bred at the Yerkes National Primate Research Center. Mice were group-housed with ad libitum food and water under a 07:00–21:00 light cycle. All procedures were conducted during the light phase (0900–1700 hours) and were approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee; they followed National Institutes of Health guidelines. The behavioural paradigm involved cued fear conditioning followed by extinction training two days later. Mice received either vehicle or 3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine (MDMA) before extinction training. MDMA was administered systemically at specified doses (examples reported in the extracted text include 7.8 mg kg-1 and 5.6 mg kg-1) and also delivered by central infusion to discrete brain regions implicated in extinction, including the basolateral complex of the amygdala (BLA) and the infralimbic cortex (IL). In some experiments BDNF signalling in the BLA was inhibited before extinction to test its role in MDMA's effects. Outcomes included behavioural measures of conditioned freezing during extinction training and subsequent extinction testing (including testing in a novel context), and molecular measures: mRNA levels of brain-derived neurotrophic factor (Bdnf) and the activity marker Fos in the amygdala and medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC). The extracted text does not clearly report sample sizes, exact conditioning parameters (number/timing of CS–US pairings in each experiment), nor full procedural detail for the BDNF inhibition method. Statistical analyses were performed using SPSS and GraphPad Prism. Analyses reported in the extracted text included one-tailed t-tests, one- and two-way ANOVAs, repeated-measures ANOVAs (α = 0.05), with Dunnett's test for dose–response post hoc comparisons and Bonferroni's test for other post hoc comparisons. Quantitative PCR data were compared against saline-treated controls using t-tests. Data are presented as mean ± s.e., and Bartlett's test was used to assess equality of variances.
Results
R. and colleagues report that systemic administration of MDMA before extinction training produced persistent and robust enhancement of long-term extinction of conditioned fear. A systemic dose cited in the extracted text (7.8 mg kg-1) given prior to extinction training reduced conditioned freezing at subsequent extinction tests, and these reductions persisted for several days and generalized to a novel context in which the conditioned stimulus (CS) was presented. Molecular measures showed increased expression of the immediate early gene Fos in both the amygdala and the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) following MDMA treatment and extinction. Increases in Bdnf mRNA were observed specifically in the amygdala, but only when MDMA administration was combined with extinction training; MDMA alone did not produce the same amygdala Bdnf increase. The extracted text notes that earlier work observed mPFC Bdnf increases at 24 h after a different MDMA dose, but such changes were not seen here at the time points sampled. Direct infusion of MDMA into the basolateral amygdala (1 μg) reproduced the extinction-enhancing effects seen with systemic MDMA. Infusions into the infralimbic cortex (IL) also enhanced extinction, whereas infusions into adjacent regions did not. Critically, blocking BDNF signalling in the BLA abolished the extinction enhancement produced by systemic MDMA, indicating that BDNF signalling in the BLA is necessary for MDMA's effect on extinction in these experiments. The authors also report that some reductions in freezing observed during extinction training—particularly early reductions in freezing after MDMA—are likely attributable to MDMA's psychostimulant effects rather than to enhanced extinction acquisition per se. For example, a systemic dose of 5.6 mg kg-1 and central infusions of MDMA both altered freezing during testing and increased locomotor behaviour during the same period. Nonetheless, long-term extinction enhancements (including reduced freezing in a novel context) were observed even when immediate reductions in freezing during training were not required, supporting a lasting effect on extinction memory rather than a transient performance effect. The extracted text does not present numerical sample sizes, effect sizes, confidence intervals or p-values for these findings, nor does it give detailed time-course data beyond qualitative descriptions.
Discussion
The authors interpret their findings as evidence that acute MDMA administered prior to extinction training enhances fear extinction learning via a mechanism that requires activity-dependent BDNF signalling in the amygdala. They emphasise that MDMA must be present during extinction training to produce the observed long-term enhancements, because MDMA combined with extinction—but not MDMA administered after training—led to increased Bdnf expression in the amygdala and to persistent reductions in conditioned fear. R. and colleagues position these results as a possible mechanistic basis for clinical observations that MDMA-assisted psychotherapy can produce long-lasting alleviation of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms. They note that MDMA's acute pharmacology—robust, rapid increases in extracellular serotonin and norepinephrine via reverse transport, and interactions with 5-HT2A receptors—could plausibly engage activity-dependent processes that upregulate BDNF and consolidate extinction memory. They contrast the rapid monoamine release produced by MDMA with the slower effects of chronic selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor regimens, which can increase BDNF only after prolonged treatment. The authors acknowledge uncertainties and limitations. They state that, given MDMA's broad neuropharmacology, it is difficult to specify precisely how it increases extinction learning and Bdnf expression. They note differences from prior reports (for example, a previous observation of increased mPFC Bdnf 24 h after MDMA) and suggest that some BDNF-related changes may occur at time points not sampled in their assays. They also discuss the potential confound of MDMA's stimulant effects on immediate freezing measures, arguing that short-term reductions in freezing do not fully account for the long-term extinction enhancement. Finally, they highlight safety concerns—MDMA's abuse liability and potential neurotoxicity—and recommend isolating the specific pharmacological mechanisms responsible for extinction enhancement to develop safer therapeutic agents. The authors conclude that their preclinical data support further clinical investigation of MDMA as an adjunct to exposure-based therapies, given the role of impaired activity-dependent BDNF release in extinction-learning deficits observed in PTSD.
Conclusion
R. and colleagues conclude that MDMA facilitates fear extinction learning in mice in a manner that depends on BDNF signalling in the basolateral amygdala. MDMA must be on-board during extinction training to induce enhancements, which are long-lasting and generalise to novel contexts. These preclinical findings provide a mechanistic rationale for further clinical study of MDMA as an adjunct to exposure-based therapies for PTSD, while underscoring the need to clarify the underlying pharmacology and to address safety concerns.
View full paper sections
METHODS
C57BL/6 mice were from the Jackson Laboratory (Bar Harbor, ME, USA) and bred at the Yerkes National Primate Research Center at the Emory University. Mice were group-housed in ventilated cages and maintained on ad libitum food and water. Lights in the vivarium were turned on at 0700 hours and turned off at 2100 hours. All experiments were performed on 10-to 16-week-old male mice. Studies were performed during the lighton phase, with experiments taking place between 0900 and 1700 hours. Studies were in accordance with the National Institutes of Health guidelines, and all procedures were approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee at the Emory University.
RESULTS
Behavioral data were analyzed with SPSS 22.0 (IBM, Armonk, NY, USA) and Prism 5.0 (GraphPad, La Jolla, CA, USA) using a one-tailed t-test, one-or two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) or a repeated-measures ANOVA with α = 0.05. Post hoc ANOVA comparisons were made using Dunnett's test for dose-response data and Bonferroni's test for all other data. Data for quantitative PCR were compared against saline-treated controls and analyzed with a t-test. Data in figures are presented as mean ± s.e. The data variance was similar between the groups compared in each statistical analysis using Bartlett's test for equal variances.
CONCLUSION
Few, if any, pharmacological treatments alleviate the recurrent and intrusive traumatic memories characteristic of PTSD. Given the long-lasting alleviation of PTSD symptoms following MDMAassisted psychotherapy, we asked whether MDMA has an effect on extinction learning.We demonstrate here that MDMA facilitates fear extinction and neurobiological processes associated with extinction learning. Specifically, MDMA treatment before extinction training induced long-term reductions in conditioned fear that persisted even when the fear-eliciting stimulus was presented in a novel context. Directly infusing MDMA into the IL or BLA, but not into adjacent regions, also enhanced extinction. Extinction enhancement by MDMA coincided with increased markers of neuronal activity in the amygdala and mPFC, as well as increased expression of Bdnf in the amygdala. Disrupting BDNF signaling in the BLA completely abolished MDMA's effect on extinction. Together, these data demonstrate that MDMA enhances fear extinction learning in a BDNF-dependent manner. MDMA facilitated the extinction of conditioned fear whether animals were initially conditioned with either a single CS-US pairing or multiple CS-US pairings. Several manipulations fail to conserve their effects on fear learning when tested across different fear-conditioning protocols, as single and multiple CS-US training paradigms appear to engage unique profiles of neurobiological mechanisms.Here, we demonstrate that MDMA reduced conditioned freezing during extinction testing overall. In the multiple CS-US-trained animals, conditioned freezing was most significantly reduced during the final five CS tones of extinction testing, suggesting that MDMA increases the capacity of extinction. Interestingly, reductions in freezing during extinction training did not appear to be necessary for MDMA's long-term effects on extinction. Whereas MDMA robustly reduced conditioned freezing during the first half of extinction training of multiple CS-US pairings, we believe these reductions to be attributable to MDMA's psychostimulant properties.Central infusion of MDMA or a systemically administered dose of 5.6mg kg -1 both reduced freezing during extinction testing without affecting freezing during extinction training. In addition, the same dose of MDMA that reduced conditioned freezing during extinction training also increased locomotor behavior across the same period of time. Our hypothesis that reductions in freezing are due to MDMA's psychostimulant properties, and not to an effect on extinction acquisition, is consistent with previous research demonstrating that stimulants can robustly reduce conditioned freezing during extinction training without maintaining that effect during later testing.Reductions in conditioned freezing were not only observed the day after treatment and extinction, but for several days afterward. Most strikingly, reductions in conditioned freezing also persisted when the CS tone was presented in an unfamiliar context. Typically, re-exposure to the CS tone in a new context renews the fear response to the CS.Ablation of fear renewal in a novel context typically requires massive extinction protocols or extinction training in multiple contexts.That a similar context generalization was observed following a less intensive extinction paradigm demonstrates that MDMA induces a powerful form of extinction learning potentially translatable to more complex circumstances in human PTSD patients. Our results inform clinical studies by suggesting that MDMA must be on-board during extinction training to induce extinction enhancements. This appears to be due to an effect between MDMA and activity-dependent processes in the amygdala that drive subsequent BDNF signaling important for consolidation. BDNF signaling is a crucial molecular signature of several forms of learning.Treatments that increase BDNF signaling enhance extinction learning,whereas treatments that impair BDNF signaling impair it.We observed that MDMA administration increases Bdnf expression in the amygdala only when combined with extinction training. The effect of combined MDMA and extinction training on Bdnf expression may explain why posttraining MDMA administration did not induce the same extinction enhancements as pre-training administration. Extinctiondependent increases in Bdnf mRNA induced by MDMA suggest that its effect on extinction is a learning phenomenon. This is consistent with reports that BDNF is required in the BLA for consolidation of extinction memory,and that chronically administered selective-serotonin reuptake inhibitors reduce conditioned fear only when combined with extinction training.Acutely administered MDMA (10 mg kg -1 ) has been previously observed to increase Bdnf expression in the mPFC 24 h later.Although we did not observe such changes here, BDNF in the IL is known to facilitate fear conditioning.Therefore, other unobserved MDMA-induced changes in BDNF signaling that also contribute to extinction enhancement may occur at a later time. Many extinction-induced increases in BDNF are observed after 2 h in a variety of brain regions.However, our observation that disrupting BDNF signaling in the BLA abolished the effect of systemically administered MDMA underscores the importance of BDNF in the BLA. Given the wide variety of MDMA's neuropharmacological effects, it is difficult to speculate on how it might rapidly increase extinction learning and Bdnf expression. MDMA's primary effect is to release serotonin (5-HT) and norepinephrine (NE),which is essential to MDMA's acute behavioral effects.Increasing 5-HT and NE with reuptake inhibitors upregulates Bdnf expression, but only with chronic regimens.Similarly, only chronic regimens of 5-HT reuptake inhibitors enhance fear memory extinction.MDMA rapidly and powerfully increases extracellular monoamine levels by reverse transport,and therefore acute treatment may achieve increases in 5-HT and NE that typically require chronic administration of transporter inhibitors. MDMA also binds directly to 5-HT 2A receptors that have been observed to enhance fear memory extinctionand increase BDNF signaling.Given MDMA's combined abuse liability and neurotoxicity,it is important to isolate the pharmacological mechanisms through which MDMA enhances extinction in order to develop drugs with fewer risks. For a brief period beginning in the 1970s, MDMA was being explored as an adjunct to psychotherapy, primarily for inducing mildly altered states of consciousness with increased social/ empathic behaviors and reduced anxiety.Whereas the general pharmacology of MDMA's effects on subjective states have been explored, these have provided little information on how acute MDMA experiences induce long-lasting behavioral changes, such as those observed in PTSD patients treated with MDMA.Our observations suggest that MDMA enhances fear extinction learning in part by upregulating BDNF signaling in the amygdala. Further clinical studies of MDMA as an adjunct to exposure therapy should be explored, as impairments in activitydependent BDNF release contribute to extinction-learning deficits in PTSD.
Study Details
- Study Typeindividual
- Populationhumans
- Journal
- Compounds
- Topics